TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

MediaDefender Walks The Plank to Bankruptcy

MediaDefender and parent company ArtistDirect have had some serious setbacks recently. Last September they suffered a huge security breach when internal emails and a phone call were leaked to BitTorrent. They received even more bad press recently for DDoSsing Revision3. As a result, MediaDefender’s parent company stock dropped from $2.00 down to just 16 cents.

mediadefender stockMediadefender has had a rough year, and the future isn’t looking much better. Last month, MediaDefender lost one of its larger customers. The business accounted for roughly 18% of MediaDefender’s revenues.

In a recent financial statement, the company stated that there is a decrease in interest for their anti-piracy services, and that the results of their p2p-advertising model are also disappointing. This news led to further decrease in the stock price, which was sitting at an all time low of just 16 cents this Monday.

Surprisingly enough, the company structurally fails to mention the email leak and security breach, which has cost them a significant amount of money. In September 2007, disaster struck. MediaDefender had made many enemies with its anti-p2p activities. One of them decided to teach the company a lesson by hacking into their systems and leaking their internal emails and closest secrets to the Internet. The effect on the company and its operations was dramatic.

In an interview with Portfolio, the hacker (using the pseudonym ‘Ethan’) explained how things led up to the leak. Ethan, a polite high-school student who lives with his family, was on his Christmas break when he first gained access to the anti-piracy company’s servers by exploiting a weakness in their firewall. This was at the end of 2006, at a time when business was still good for Media Defender with revenue standing at nearly $16m.

Soon after that Ethan got access to the company’s email, its networked resources and even its telephone system. Logging in a handful of times each month through the summer of 2007, he started to get bored with ‘Monkey Defenders’ – his pet name for the anti-piracy outfit. Deciding to go out with a bang, he and the Media Defender-Defenders gathered thousands of the company’s internal emails and published them on web.

Last November, MediaDefender said it lost $825,000 as a result of the leaked emails, and this amount has probably gone up significantly in the months after that. Its stock price is falling, and it’s beginning to look like the company won’t recover anytime soon. The Pirate Bay wished last year that MediaDefender would go bankrupt, and by the looks of it, they might just get what they hoped for…

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • berethend

    at long last.

  • Abhi

    hahaha mediadefender will die
    ALL HAIL TPB ……

  • HUH?
  • mu57i11

    slow news day me thinks

  • will

    what the hell #3 the piratebay are awesome whats wrong with them !

  • greylion

    @ #3
    You hope TPB dies with them?
    ..and exactly how do you imagine that happening?
    The case against TPB certainly doesn’t look like it’s going to be won by IFPI.
    Even if that was the outcome and TPB had to shut down in Sweden, they have servers in other countries, and wouldn’t have any problems setting up servers in just about all european countries.

    TPB is here for the long haul.

  • chad

    why isn’t anyone pressing charges on them for the DDoS attacks? This is illegal, and you can bet that nobody on “their side” is willing to let anything go that could be prosecuted? I hope someone presses charges to protect the rest of us from companies like this.

  • Lol

    I think #3, like myself is just tired with everyone boning TPB. Yes, they are successful; that’s good for them but TorrentFreak constantly praises them in alot of it’s news posting, infact atleast a good fifth of news content on torrentfreak usually mentions TPB. However TPB is just a small representation of the larger bit-torrent community. Personally I don’t hate TPB but I think the bias propaganda and visual representation of a site like TPB shouldnt be forced onto the readers here it as much as it is. We want bit-torrent news, not purely TPB news! lol =) Long live file sharing

  • #YLS#

    @ HUH? and Lol

    Well I understand your point that TPB are praised highly but there is a good reason.

    They work together with TorrentFreak and other organisations. The likes of Mininova and Isohunt are big torrent systems but they are mainly interested in advert profits, I’m not saying thats a terrible thing but there not running with the community in the same way as TPB.

    TPB is very individual, they host and track plus they allow 100% public usage even Demonoid has private restictions.

    TPB like to keep everyone in the loop, I am for one thankful they spend so much time being informative. How many torrent admins contribute to documentaries?

  • Dragus_Draak

    Yes best news i heard in months finally a victory file sharing hopefully we can stay on a roll.

  • pink panther

    Well, the celebration is tempered by remembering how long SCO has continued to operate without revenues or products or any sense of purpose or mission. They just never go away. Will MediaDefender be like that?

  • Pw

    They’re going to lose just like the rest of them, because genuine pirates aren’t in it for the money, they are.

  • Minimal

    @8

    WTF? ‘Tired of everyone boning TPB’? Is anyone else actually doing anything?

    It isn’t news bias if there’s no other vnews to report; no single torrent tracker is standing up and fighting for what they (we) believe in like the pirate bay are.

  • Anonymous

    Let’s get back on topic: MediaDefender is going down. Praise Jesus, karma is a bitch!

  • Anonymous

    Not yet bankrupt, but it should be soon, at least. I think that we should do more to make good things like this happen.

    There is a simple anonymous (i. e. no registration) discussion board for how people can take action, here:
    http://www.28chan.org/fs/

    And I think that simply by discussing, and forming a community, that we can actually make things happen.

  • RachelFaith

    Didn’t this story appear here on TorrentFreak about 3 months ago? Well either way it’s good news. They won’t be able to DDoS any legit companies anymore.

  • Mr Roboto

    TorrentFreak is a WEB BLOG not a fucking News site. This isn’t CNN. These are TorrentFreak’s opinions, if you are tired of them mentioning The Pirate Bay then go somewhere else. I’m seriously sick of people whining about the content here or saying stupid shit like “Must Be a Slow News Day”. Go to Reuters then if you want news.

  • Crynsos

    @8
    TPB is probably just often mentioned, because most special things happen around them, including their server raid, their /legal page, etc., and because they are one of the greatest, as well as the seemingly most community-active tracker/index site…

    Finally they really go the way to the end, even though I hoped and expected it to happen sooner… but now, that so many failures happened to them, bankruptcy is just inevitable…

  • asdfghjkjhgfdsa

    S_i_e_g h_e_i_l ALL PIRATES SHOULD D1E

  • seany

    #15, please stop spamming every thread with your shitty ‘board’!

  • #YLS#

    @ 19 – asdfghjkjhgfdsa

    all pointless losers please find a productive thing to do with your time.

    @ seany

    I’ll admit it irritates me too but he is still giving oppinions so it’s not totally spam.

  • Ibod Catooga

    I anally raped them!

  • Jeff

    @ 19:

    WOOP! WOOP! WOOP!

    “Anti Piracy troll detected off the
    starboard bow!”

    “Your orders, Captain?”

    “Fire cannons, mateys!”

  • Josh

    If I owned torrentfreak i’d stop comments.

    They are abused so much and spammed.

  • http://www.28chan.org/fs/

    @24
    Hmm…
    Well, what is the alternative?
    Just some silent postings?

    Discussion is a powerful thing in any case.

    @17
    It’s just a blog, isn’t it?

    In any case, perhaps you could start your own blog. It is not so difficult, is it?

    The more blogs and the more discussion/community about it, the better.

    @20
    Since when were blog entries called “threads”? I just think it is far easier to discuss things in a free-forum. And why would you call it “shitty” anyways? It’s a discussion board just like how we’re discussing things on the comments section of this blog.

  • Super Laser Gal

    now the sons of bitches just get your ISP to screw you over instead

    http:/ladysmooth.com/

  • http://www.28chan.org/fs/

    @26
    What?
    Are you talking about BPI?

  • kevl

    sucks all those people will lose their jobs but hopefully breaking in to all of these companies and fucking them up will make them stop trying to police the internet. use your resources to track down sex predators and kiddie porn, not the new Prince album and shit like that. believe me, Prince isn’t worth the effort.

  • Dante.Xaiver

    Lets break out the champagne keep up the good fight guys we are winning this battle

  • Izumi-sensei

    @29
    It’s not time to celebrate until the fight is over. Simply put, the commercial industry disgusts me to no end – they regard culture as something without meaning, only there to extract money from the people. Only when the law itself is changed will it be time to celebrate.

  • Dante.Xaiver

    ok then how about just time to smile haha

  • Izumi-sensei

    @31
    And also the time to consider how we can make happen a repeat of this.

  • One owner rider

    Well the cartels will next be demanding compensation for “lost time” and expenses incurred in fighting “piracy”. No doubt this will be reflected in even more outrageous claims against alleged file sharers and blanket claims against media device mfrs and the PC industry, with concurrent demands to integrate their trojans and cripple hardware.

    As a last measure they will seize assets and bomb the remains of all residences capable of owning a PC.

  • Anonymous

    They will make sure the occupants are at home at the time. Then later, not being satisfied with that, they will seek further compensation from relatives of the deceased, and demand incarceration for them also.

  • Anonymous

    @33 and 34
    Industry has the power to do that essentially because file-sharers really don’t seem to care about political power and changing the laws. If only people would get out there and start to vote.

  • http://neuron2neuron.blogspot.com Ben Jones

    or, anonymous, if they’d go out and join and help out the organisations that already exist. I know the US pirate party is crying out for help, as is the UK party. I’d guess others are too. They’re out there, but, as you said, they’re too lazy to actually DO anything about it.

  • Anonymous

    I mean, statements such as “if you vote out a corrupt politician who was bribed by the industry, then the person voted in would just be as corrupt. They make promises to change copyright law, and will break them” must be from the industry saying, “don’t bother trying to vote, because you’re powerless.”

    I am advising all of you not to be taken in by such claims as “voting is powerless, don’t even bother.” If you don’t do anything, then nothing will happen.

    I don’t understand what’s with the exaggerations and hyperboles like “all politicians are bought and corrupt” and making these wild links to Guantanamo Bay and tons of other unrelated stuff. I mean, that kind of nonsense is just stupid. Politicians are favoring industry not because they are given bribes, but rather because the industry is the only powerful voice speaking, and many people actually believe their propaganda.

    The fact is that the current public atmosphere is that in “cyber-ethics,” one should not do things like file-sharing. It is distributed everywhere, in schools and places like that, and many people believe it. There are many press releases detailing the “problem” of file-sharing. And there are a fair number of academics who say that copyright is necessary for an incentive to be creative. Finally, there is NO SIGNIFICANT VOICE against copyright. Either they are in their homes just pirating stuff, quietly minding their own business, or simply not caring enough to take political action. THIS is the reason why politicians favor copyright law. Not because of illegal bribery or giving of “gifts.” But because of the fact that industry cares enough to take action and to “educate” the public, while we don’t.

  • Anonymous

    @36

    Either way, it would be important to somehow take OVERT POLITICAL action. I mean, MediaDefender’s downfall might be nice and all, but how will it vote out a politician who favors copyright?

  • Anonymous

    All the time, I hear that copyright is a “non-controversial” issue. And non-controversial in what sense? Obviously that most people think that copyright is a good law that should stay in its current form, or be made “stronger.” The only disagreement is whether the current laws are “enough” or whether they should be made “stronger.” Why is it non-controversial? Because people on the other side aren’t taking action enough to start a controversy about it.

    Simply put, MediaDefender going bankrupt is no evidence of any controversy. It’s only evidence that industry seems them as not effective enough in eradicating the “problem” of piracy.

  • MD-watch

    Artistdirect’s stock price, now trading in the 15 to 20 cents/share range, has already dropped over 90% since the MediaDefender email leak. When the first quarter 2008 report gets released, probably in the next few weeks, we can further witness – and even gloat over – their continued financial hemorrhaging.

    It seems that unfortunately, few investors read Torrentfreak, or knew about MediaDefender’s massive email leak. Anyone who spent some time reading through the leaked company emails would have realized back in September that MediaDefender had damaged it’s reputation beyond repair, and would likely start seeing an exodus of its clients once their contracts were up.

    Like rats fleeing a sinking ship, the news that one more of MediaDefender’s major customers is leaving hardly comes as a surprise. “This is really fucked”, Randy Saaf once shrieked, and those words have since become prophetic as the company continues to sink deeper and deeper.

    It’s been fun watching the slow death of MediaDefender, the P2P saboteur company that founders Randy and Octavio spent eight years building up and is now going belly-up. Many of us predicted the company’s imminent demise when the email leak broke last September, a leak whose most damaging aspect was no doubt showing MediaDefender’s execs caught with their pants down lying to their RIAA & MPAA customers while fumbling their way chasing after the P2P scene. MediaDefender sold themselves as a digital-age Perry Mason, then the leaked emails revealed them to be more like the bumbling Inspector Clouseau.

    Saaf and co. have learned all too late that leaving a trail of incriminating internal emails, not only admitting to their company’s failures, but mocking one’s customers behind their backs, can be a very risky business practice.

    Will the ArtistDirect management turn around and sue Randy and Octavio? After all, they alone are the ones responsible for the company’s loss of customers. It’s primarily through their big mouths and behind-closed-doors (or so they thought) antics that they’ve run the name of MediaDefender into the ground.

    “Material Impairments” MediaDefender takes $25 million write-off
    http://biz.yahoo.com/e/080709/artd.ob8-k.html

    Artistdirect purchased MediaDefender in 2005 for $42.5 million, with $31 million of MediaDefender’s value being classified as “goodwill”. The term “goodwill” refers to a company’s non-material assets such as a strong brand name or good customer relations. The company has finally admitted that the $31 million figure was much too high, and announced plans to take a $25 million write-off.

    It’s a significant event when the company itself admits that the value of the Mediadefender “brand name” – its reputation in the industry and its trust among its clients – has dropped by a whopping 80%.

    With ArtistDirect unable to pay its debt and expressing doubts about the company’s future viability in its existing form, the company was in negotiations to sell off its operations. They’ve apparently failed to find any buyers yet, despite the substantial price they’ve paid a consulting firm to arrange a sale.

    (According to Investopedia.com, “Impairment charge” is the new term for writing off worthless “goodwill”.)
    http://www.investopedia.com/articles/analyst/110502.asp

  • jack_spratt

    Well, all users of P2P technology past, present and future owe ‘hacker ethan’ a great debt. It seems he took on this vile and deceitful enemy of justice virtually single-handedly, and served them a punishment that nobody else could give.

    I don’t think that exploiting internet security holes is a good principle to work or live by, but when most of the world is fooled into supporting the enemy, this sort of victory is pricelessly valuable to we, the persecuted few.

    And by the way, regarding TF comments: yes, they are sometimes abused, but I think that if anything needs to be done then old fashioned tighter moderation will suffice. The discussion on here, whilst not always fruitful, often proved a desperately needed medium of communication for our largely disunited group. Allowing people share and vent on here is a great service, in my opinion, and we should make the most of it. The comment situation here is a thousand times better than at youtube.com, for instance, and actually serves a purpose.

    Also, can people quit passive negative criticism of TF articles please, their reporting is generally of a very high standard, and to those that think its smart to jibe some analysis as being the product of ‘a slow day’: well fuck you, try providing a consistent community service as important as TF before you slight their site.

  • Kevin

    Lets just get rid of this pathetic company and start on the next. I will not rest until all of these anti-piracy companies are dead and gone, only to be read about in history books. That twat at BREIN should be dragged down the town street and drawn and quartered, not that I’d like to see.

  • Izumi-sensei

    @42
    It seems like we have a common interest then. My discussion board 28chan.org/fs/ is an easy way to communicate, but perhaps you could also use my e-mail, aworldwithoutsnowflakes@gmail.com if you are interested in speaking with me.

    As Andrew Jackson said, “it is killing me — OR I WILL KILL IT” – he was taking about the national bank, and his decision to get rid of it was foolish. But at least he had the virtue of acting on his beliefs, rather than passively bemoaning whatever discontents he has. Nothing good will happen if we complain “life sucks” and so on.

  • Jim Jones

    Soudns like someone was asleep at the helm for a long time there. Pretty sad indeed.

    JT
    Ultimate Anonymity

  • Groovesan

    You have not seen ultimata victory of this battle againsta anti-p2p spammers and data corrupters.

    You can say “the end” after The Pirate Bay community buys all Media Defender’s stocks and makes it P2P favour company after kicking some employees ;)

    There is no bankruptcy option available in IT-technology companies sector, they are always sold/integrated to other companies. As far TPB is not a company, just community it is safe of overtakers.

  • Anonymous

    if you have a bad business model, you sneak around bending rules or breaking laws, and people find out about it (i.e. the leaked emails), you will end up like media-defender. fcuk them

  • Andrew

    @15
    Fuck off spamming that link around. We saw it first time, vomitstench.

  • Snow Owl

    Good MD needs to hurry and go out of business it’s not as much a problem for me with torrents as it is ANYTHING ELSE. They have got standard p2p networks so corrupt hunting for a single mp3 takes a lot longer than just fetching the whole album anymore.

  • Red Alert

    16 cents… lols.

    Someone should paint in some visually representative images of ‘USS MediaDefender’ as it plots its course along that abyssal curve. :)

  • smile while they die

    MediaDefender is bad enough.
    But if I remember right. ArtistDirect
    the parent Co. Killed a handfull of p2p projects imesh, bearshare, and now are trying the same with shareaza.
    Thanks to sourgeforce for helping that fight.
    It maybe better they just linger on the vine. As some new scumbucket that would take its place would be as pesky as they once were.

  • RIP mediadefender

    Your ship is the one sank arrrrrrrrrrrr

  • Meocross

    Media Defender has been dealt 500,000$ damage by Ethan.

    Media Defender has been dealt 900,000$ damage by Ethan.

    Media Defender has been hit with Sue-ward by Rezzard Inc.

    Media Defender has been K.O’ed by the PirateBay.

    P W N T. Game over GudNite Suckers!

  • Jeff

    MD may be walking the plank to
    bankruptcy, but their servers used
    to DDoS p2p networks are alive and
    well, at least those that are
    hammering WinMX users with unwanted
    traffic at the rate of some 1800 hits
    per hour.

    The sooner they die, the better.

  • deardemonoid modchrist

    you are such a coward. cowards=worthless.

  • fuzzypig

    What a fecking shame! Ha ha!

  • Sana

    Walking the plank or not, my friend was just sent an email by Media Defender. If they are going down, they are going down and taking everyone door with them.

    My friend is really scared at the moment. Can’t blame her.

  • http://hackerblog.net Hacker

    I am sure all of us will deeply misss mediadefender </sarcasm>

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

  • Pirates Can Be Identified Despite Sharing IP Addresses, ISP Claims

    Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation is a network mechanism through which many Internet subscribers can share the...

  • Feds Seize Cash from Major Bitcoin Exchange’s Dwolla Account

    The U.S. Government has taken a significant action against the web’s top Bitcoin exchange by seizing...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.