TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

File-Sharing Is Linked to Depression, Researchers Find

A new paper published by researchers at Missouri University of Science and Technology reveals that people with depressive symptoms are more avid file-sharers than those without them. The research in question was conducted among students whose connections to the campus network were monitored. Perhaps more worrying than the results themselves, the lead researcher suggests that it might be a good idea to monitor people’s file-sharing habits for use as a diagnostic tool.

sad pirateNearly every day we write about negative associations towards file-sharing, and today is no different. A new academic paper now reveals how file-sharing is linked to depressive symptoms.

The paper carries the self-explanatory title “Associating Depressive Symptoms in College Students with Internet Usage Using Real Internet Data” and will be published in an upcoming issue of IEEE Technology and Society Magazine.

In brief, the researchers monitored how 216 undergraduates at Missouri S&T used the campus network. They then linked these findings to the results of a self-rated depression scale (CES-D survey).

What they found was that the use of peer-to-peer octets, packets and duration is positively correlated with depressive symptoms. In other words, people who are “depressed” are more avid file-sharers than those who don’t show depressive symptoms.

According to lead researcher Dr. Sriram Chellappan, the findings are unique among their kind.

“The study is believed to be the first that uses actual Internet data, collected unobtrusively and anonymously, to associate Internet usage with signs of depression,” he told Psys. “Previous research on Internet usage has relied on surveys, which are ‘a far less accurate way’ of assessing how people use the Internet.”

It is unclear what the direction of the relation between depressive symptoms and file-sharing is. The MPAA and RIAA may use the results to claim that file-sharing is bad for your mental health, but this can’t be concluded from the current findings.

Aside from heavy P2P use, people with depressive symptoms also use online chat more, and spend more time sending email. HTTP traffic and streaming were not correlated to depressive symptoms.

As a category file-sharers are in good company as previous studies have linked depressive symptoms to online shopping, excessive online video viewing, social networking, online gambling, and excessive late-night Internet use.

Where things do get scary is when Dr. Sriram Chellappan suggests that it might be a good idea to develop applications that scan people’s Internet use for these risky behaviors.

“The software would be a cost-effective and an in-home tool that could proactively prompt users to seek medical help if their Internet usage patterns indicate possible depression. The software could also be installed on campus networks to notify counselors of students whose Internet usage patterns are indicative of depressive behavior,” he explains.

This goes a bit too far, and is also uncalled for as there is absolutely no evidence that even a decent percentage of all avid P2P users show depressive symptoms.

That a researcher even suggests this is baffling. Not everything has to be monitored and checked. Most people just want their monthly invoice from their ISP, not a complete mental health report. Or perhaps i’m just being far too negative…

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • pitch pine

    Huh, who’d a thunk it!

    • ViTALiTY

      Read it before. And that’s a damn great article.

      • pitch pine

        Yup! Glad I read it.

        • Anonymous

          my buddy’s sister-in-law made $18108 a month ago. she worrks on the internet and bought a $525400 condo. All she did was get blessed and put into action the instructions given on this website ===>> ?????? makecash-home.blogspot.com

        • Anonymous

          my roomate’s ex-wife brought home $19224 the previous month. she is making income on the internet and moved in a $491500 condo. All she did was get lucky and try the instructions laid out on this web page===>> ?????? http://Freelancerseeker.wordpress.com

        • Anonymous

          my friend’s aunt made $17398 the previous week. she is making income on the internet and bought a $578000 house. All she did was get lucky and try the steps written on this website===>> ?????? http://hiringfreelancers.blogspot.com

        • Anonymous

          my buddy’s mother go t paid $21508 the previous week. she is making money on the internet and bought a $386500 house. All she did was get fortunate and put into work the instructions explained on this web site===>> ?????? http://hiringfreelancers.blogspot.com

        • Anonymous

          my friend’s aunt made $17398 the previous week. she is making income on the internet and bought a $578000 house. All she did was get lucky and try the steps written on this website===>> ?????? http://hiringfreelancers.blogspot.com

      • John filestorage

         You need to learn the difference between a great article and a bought study.

        However I like the results. I will now go to a doctor and try to get some drugs to overcome my depressed state due to file sharing. To stop is not possible since I also suffer from Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD).

        • Bought_study

          How is the study bought, may i ask?

        • Anonymous

          I wander if massive unemployment and the whole financial situation worldwide has anything to do with depression and file sharing. If this is true, then the mpaa and riaa should just stop messing with the internet so we could get out of this huge financial problems, if they take this, ppl more likely will wake up and the outcome wont be pretty

        • defendant

           ” I will now go to a doctor and try to get some drugs to overcome my depressed state due to file sharing”

          I think the point was that people who have or are prone to depression tend to do more file sharing not that file sharing causes depression.

        • Anonymous

          I think people who file-share are depressed because of the things that are happening to the file-sharing world and the internet, not because of file-sharing itself. This study is complete bullshit.

        • Sigh…

           ”I think the point was that people who have or are prone to depression
          tend to do more file sharing not that file sharing causes depression.”

          I completely agree with you. The number of people failing to comprehend the article is worrisome too. As someone who suffers from depression for various reasons (like poor quality of life due to health problems which have me trapped at home) I can safely say the research is 100% correct.

      • Yep

        David Wong, man, that guy writes great stuff. Him and John Cheese or Cleese, whatever his last name is. Those articles are golden.

    • No1_2_u

      Dr. Sriram Chellappan is a retard trying to make a name for himself.

      “What they found was that the use of peer-to-peer octets, packets and duration is positively correlated with depressive symptoms. In other words, people who are “depressed” are more avid file-sharers than those who don’t show depressive symptoms.”

      (Occam’s razor) The simplest explanation is always the best; they are online in order to find something to pass the time & feel less depressed.

      My diagnosis of Dr. Chellappan is that he needs a radical cranial extraction from his rectal cavity stat! 

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OK7Y7PCSTJ27RCKZ2MGRSAYCTE NEIL

         ”The simplest explanation is always the best; they are online in order to
        find something to pass the time & feel less depressed” Yep that’s me…..

        • Xadamx

          me too

        • fuckcopyright

           agree

      • Sigh…

         ”(Occam’s razor) The simplest explanation is always the best; they are
        online in order to find something to pass the time & feel less
        depressed.”

        You do realize your stating exactly what this research shows right? People who are depressed are likely to do more file sharing. Why? Because it makes them feel better, at least for a little while (speaking form experience).

        • pitch pine

          He probably doesn’t.

    • Tanisha

       ok u stupid idiots doing the survey, I have been filesharing for maybe 12 years or more, am not depressed, and think u are full of shit. If u watched, this came out after bittorrent piracy linked to more music sales.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OK7Y7PCSTJ27RCKZ2MGRSAYCTE NEIL

         It’s about cause and effect – those depressed using the service, not those using the service getting depressed…..

        • pitch pine

          Quite.
          I wonder if the people who were quite anal about the definition of “service” in the other thread will show up here.

        • http://twitter.com/icanhazsake Ninja

           Oh good, I thought I was on track to suiciding! /joke

      • Guest

        Rule 1 of science: 1 case study does not disprove results found with scientific rigor. In short, your personal story doesn’t mean jack-shit to science.

        That said, what NEIL said is also a viable possibility.

        • BestGuess

          Depression includes feeling sluggish and hopeless, acheyness.  That shit’s all associated with…. sitting on your fucking ass.  Psychiatrist Dr. Gordon Warme wrote a book about Psychiatrists needing to legitimize their field of expertise with science.  I can see the technology dreamery of the psychiatrist who discovered the depression-internet link….He would install a technology thing so that your computer tells you to when seek help, and we will all read about his wonderful contribution to A Technology or B Science; maybe both!  It’s not his feild of study.  He get’s a quote in this article and likely others, but doesn’t prepare a bite for his findings or suggest embracing life and human interaction?  It wont happen because techies and doctors alike have long lists of why this is both stupid and not feasible, including legalities.

    • Nonof Urbiz

       A follow-up study will show that these students are depressed just because they couldn’t find the content they were looking for…

  • Andrew Lee

    ROFL!!! BULLSHIT!

  • http://twitter.com/binarymutant Christopher Lunsford

    then television is suicidal behavior

  • Kiran

    just about every file-sharer I know isn’t depressed, atleast on the outside, so Idk where these researchers got their data from

    • Guest

      To put this simply, you likely wouldn’t really be able to tell if they were depressed. Depression is rarely observable to the casual observer; you have to be looking for it. That’s just the nature of the disease.

      • pitch pine

        A man who is his own lawyer has a fool for a client. 

        Self-diagnosis, good way to go!

    • Anonymous

       Smart people are more likely to experience depression; file sharers tend to be smarter than average because it requires a certain level of problem-solving ability.

      Or, as the internet has been telling us for 30 years, “correlation doesn’t equal causation.”

    • Sigh…

      “just about every file-sharer I know isn’t depressed, atleast on the outside, so Idk where these researchers got their data from”

      That’s because Ernesto misinterpreted the research, then wrote a biased article that caused others to make the same mistake. The research doesn’t show all file sharers share because of depression. It also doesn’t say file sharing is the cause of depression. All it shows is that people who are ALREADY depressed are likely to do more sharing than their non-depressed counterparts. This makes it a good indicator for depression because all you have to do is identify people who share more than the norm. It’s not a guarantee there actually is depression, but it is a good starting point from a diagnostic point of view. That is why this study is valuable and has nothing to do with anti-piracy at all.

  • John Hooper

    Fags

    • Jessicafischerqueen

      Always a great thing to type, I never get tired of it. It says so much with just 4 characters, I find.

  • Unknown

    Umm… Quite enjoying life, not depressed at all I download/stream content because it’s easier and saves me the depressing walk to a rental store.

  • Anon1

    Yes, because 216 college students is certainly a large enough pool to draw conclusive “evidence” from. This is utter horseshit.

    • http://twitter.com/icanhazsake Ninja

       That. Sampling is kinda messed up.

    • Sigh…

       It’s amazing to watch Ernesto’s bias and confusion spread like wild fire among the populace here lol. He clearly didn’t understand the research (or at least part of it), which explains why he didn’t understand statements made in relation to it either.

      Once again this has nothing to do with anti-piracy. It’s not saying depression causes file sharing. It’s not saying that all file sharers share because they’re depressed either. It only shows that people who are already depressed, for any reason, are likely to share more than the norm. The hypothesis is that this could make it easier to diagnose someone as having depression, something that, due to it’s very nature, is rarely ever clear. It’s not something easy to diagnose, like a rash for example. A lot of people who suffer from it don’t come forward to get help. More often than not friends and family don’t learn there is a problem until something bad happens as a direct result of it.

  • Student

    Maybe because the less well off are fire shares for obvious reasons thereby having a greater amount of stress is due to financial limitations or problems, so stress and file sharing are correlated but one is not the cause of the other.

  • http://Not.Telling/ Kr0nZ

    bald people wear hats, therefore all hat-wearers must be bald

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OK7Y7PCSTJ27RCKZ2MGRSAYCTE NEIL

      Yep – you got the cause and effect correct – love the sarcasm….!!

      BTW love your graphic!!!

  • anon

    so, more intelligent people are more likely to be depressed? that isn’t news

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OK7Y7PCSTJ27RCKZ2MGRSAYCTE NEIL

      That got used a heap by my councillors – LOL!! Used to say I was only really like this ‘cos I got it – wereas others were too dumb to know….

  • Marvin
  • DarkCanuck

    File sharing saves me time so I can spend more time with family & friends.  I work in medicine and am 100% certain I’m not depressed.

  • Guest

    Well, yeah.

    Depressed people tend to deeply bury themselves in distractions like entertainment, social media, etc. as a form of escapism. I thought this was common knowledge?

    So of course they’re the ones who fileshare the *absolute* most. They’ve got the highest need to consume entertainment. 

    As for Dr. Sriram Chellappan’s suggestion, he can go fucking fuck himself. A surveillance state isn’t the answer is any situation.

    • Guest

      *in any situation

    • SooooSaaad

      I’m so depressed that I don’t share anymore

      I just leech (and I can’t even cap lock on posts) 

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKUAroimQrk

    • Leecher

      I think the real depressed people are the ones you see in forums seeding new stuff everyday. They doesn’t seem to talk much. Doing what they do day in day out 365 days. It’s quite an incredible feat. Theyre the true heros of our filesharing community imo. kudos to them! :)

    • blah

      Maybe we should install a camera in his bathroom, just in case he feels like slashing his wrists?

  • http://twitter.com/meekcritic Meek Critic

     If anyone from the entertainment industry is reading this, this is what I propose: 

    For a one time small fee of $25 Million I can create a program that will do the following:

    Keep track of downstream and upstream speeds and if the speed crosses 100kB/s (this can be customizable) an alert box will popup on the computer and a siren noise will sound.  The alert box will inform the user that the PC will automatically shut down in 2 minutes if the 100kB/s threshold continues to be exceeded.

    If the PC is automatically shut down, a large alert box will appear upon reboot.  This alert box will list several help lines along with a number to an RIAA or MPAA sponsored call center. 

    If this type of automatic shut down happens 3 times (this number can also be customizable) then ransomware malware – http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ransomware_%28malware%29 – will be installed on the PC and the only way to unlock the PC would be to call the RIAA/MPAA call centre and obtain a code, for a one time fee of $99.

    Everyone says that the **AA is heartless, but together we can create something beautiful that will obliterate file sharing (and any other type of activity that requires significant bandwidth) and cure the world of depression.

    • Waer

      rofl

    • Anonymous

       Sounds like a modest proposal to me.

  • Krosis
  • Pirate

    Why would making the RIAA and MPAA shit their pants on a daily basis make me depressed?

    • http://twitter.com/TPBGirl TPBGirl ™

      ^^^ Thats it in a nutshell! ^^^

      Or living and going to school in Missouri could be depressing enough. Ya neva know! ;)

  • http://pogue972.blogspot.com/ pogue972

    This is great news.  If the RIAA ever sues me for file sharing I’ll claim I’m mentally unfit to stand trial.

    • oh well

      And the RIAA’s suit will be dismissed because their profit loss is all delusional and they’re suffering from schizophrenia

      • Guest

        This is an insult to the schizophrenics.

  • Picard

    Not a problem. Torrent prozac, calibrate monitors for zombie mode, download scanning plugin.

  • anon

    lets not forget the coders of the sites they can get very depressed also or are very depressed. some spend 12 to 18 hours a day at the pc coding. most people on sites i have been on that are on all the time do have some issues of some sort or are on meds

    • Chell

      Isn’t that what happenned with Bill Gates.. Spent nearly every waking moment writing code.. and about 15 or so years later becomes a billionaire.. follow your passion.

  • http://twitter.com/MarkGisleson Mark Gisleson

    1. What percentage of the nonfilesharing online community is depressed?
    2. Is it possible that the online community is more depressed as a whole?
    3. Isn’t depression a sane response to insane times? And isn’t the online community more aware of current events than those who don’t go online?

    I’m betting that if you polled people smoking outside of office buildings, you’d find they were more anti-govt. regulation than the population at large. This strikes me as a correlation, not causation. We are living in the Golden Age of Apples and Oranges.

    • jack murdock

      I think a lot of the online community is depressed.

  • Great school u av there

    undergraduates at Missouri.

    1. Feeling down..
    2. Away from home.
    3. lonely , missing loved ones.
    4. No expendable money.
    5. plenty of spare time after school.

    So fileshare to get content , to pass the time while on campus…….Seems legit.
    FFS only No.4 + No.5 are a prerequisite for more filesharing.

    BUT wtf conclusions ,can you invent from that ?
    My conclusion is ….. Missouri University is a depressing place to be !

     

  • PB

    I’m not surprised these students are depressed with all the underhand, scheming and corruption reported on file sharing issues over the past few years

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Zack-Nelson/1287355169 Zack Nelson

    I really need to speak up here.

    I have depressive episodes, and I do seed some Linux ISOs and check up on news about copyright, digital liberties, hacking, and information technology in general. Aside from my job and college course work, I really don’t have anything else to do.

    From my experience, I’m guessing that people with depression have lots and lots of time on their hands, and have no idea what to do with it all. While I can do lots of cool stuff with computers, I’m not sure what to do with my skills (I live in America’s I.T. deadzone). I can’t help but think that there are other file-sharers who are also in my position in life. I know these are mere first world problems, but it just happens to be relevant to the discussion.

    The only thing I don’t like about this University study is the recommendation that a “diagnostic tool” monitors other people’s file sharing habits, or at least being monitored by unnatural persons.

    • SuperEgo

      Zack.  Are you computer generated or a real human being? 

      Maybe posting on a blog like TF is social.  Maybe? 

      I use VPN to hide my IP address. 
      I use fake email ID’s. 
      I am anonymous. 

      But posting here is FUN. 
      And TF is actually like the 75th rated blog on the planet. 

      I enjoy the interaction here. 
      I also screen my phone calls. 

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Zack-Nelson/1287355169 Zack Nelson

        I’m an actual human being, and yes being on the internet is fun (I wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t, I’ve posted on TorrentFreak in the past). I’m just saying that I can personally relate to this study. There are many others who do, and many others who don’t.

        I’m not saying that people on the internet need to get a life, nor am I saying that piracy has an adverse effect on your mental health. I’m just agreeing with the study (save for the recommended course of action).

        • Picard

          Damnit zack.  You had one job. It was all good until you said the p word.  Before today I had yet to see a pirate bay logo in somones facebook profile pic.  What’s the relation? If their isn’t any, why did you just call file sharing piracy?

        • Guest

          Picard:

          People just call filesharing piracy. The words are synomous to many people, with no difference in meaning or implication.. Get off your high horse and evaluate what he said, not the exact words he used to say it.

        • SuperEgo

          Group “Planetary” Hug to ZACK! 

          Zack … You Da Man! 

          Go Zack Go 
          Go Zack Go 
          Go Zack Go 

          You are GOOD.  You Don’t Do Evil. 
          (Like the asshole(s) whom F’D-up TPB) 

          Zack Good. 
          (Wet Pussy Cold Beer Good Also)

        • Deal with it or it will

          Lifestyle and experience….. Zack ( you said it )

          Experience something new….. anything…(just not downers)

          Randomly change your lifestyle…. ( eg.. get up an hour early EVERY morning and go to a coffee shop , join a club on a subject you hate etc…)

          Lifestyle and experience….. Zack

    • Sharing is …

       ”I have depressive episodes”

      Now where’s the torrent?

  • JDFWP

    JUST DON’T FUCK WITH PORN

  • No1_2_u

    This is depressing news…LMAO!

  • Anon

    Researchers have found that most bullshit that is spread around the globe is infact other researchers research.

    • radioman

      damn stupid depressive research ;} well you known scientists forget to eat, and become bullshit talking zombies

      • you are scienceMan

        that your excuse ? : )

  • Ahnon

    I think this study is interesting. I spend alot of time on the internet/computer and would consider myself as having mild dysthemia. Its difficult to tell which came first, but I think this study highlights the issues that plague many internet/computer users.
    It seems to make sense that the more time one spends online (whether downloading or not), since you are (for one thing) also reducing your degree of social interaction. Social interaction has been found to be important for overall mood, but again, depressed people do not want to socially interact, so difficult to tell what comes first.

    It is in this context that I don’t think study is very comprehensive because it may not be internet use/file sharing per se linked to depression, but other factors associated with internet use that are associate to the depressive symptoms (such as reduced social interactions, reduced physical activity, etc.).

  • Revolt101213

    to usa –   Monitor this: this is bullshits and go fuck yourself and die and don’t download porn from TPB because you all will be blind :D

  • http://mineshafter.appspot.com/ download13

    Are they proposing any sort of direct causal link? All I can see for this is an possible indirect link. In this case, depressed people may be more likely to eschew human contact for time spent on the computer and people who spend more time on a computer may be more likely to share files.

    The overlap between those groups could show a correlation, but unless the correlation was nearly linear, the suggestion that this information should be used as a diagnostic tool (especially when you consider the invasion of privacy) is ridiculous.

  • http://www.twitter.com/echoman74 echoman

    Oh hell naw LMFAO HOLY SHIT :p
    Depression seriously? The only thing that makes me depressed is how out of touch and totally delusional that this study could publicly be announced!! Aswell as the industries making up these delusional studies and then telling the government how 2.2 million invisible people who are losing jobs in the “creative industry”. OK EVERYONE TIME TO GO TO DOWNLOADERS ANONYMOUS!!!

  • townie2

    sounds like another excuse to monitor people’s internet. “we were just checking to see if he was depressed by checking for copyright violated material”, lol.

  • Noone

    Speaking as a diagnosed depressive & an avid file sharer, I have to call bullshit.

    File sharing is one of the few things left in my life that keeps me “connected” to a world I can no longer take part in due to my illness, its not a cause nor is it a cure but it certainly helps.

  • Bert

    Absolutely, positively, fundamentally fucking ridiculous topic. So you’re depressed if you file-share and chat but not if you share and stream video? Retarded. The people behind this need to be raped by a large animal with horns.

  • Bert

    I’m in the process of mailing a large steamy cow turd to the offices of the people behind this study. The can put it on the shelf next to this ground-breaking study. Fucking coons.

  • Jmda91

    I have my personal reasons to be depressed, and its not becuase of file sharing, i mean SHARING IS CARING right?! this is blasphemy >…>

  • Anon

    A few things should be considered to keep this in perspective.
    1). Researchers will do anything to suggest some useful application of their work. If you find some tenuous link to internet use and depression, you just do a bit of creative thinking and come up with monitoring internet usage to find depression (actually if they ran a blind trial where they actually did that, you’d have an interesting study). Considering these researchers want to find social impacts of technology it’s not at all worrying or surprising that they have some madcap application.
    2). This sort of study is always a tad dubious because they get a load of data then mine it for “statistically significant” conclusions. Come up with enough hypotheses, and some will be statistically significant.
    3). As flawed as that sort of data mining study is, it is better than anecdotal rebuttals.

    But it’s a pretty weak study, so who cares?

  • Anonymous

    Thank God for online PORN!  It balances everything out.  I feel depressed cuz I shared an MP3. (insert random porn site here)

  • Anonymous

    Who comes up with this bullshit anyway?

  • MutherFucker

    How many FileSharers DID NOT call ther MOTHERS on Mother’s Day? 

    HOW MANY !!!!!

  • Roger
  • http://fightcopyrighttrolls.com/ SJD

    Even if a single student from the sample was a victim of copyright trolls, he would have enough depression to hijack any correlation.

  • Guest

    buying a dvd is bad for my
    mental health as i have no money to buy my pills and food and pay the bills

  • Pingback: Abmahnwahn 2.0 - allumfassend - Seite 462 - netzwelt.de Forum

  • Truetrue

    makes sense.. every time i read about the stupidity and arrogance of copyright trolls, i get a bit more depressed.

  • Guest

    did you know if you download a pirate movie you and you pc will get ads 
    its ture make you pc wares a Condom lol

    • Anonymous

      If you play Sony Music CDs, you get an automatic rootkit STD!

  • Hi

    So people who are depressed are more likely to engage in more advanced Internet usage than just browsing websites, who would have thought?

  • Guest
  • Master

    How much did the MAFIAA pay them to do this study?

    • http://twitter.com/TPBGirl TPBGirl ™

      It has to show up on somebody’s expense report sooner or later ;)

  • Guest

    Speaking from personal experience, my file-sharing has increased dramatically over the last few years, and I have had problems with depression. My general lack of interest in anything led me to download a large amount of tv shows and games to simply distract myself and try to find something that interests me.

  • http://www.facebook.com/orphicdragon Trisha Lynn Dragon

    Oh dear God the stupid here is terminal. 

    I don’t understand why they are calling it a study. There is absolutely nothing valid here. He didn’t even attempt to address the obvious MASSIVE problem, whereby depressed people often lack social interactions and cash. It’s invalid and worthless because you cannot ascertain if the depression lead to the file sharing or if file sharing lead to depression. 

    Lets face it, if you have friends, lovers and cash you are less likely to be depressed and sittin’ your fat ass on the couch watching downloaded episodes of Code Monkey and Game of Thrones. 

    ….

    Code Monkey like Fritos
    Code Monkey like Tab and Mountain Dew
    Code Monkey very simple man
    With big warm fuzzy secret heart:
    Code Monkey like you
    Code Monkey like you

    *cough*

    just sayin’

    • Anonymous

      I think you win one internets for that lucid and succinct analysis.

      Combine it with the fact that the heavy internet-user also gets a lot more depressing facts pushed into his face on a daily basis which the ordinary John Doe avoids since he only ever reads the funny pages in the daily paper and I think we have a very hard case to make that “file-sharing” doesn’t really have any direct link to mental states.

  • Anonymous

    This paper must be a technologist’s joke. First the paper is published through scribd.com … not very convincing, then check the abstract of the paper.

    Already the abstract tells me this is genuine technologist’s ingenious humor :)

    • Derp

      Except, if you read, you will see that it will be “published in an upcoming issue of IEEE Technology and Society Magazine.”

  • http://twitter.com/TPBGirl TPBGirl ™

    Plead temporary insanity due to depression, have proof from doctor. Drugs made downloading habits worse being that I was heavily medicated (doc’s fault) and didnt know what I was doing.

    I am sooo calling my doctor. Get it documented now, use in court later against MPAA. Free drugs to boot. Yep, works for me. Thank you Missouri! :))

    • Guest

      I don’t think that defense has been legal since the Twinkie defense.

  • Mandtao

    Quite clearly this Sriram is just a paid hack masquerading as science. Of all the stupid nonsense. He should wear a badge “For hire will hypothesise anything for a research grant”. In some ways it ought to be mandatory on any published study where the original source of funding came from, and similarly when studies are quoted. It might start to get rid of the proliferation of “cigarettes are good for you” bullshit science.

  • Guest

    dam i will kill my self now i am so depressed about all them free stuff online

  • fghzstxj

    if you play video games to much you may get depressed
    if you watch tv to much you may get depressed

    but if do this with other people and not by you self you may be ok 

  • Vincent Giannell

    Good idea? more like bad idea to be monitored.

  • Alcohol

    Wow!
    The root of my depression was filesharing. Now that the cause is known, I will no longer visit the psychiatrist and save a heck lot of money. Right now onwards I am unnstalling my torrent client and deleting $15000 worth of “free software’. Wait, I am disconnecting from the internet permanently so that …………………………………….

  • Pas Antho

    post hoc ergo propter hoc. It seems from this article that Depression is linked more with internet usage than file sharing. The effect of greater file sharing is explainable by the positive correlation between internet usage and file sharing.

    • Anonymous

      I think you are correct. Heavy internet usage generally means you end up reading a lot more in-depth articles on various horrid facts which just don’t get published in the daily papers.

  • A.E.

    An amateur logical fallacy: correlation does not imply causation.

    http://www.env-econ.net/2012/05/more-on-baseball-and-climate-change.html

  • john doe

    They don’t know what causes what.

    I guess filesharing is not the cause, it’s the cure!

    Maybe people go fileshare to forget their problems and feel better.

  • Desu1

    Herp derp. It’s an outlet for basement dwellers. Why do you think Sweden is so big into piracy? Pretty much the whole country are basement dwellers. Can’t blame them. If I lived there I wouldn’t want to go outside either. 

    • Anonymous

      It’s no worse than any other country in terms of climate.

      But it is true that swedes are seen as the archetypical geeks of the nordics.

      That said we don’t hold the record in filesharers with a mere 20% estimated. China beats us hands down with an estimated 62% of their online community being filesharers.

  • Denis Avashurov

    I’m wondering, do they just randomly checking correlations? They should try checking the correlation between file sharing and IQ, to understand the relation to depression better. Checking correlation between shopping and depression wouldn’t hurt ether. 

    • blah

      There should be a study to see if there’s a correlation between psychology 
      researchers and spurious claims. The control group should be a bunch of lobotomized monkeys. I predict that the monkeys would fling far less shit about than the psychologists.

    • Anonymous

      Or, generally speaking, ask the question “How much time do you spend on the internet, looking at depressing facts which didn’t make it into big media?”

  • SUPERVEGITOYeh

    everybody depressed recession bullshit theres enough money on the earth to protect us from and incoming asteroid loling hahaha who cares live free are die trying

  • SUPERVEGITOYeh

    IF it wherent for sharing or looking after each other weed all be fucked even though it fucks us all off

  • madheadBANGer666

    Ok.
    I download at least 4GB and share at least 5 GB every day.
    I’m helping people to get what they love.
    I’m doing some kind of humanitarian job.
    So, i’m not depressed but happy……
    Researchers aren’t always right. Sometimes, you’ve to trust on yourself.

  • Pingback: === popurls.com === popular today

  • Anonymous

    I’m depressed now!  But it would REALLY depress me to be secretely monitored. 

    • Anonymous

      Don’t come to Sweden, in that case. The EFF branded us the most government-monitored citizenry in the western world in 2006. And after that we also got the data retention directive…

  • Caveman

    hmm this article might be true. I can certainly verify that the more depressive I am, the more time I spend behind the internet. it becomes an alternative to real social life for me.

    • Anonymous

      I think you may be on to something. Generally speaking the more internet-savvy a person is the more likely he is to include filesharing in his habits.

      And internet-savvy people in general have many reasons to be depressed given the developments in later years.

      Personally I think this is yet another version of “Ignorance is bliss” rearing it’s head. The more time you spend on the internet the more likely you are to actually find horrible facts.

      Case in point: When deepwater horizon began leaking the news blew it up to massive proportions. Only on forums and on twitter feeds did anyone acknowledge that Shell has had an open pipeline in a river delta in sudan spilling similar daily quantities of crude oil over a densely populated area for twenty years. Of course, it mainly being african bushmen having their livestock killed and their crops poisoned it’s not “newsworthy” material. People who spend a lot of time on the internet in general would for reasons such as this easily become far more depressed, I’m thinking…

      • Andy P

        I agree.  If you want some daily scary facts about the world just visit http://www.dreamindemon.com  Maybe that’s where I get depressed. LOL.  

  • LOLLOL

    I must be one sad mofo

    mc dot tt

  • Pingback: GNC #766 BSD Blues | GNC Show Notes

  • Max Freakout

    Mental health diagnosis has been used as a political tool many times in the past, they even tried to say people who eat healthy food are mentally ill (‘orthorexia’):
    http://www.naturalnews.com/029098_orthorexia_mental_disorder.html

  • http://www.facebook.com/anette.thorsell Anette Thorsell

    Eh, maybe depressed people need some quick diversion and therefore download a lot of movies and such?! And since having problems with too little money is a common cause of worry and (DUH!) depression… well, this professor can surely figure this out.

  • Aquacello

    Maybe not complete bullshit, maybe just partial bullshit. 

    I think I can agree that a lot of avid pirates and filesharers are depressed, I known more than a few, in fact most everyone I know who torrents frequently is depressed, or shows signs of being easily and/or frequently depressed.

    However, to say that filesharing causes depression is a magical degree of idiocy. I think it much more likely that depressed people are more likely to fileshare. It makes sense doesn’t it?
    From both the emotional and intellectual standpoint. 

  • The Holy One

    File-sharing can also be linked to religious symptoms such as Kopimism

  • http://profiles.google.com/orfetheo Orfeas Theofanis

    It’s not exactly that file-sharing is linked to depression.
    Movies and tv shows are.
    People with depression do watch more tv and/or movies, and that’s why it’s linked to file-sharing too, cause if you watch 5 movies a day, you obviously can’t buy/rent all those.

  • http://twitter.com/Anime4PSP Anime 4 PSP

    Yes, let’s compare habits of 216 students and link them to habits of few billion people. Bullshit

  • Pingback: Les pirates, des dépressifs ? | Geekattitude

  • Pingback: File-Sharing Is Linked to Depression, Researchers Find | Best Seedbox

  • Anonymous

    lol, no way I dont believe that for a second! Not one second. No, where is my Xanax bottle?? uggh.    Privacy-People.tk

  • YARIGHT

    im so depressed i think ill download  ….lol ok ….i think i need to better my mental health and download more…use this study in canada and in 2006 you’d have to say that 11 million people are depressed?

    get a grip foolish people its about economy stupid….im not paying your crazy 30$ a music cdr they wanted we canucks to pay….

    • YARIGHT

      hrm maybe 30$ cdrs depress you too

  • Som3

    And i can’t find where waldo is wow what i  waste of research! Don’t believe this one bit! nice try!

  • Anonymous

    the first thing I learned in stats and psych 101 is that correlation does not mean causation

  • Pingback: File-Sharing Is Linked to Depression, Researchers Find | We R Pirates

  • Pingback: Uno studio americano collega il file-sharing alla depressione | PowerBlog.it

  • Pingback: NRK Lydverket » Fildelere er mer deprimerte

  • Bert

    Straight out of the Masturbation makes you go blind play book ?

    The motives of the teams lead Doggie ought to be placed under scrutiny :)

  • Guest

    Only happy people fileshare because they want to share the happiness.

  • O0mg

    this is just a other twisted way they have found to try to spy on our private life …. 

  • Sean

    File sharers are depressed because we don’t have enough money.  Isn’t that the reason why we download free media in the first place?

    • Guest

      So what, people who are depressed reach out to others and engage in sharing culture, isn’t that what helps them get better?

  • http://profiles.google.com/phrenytz Carlos Gomes

    I afraid that’s true.
    I ran a tracker a couple of years ago and the most active uploaders had a very similar profile.

  • http://www.1000niaz.com/ fun

    bbc.com…….. see

  • Anonymous

    I totally agree with Ernesto’s statements in the last two paragraphs.  I think this so-called “study” sounds like a crock.  I just looked up the Missouri University of Science and Technology.  According to US News and World Report, the school accepted 91% of its 2010 applicants, so I have to wonder about the academic rigor of a place where pretty much anybody gets accepted.  Then I have to wonder about this guy Dr. Sriram Chellappan, the writer of this study.  Plenty of academics, including those teaching at second-rate schools because they weren’t good enough to get a better appointment, are under a lot of pressure to publish, publish ANYTHING that has a scholarly twang to it, for the sake of tenure. A great many studies are based on manipulated and/or misleading evidence, which appears to be sorely lacking in this study.

  • fuckcopyright

    People who suffer from “lack of vagina” also tend to be more depressed than those people who suffer from “over abundance of vagina”.

  • Guest

    I share when I’m sad, that makes me feel better.

  • fuckcopyright

    Think about how many real street crimes are not committed  because people are using their PCs to share files. A mind occupied is less likely to do crimes against people. Robbery, rape, & general mayhem.

  • Still Kicking

    So leechers are what? Greedy Type A wanna be dictators? I share because my music collection means a lot to me and would not exist except for the generosity of others. If I can return something to others it makes my day.

  • Pingback: Il file sharing è sintomo di depressione? | Tecnologia | BlogLive.it

  • Brooke Landers

    The study is believed to be the first that uses actual Internet data, collected unobtrusively and anonymously.

    http://www.therespiratorytherapist.com/
     

  • Pingback: Friday Links (on Saturday) « A Clockwork Submarine

  • Anon

    Abstract: Depressed people seek solace in file sharing.
    .
    CONCLUSION: Lets bug peoples computers and use suspect data mining techniques to diagnose them with mental illnesses without their informed consent.
    .
    Love
    Raghavendra (Ka-ching) Kotikalapudi, Sriram (chll) Chellappan, Frances (Monies) Montgomery, Donald (Win) Wunsch
    and Karl (lulz) Lutzen
    Missouri University of Science and Technology
    ps,
    .
    Big Pharma & musak plz give me monies to fun my unbiased “research”.

  • Borharris1

    too funny …. what will they think of next 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dakota-Dube/1178206657 Dakota Dube

    well considering file sharers typically file share because of a lack of money for digital content, odds are there is a lack of money in general. what should have been the headline of this article is “STUDY FINDS LACK OF MONEY DEPRESSING.” since that is really all it is stating.

  • tonyj

    I don’t know if the researchers understand file-sharing habits. First you look for what you want, maybe several items, point and click and you’re on your way… out the door because I don’t have time to watch my downloads finish to completion.

  • Myrddin8453

    Depression IS linked to piracy.  Economic depression, that is.

    I download, because I can’t afford cable, let alone HBO.Hell it’s $60.00 per/month just for high speed internet.$130.00 if I got HBO & Cable.Doesn’t sound like much?

    $11.00 per/hour at 40 hours per week =  $440.00$440 taxed at 20% = $352.00$352 x 4 weeks = $1,408.00

    $721.00 per month, Mortgage on a house that is now worth half as much as I purchased it for.$100.00 per month approx. on Home Gas.$100.00 per month approx. on Electric.$400.00 per month approx, on Food (which is NOT a lot of food)$200.00 per month on Gasoline.(Luckily I own my own car)All that = $1521.00

    Hell, I DESERVE to download Game of Thrones after the way I’ve been raped.And continue to get…

    It makes me want to cry…

  • No

    we beat off a lot too

  • ndmushroom

    The study is interesting, yet misleading. It offers a snapshot instead of a video. Let me explain: According to the study, they gathered a group of students, measured their level of depression, monitored their internet habits and then compared these two things, to draw statistical conclusions. Thus they concluded that people with higher levels of depression fileshare more.
    True. But what does this tells us about filesharing? Nothing. Filesharing could be the cause of the depression, but it could also be the remedy. I could hold a survey taking students’ temperatures and examining their medicine intake, and I think we can all safely assume that there is a strong link between higher body temperature and medicine intake. Not because people who take medicines catch a fever, but because people who catch a fever take medicines.
    A study on the same group of people, examining their internet habits and checking for changes in their levels of depression, would be most revealing. Until then the MAFIAA can use this research to claim that “piracy makes you depressed” and filesharers can use it to claim that “if you feel depressed, filesharing helps”. Both claims are equally unfounded.

  • Mel

    Depression? What is so ridiculous about “earning money by sharing” that they have to call it “sharing by depression”? Its easy money, simple as that.

  • Truth

    I believe the correlation would be the fact that lonelier people, who are more likely to spend their time at home, download as a means of “company.” 

  • http://www.nycitylimo.com/ Shari Clinton

    They then linked these findings to the results of a self-rated depression scale  .

  • Anonymous
  • Pingback: File-Sharing Is Linked to Depression, Researchers Find | Mediafire Search Engine

  • David Nix

    When I am clinically depressed I feel a much stronger urge than usual to be part of a group, in fact when I get well I am usually in the awkward situation of wanting to jettison the social groups I’ve joined when depressed, even though I’m sure their company helped me out of depression! (it’s like being 2 different people).  

    Perhaps heavy net users are doing the same thing on line, whether it works is another matter.

    I’ve read shrink advice that a depressed person should spend time with friends & family & not watch TV, perhaps the same is true of the net.

    In the end with the net or TV I think the problem is you’re dealing with a piece of metal, there’s nothing quite like “the warmth of assembled animal bodies”(Kafka). 

  • Pingback: Latest Depressive News | The Future Of Depression

  • Pingback: The Internet Habits of Depressed People - How I Beat Depression

  • Guest

    Pirated software makes U fat! 

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

  • Pirates Can Be Identified Despite Sharing IP Addresses, ISP Claims

    Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation is a network mechanism through which many Internet subscribers can share the...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.