There are a lot of folks who justify theft since they don’t like the price. I agree that buying a CD with one good song and a lot of garage music is ridiculous. However, there are usually ways to legally acquire JUST the good songs for a resaonable price. Even if there wasn’t, theft is never justified. I’m sure few like the price of a new car but that doesn’t justify theft. (Of course it’s almost trivial to steal music through the Internet with little chance of being caught while it’s considerably higher risk to steal a car.)

That said, I do approve of the ruling. I know that the industry is doing all it can to protect itself but this is no different than seeking damages from the post office/UPS/FedEx because they delivered a package whose contents are illegal. Although difficult, the sender and receiver are liable, not the delivery mechanism.