Another EliteTorrents Uploader Facing 10 Years in Prison
Written by enigmax on November 17, 2007The fallout from the FBI raid on EliteTorrents in 2005 continues, with a seventh defendant associated with the uploading of Star Wars Episode III facing the prospect of 10 years in prison coupled with a $500,000 fine.

Every few months it seems the FBI manages to come up with yet more people to charge in connection with Operation D-Elite - the joint ICE and FBI raids against the US-based BitTorrent tracker, EliteTorrents, in 2005.
Everyone charged so far has been accused of being involved in the uploading of Star Wars Episode III which, at the time, was a pre-release movie, carrying criminal implications for the uploaders under the Family Entertainment Copyright Act.
According to an announcement by Assistant Attorney General Alice S. Fisher of the Criminal Division and U.S. Attorney Patrick L. Meehan for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, a seventh defendant has pleaded guilty.
An Duc Do, aged 25, of Orlando, Florida, has pleaded guilty before U.S. District Judge Legrome D. Davis of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania on a two-count felony. He’s charged with conspiracy to commit criminal copyright infringement and criminal copyright infringement.
Do is the latest in a line of people pleading guilty in this operation against EliteTorrents. Previous guilty pleas and convictions include those of Scott McCausland, Grant Stanley, Sam Kuonen and Scott D. Harvanek.
In this copyright case tried in the criminal (rather than civil) legal domain, potential punishments are harsh. Do is facing up to 10 years in prison coupled with a fine of $500,000.
He will be sentenced on February 27th, 2008.
Previously: The Pirate Bay Laser Graffiti Tribute
Next: Mininova Hits The Million Torrent Uploads Mark





260 Responses
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 11 » Show All
Were the Usernames these guys used to upload named?
I didn’t go through all the comments btw, just a bunch of bickering, it was getting annoying.
Bwahaha, #171:
Europeans hating on America is a joke. America should have saved Jews and left the rest of you to your Vichy French fascists, Franco fascists and all your other Eurofascists and SS lovers.
You smug, insignificant, pathetic Europeans drone about “Corporate America, Inc.”, but the fact is you prefer fascism over democratic ideals every day of the week. You’d be saluting “Heil Hitler”, IN GERMAN, if Americans hadn’t come to save your sorry rear-ends.
With the fall of your buddies in the Soviet Union, America could be ruling Europe with an iron fist like ancient Rome, and there would be nothing you could do to stop us. The only reason we don’t rule you is the greatness of our nation and our people, unlike any other superpower in world history.
Get over your insecurities, inferiority complex and BDS (Bush Derangement Syndrome) pathologies.
(#4: “America is one nasty country to live in. Evil… pure evil this is. Thank god I don’t live in there.”
# 9: “What would that chimp Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and Co get then if they were brought to the court for crime against humanity? I just can’t take that scummy American way of whatever you might want to call it anymore. Stay away from the rest of the world ffs!”
#23: “America is a ***** up country. That’s for sure.”
#65: “U.S.A is the axis if evil now days”
#31: “another reason why we should nuke usa and no im not a muslim”
#142: “America makes people want to attack it and its allies.”
#171: “hey Adam, I know why you bring up WWII - because it was pretty much the last time you Americans did something right.”)
The rhetoric has confused me. But I’ll say this:
The inhabitants of the United States are not the ultimate cause of the world’s problems. I doubt that Europe and Asia can teach us much about civilization. Over the centuries, you’ve killed many many many many millions of people over there, and we haven’t done that here yet. We’re trying to avoid the mistakes that you have made.
[quote]You smug, insignificant, pathetic Europeans drone about “Corporate America, Inc.”, but the fact is you prefer fascism over democratic ideals every day of the week.[/quote]
You’re saying it’s a fact that I prefer fascism over “democratic ideals”?
Congratulations, you’ve lost the credibility you didn’t have in the first place when you lie. I’m an anarchist and deeply opposed to the American fascist government.
[quote]You’d be saluting “Heil Hitler”, IN GERMAN, if Americans hadn’t come to save your sorry rear-ends.[/quote]
It was the Soviets who did most of the German killing in WWII. Look it up sometime, or are you one of those Americans who thought they were the only one on the allied side in WWII?
[quote]With the fall of your buddies in the Soviet Union, [/quote]
When your pathetic rhetoric fails, turn to calling everyone else “evil commie mexican immigrant terrorist muslim europeans” :D
[quote]America could be ruling Europe with an iron fist like ancient Rome, and there would be nothing you could do to stop us.[/quote]
There’s no way you could do that if you tried.
[quote]The only reason we don’t rule you is the greatness of our nation and our people, unlike any other superpower in world history.[/quote]
Ahh, you’re a nationalistic idiot also :D
*cough* fascist *cough*
I am indeed very happy I don’t have to live in the land of fascism and imperialism that is America.
Why do Americans hate freedom? Because they can’t profit off it ;D
Mr. Hah, have you lived in the US? Do you speak from experience or ignorance?
Why do Americans hate freedom? Because they can’t profit off it
^^– That quote is awesome. I must make a t-shirt with that on it.
Ok.. So, would he then have been better off, just going to speilbergs house and steeling the actual film itself and raping his daughter while his at it.
MEMO
TO: Hah
FROM: United States of America
RE: “There’s no way you could do that if you tried.”
If you doubt whether the USA could take control of Europe with an “iron fist” in a wink, if it so chose, consider the following:
One Trident nuclear warhead packs 100,000 tons of explosive force. One Trident sub missile can carry up to 8 nuclear warheads. One U.S. sub can carry 24 Trident missiles. A couple dozen U.S. subs can launch over 4,000 nuclear warheads. All the USA would have to do is pick a date and hour, and Europe’s biggest 4,000 villages would be demolished in about one hour, quickly solving Europe’s big, bad capitalist problems for you and your anarchist soulmates. Of course, like WWII, 1 or 2 warheads would probably suffice, particularly for the French surrender monkeys.
BTW, there’s nothing, nothing you could do to stop this. What little military/nuclear might that Europe possesses (before it disarms) would be easily destroyed. The fact that you are living is simply due to the sheer goodwill of the United States of America, and for no other good reason.
With nuclear sub missiles, we wouldn’t even need to step foot on European soil.
If, on the other hand, the Soviet Union had not collapsed and was the only remaining superpower, rest assured that you would be cooking borsh or serving vodka for your Gulag masters, rather than writing anti-American missives and anarchism.
You should count your lucky stars that the USA is not a Soviet Union, otherwise you wouldn’t be using the Internet to buy james’ t-shirt.
LOL .. yeah right, US wouldn’t stand a chance against the sleeping giant of China. You think they’d put up with American shit.
[quote comment="217368"]You should count your lucky stars that the USA is not a Soviet Union, otherwise you wouldn’t be using the Internet to buy james’ t-shirt.[/quote]
Definitely the best quote in a long time, and so true at the same time.
Eurofascist,
your speeches about america, and against europe, are valid in that they show an opinion that no country escapes having flaws;
however, you are promoting your viewpoint so aggressively that it’s coming across as a Stephen Colbert-esque viewpoint, ie one which attempts to ridicule the victim, by posing as the victim and making aggressive, irrational, and outright obnoxious statements.
And this uploader? Yes, he broke the law. No, not all written laws are higher than the “spirit of the law”.
Yes, he and all other uploaders are something of heroes in the nonviolent opposition of short-sighted pseudo-capitalist greed. No, it is not a triumph that our only significant alternative is to commit immoral acts of theft, and deprivation to legitimate creators.
Finally, odds are zero that any normal uploader would receive the full prison sentence; because this guy is ~symbolic, he _might_ be made an example of, and c’mon, that’s legit!
I highly doubt that 20,000 highschool kids who upload a favorite album/movie or so are also going to be receiving the max fine!
So, let’s see… at $20,000 (mininum) per year for jail time, for 10 years is $200,000 and those numbers are way old, like 5 years!, so, you take THAT, plus all the time the FBI has spent, plus all the money spent that could have been better spent on other things… This is starting to like the drug policy folly - Lord help us all!
I guess it helps to have low friends in high places.
Please, Jules, China wouldn’t stand a chance against an American land, sea, air nuclear attack. The Chinese could retaliate with lead-painted Barbie dolls to cause harm to US.
Obviously, the disease of anti-Americanism is causing senility in Europeans, who whistfully hope for the freedom-loving Chinese goverment to protect them from America.
Pretty pathetic, Jules.
Crimson, when fanatical, anti-American hatred is the standard fare across Europe, it is clear that the continent has lost its way and collective minds.
When Europeans are so blinded with rage against a people who sacrificed so much life, limb and treasure for the safety and security of Europeans, it must be called out.
The mere argument about uploading bits of data can unleash the most venemous, virulent and obnoxious anti-American garbage that Europeans can write.
If it were not for America, Europeans wouldn’t have an Internet on which to bash it.
So, the greed of the corporations has turned this into america vs. the world.
I wouldn’t say I hate americans, but something has to be done within the country to fix the system. It’s just wrong.
And talking about nuclear war is just plain stupid. No-one can win a nuclear war and you all know it.
[quote comment="216274"][quote comment="216209"]
Spyware is spyware whether it states it does so and why or not. This is exactly the attitude that is wrong with closed software.
Perhaps you need to read my post again. What exactly has giving software away for free has to do with giving ALL your *products* away for free? That’s not what I claimed, go twist someone else’s words.
In most cases piracy isn’t eating away at anything, a downloaded copy does NOT equal a lost sale. You’re just being an ignorant cry baby.[/quote]
S: (n) spyware (computer software that obtains information from a user’s computer without the user’s knowledge or consent)
You’re continuing to completely miss the point here. I put the code in for one reason and one reason only, to get statistics on legal vs non-legal copies. Had I done this without full disclosure, yes it would have been ’spyware’.
Ok, so I read your post again. You write “Now isn’t it funny that there are loads of people (whole companies even) giving their software away for free and still make a pretty decent living off it?” - I’ll let people decide for themselves who’s the bigger idiot here. But you do come off sounding like some ignorant open-source everything hypocrite. And you definitely suggested that there are companies out there that gives away [all of their] software for free and still makes a pretty penny.
I do give away some applications for free, I charge for others. I open source some and I keep the source very secure in others. These are all conscious decicions with a lot of thought and method behind them.
At the end of the day I have to put petrol in my cars, put food on the table, pay bills and whatnot - these things are not free you know (or perhaps you don’t because your parents are still paying your way?).
If I make my money by selling MY intellectual property, either by way of a closed source secure application, open source community driven application or by me providing hourly consultations does not really make a difference here - we’re still trading in IP and the same goes for those knight-on-a-white-horse companies you mentioned above.
I’ll agree that in SOME cases piracy has no detrimental effect, but to say that in MOST cases it does not is just plain ignorant. In this case I have a DB full of proof that it obviously has had a negative impact on my earnings - with some 2852 users continually using my product without actually purchasing a (very affordable) license. Like I stated already (in my original post) though, all of those does not equal a lost sale, but some most certainly do (and yes, some have started out using the pirated version and later purchased a license - even though there are no-limit trial versions available for download).
As for being a cry baby, you think what you want, but calling me that after reading my posts clearly shows your lack of comprehension of the english language. I have in no sense of the word ‘cried’ about my lost revenue, I was simply pointing out that the good old defence “It’s a victimless crime” does not really apply.
Now, getting back to the issue at hand; I find it interesting how no-one has picked up on the fact that one of the charges against An Duc Do were “for the purpose of private financial gain, infringed the copyright of of a copyrighted work by distributing” - are you all OK with something like this? It’s one thing to share files, it’s a completely other to actively try to better your financial status by means of copyright infringement.[/quote]
First of all, end users don’t read EULAs so I’m willing to bet 99% aren’t aware of being spied uppon by you at all. (Where can we find this EULA BTW?)
Second of all, why not put in a mechanism to deactivate their unlicensed copy, then you’ll find out that none of them are willing cough up the cash.
Now if all of your users became aware of you spying tactics I’m willing to bet even most of those paying users won’t even continue to use it.
Thirdly, there are loads of companies that give away all their software for free. Yes I said *software*, not *products* as what you tried to twist my words into in your previous reply. And just FYI I use opensource exclusively, and not just to avoid crappy spyware from dickheads like yourself.
As for the rest of your nonsense, I can’t even be bothered to adress it. So why don’t you just dry your tears and get a real job instead?
For all you flagwaving Americans going on about the second world war:
Please do have a look at what your “I.G. Farben”, “U.S. Standard Oil” and “Union Banking Corporation” did in that war. And let’s not forget about your “Operation Gladio” afterwards.
Then you can come explain to us what we Europeans have to thank you for…
Eurofascist, I’ll give you that, you manage perfectly to come across as the embodiement of the proverbial American superiority complex and the nationalist delusions that come with it, a stance that has greatly helped to put your country where it is today in the world. Also, the mere fact you have to resort to its nuclear arsenal to get your point across speaks for itself.
But what is this pathetic point you’re fussing about, anyway? That America doesn’t rule the world by force, even though you could, because you’re way too nice and gentle for that? Dang, you must have a real small dick there, mate.
And by the way you’re takling, you couldn’t tell patriotism (love for ones own country)from a fascism (believing ones own country is superior to all others and has the natural right to rule over them), even if the latter jumped in your face and bit your nose off, if that hasn’t happened already.
A nation is just an invention of the human mind. A unit of organization.
Those who ascribe any more significance to a nation than that are silly.
There is no such thing as an “American”. There is no such thing as a “Frenchman”.
There are people who happen to live in America, and there are people who happen to live in France.
Now, political LEADERSHIP of a given nation, that is a different story.
And I would argue that human leadership has, by and large, sucked hardcore throughout history and across cultures and continents.
America has crap leadership presently. So do a lot of other nations in the world.
U know.. we shouldn’t be fighting like this. We should all unite as people who love P2P.
In that case, then we need to show the corrupt government that we won’t tollerate people being treated like this. Whether in America or China or wherever.
People should have a say in what the government does and the laws it inacts, not corporations.
The beauty of the internet is that we can unite like this.
Think about it.
#191, European Ignorance is bliss:
I’ll take a look at your pitiful attack on our gracious service to
humanity to save you Europeans from yourselves (again), after you take
a walk around the graves of the 400,000+ Americans who willingly gave up their lives for you and your progeny.
You’re comment is a great reason why we should have left you to your
SS benefactors so you could happily serve the German-Nazi corporate
empire.
There’s a real sickness in Europe and your love of fascism is at its heart.
#192, Bwahaha:
It is ONLY because a benevolent USA does NOT insist on a “natural right to rule” over Europeans that you live freely to spout off your vitriolics. We have the military and economic might to rule Europe, and to do so, with ease. Were they the sole world superpower, neither the Nazis or Soviets or Chinese Communists would give you a lick about Europe, other than to enslave your sorry rear-ends.
#193,slats:
America is more than a parcel of land, but an idea and ideal. Read the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. People are literally dying trying to get into this country because of that (easy to say, being half-Mexican). People aren’t dying trying to get into Denmark, France, Belgium or Russia.
[quote comment="215923"]I’m just curious what application Bittrucker is responsible for so I know to A) Not pay for it and B) Download a pirated copy of it for free if I already haven’t done so.
[/quote]
lol
I started to read the comments expecting a 20 or so count… then as my middle finger became fatigued at scrolling i used page down… then after 3 minutes of scrolling I arrived at this lame comment 8) :idea: :arrow: :mrgreen: :roll: :evil: :cry: :!: :?: 8O :x :|
The majority here should stand together as P2P mates….like it or not we’re all in this together, united, regardless of country, culture ETC…the fact that a mate of ours is going to be spending some pretty harsh time in jail for a white collar offense is terrible, and a travesty of justice. I am going to try and write my congressman here in the states. I don’t know if it will do any good, but at least I am trying to make a difference. Everyone can make a difference in some way by keeping a positive outlook. I’m serious.
Maybe we should lock up librarians for sharing movies…oh no! They share books and music too don’t they! OH GEEZ! SOME DO SOMETHING!!!
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [8] 9 10 11 » Show All
Responses are closed
All remaining responses will continue to be archived. Use the TorrentFreak forums if you want to discuss something.