TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

TorrentFreak Trolls a Copyright Troll

Prenda Law, one of the law firms involved in the ongoing mass-BitTorrent lawsuits in the US, is using a recent TorrentFreak article to threaten alleged BitTorrent downloaders. While we generally encourage people to promote our content, being used as a tool in extortion-type letters is not something we’re happy with. As a result we saw no other option than to troll the copyright troll.

trollIn recent years hundreds of thousands of BitTorrent users who allegedly shared films without the consent of copyright holders have been dragged to court in the US.

The aim of the copyright holders, or copyright trolls, is never to take any of the cases to trial.

Instead they want alleged infringers to pay a substantial cash settlement to make legal action go away. Some equal this scheme to extortion, but the copyright holders say they are merely protecting their work.

One of the most active law firms engaged in these mass-BitTorrent lawsuits, Prenda Law, is the topic of today’s article.

Prenda has filed numerous lawsuits on behalf of adult entertainment companies and is frequently accused of harassment-like practices once they obtain the identities of account holders. For example, the firm is known to call accused BitTorrent pirates at their homes, urging them to pay up.

While we have no problem with copyright holders protecting their content, outfits like Prenda cross the line of what is acceptable.

So, when we learned that the law firm is using one of our articles to threaten and scare Internet account holders we were not happy, to say the least. As might be expected from Prenda the letter in question references the most outrageous judgments, but without proper context.


Prenda’s letter (pdf)

Needless to say we had to respond. Here’s what we have done.

We redirected the URL referenced by Prenda to a page with information about these mass-BitTorrent lawsuits.

So, instead of being scared by an article about a $1.5 million judgment, Internet bill payers can inform themselves about the steps they can take to respond to the settlement letter.

The page in question explains that increasingly judges are condemning the practices of copyright trolls, and that many mass lawsuits have been thrown out. Just recently a judge designated Prenda’s ways as a “bad faith effort,” and dismissed one of their mass-BitTorrent lawsuits.

In addition to some much-needed balance we also included links to attorneys who are familiar with these lawsuits, plus links to other useful resources. Hopefully, this will enable a few of the victims to respond properly and resolve the matter without having to pay up.

Even if just one person reads it, it was totally worth the effort.

The original news article is still available and can be accessed here for the time being.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Guest

    motherfuckers.

    • tseuG

      Yeah, TF should have kept quiet about it. Now the mofos at Prenda Law will notice this sooner than I’d like. In order to troll properly one must not admit in doing so. :/

      • https://depthstrike.com/ Harold Feit

        They’ll re-do any further article Prenda changes the link to in the letters.

        • Le 9GAG ARMY XD

          Send them some email guize.

          http://wefightpiracy.com/contact.php

        • HUE LE LE LE HUE

          Open mp3 in text editor.
          Copy all
          Paste in comment.
          send
          FILL THEIR SERVER FULL OF PIRATED MATERIAL
          ?????????
          Profit

           
           

               ?
             ??
          Proxy up !

        • hikaricore

          A text editor wouldn’t really do it. You’d just see garbled machine code. A hex editor on the other hand… that would work nicely. ^_^

        • W00t

          Or you could just post a part of Twilight.
          Then you’d be torturing them at the same time.

        • WHY an Irrelevant smartass ?

          @hikaricore …….Text editor will do just fine
          Implying relevance of readability and format
          Implying it’s better for the reason at hand.
          Implying people give a fuck if all they see is “garbled machine code”
          Geez, they are pasting and posting it.

           
           
           
           
          Meanwhile ……… OVERLOOK, it’s actually possible.

        • Uklgvrf

          Plz everyone sign that email up for every spam sending magazine / website / service you can. I bet google can find some sites people warn others about NOT to sign up with. Those, we want for them.

        • Cdbxn

          Forgot to add the email. Btw, if they change it… It is visible if you view the source.

          accounts@wefightpiracy.com

        • Osdfj

          Oh and another one:
          resumes@wefightpiracy.com

      • Guest321

        I agree. TF should have kept quiet about it. It would have been successful trolling attempt if this news was shared at a later date. But now Prenda will simply change the URL and no damage is done.

        • Danny

          They’re going to change the URL on letters they have already sent?
          I somehow don’t think that’s possible?

      • Bananas

        sue them for unautorized use of copyrighted article.

    • JordanKratz

      IT Geeks find a way to release their scum for the World to see !

  • Phil

    This is awesome!

    • Horsey

      .????????????????
      ???????????????????????????????????.?????????????????????????????
      ??????????????????.?????????????????????????
      ???????????????????A???????????????????????w????????????????????????????????????e?????????????????????????????????s?????????????????????????????o???????????????????????????m????????????????????????????????e?????????????????????,??????????????????? ?????????????????????????????I?????????????????? ?????????????????????????????l???????????????????i??????????????????k?????????????????????????????????e?????????????? ??????????????????????????t?????????????????????????r???????????????????????????????????????o??????????????????????l?????????????????????????????????????l???????????????????????????????s??????????????????????????????.??????????????????????????.??????????????????????.?????????????????????????????
      ???????????????????????????????????.??????????????????????????????????
      ?????????????????.???????????????????????????????
      ???????????????????????????.???????????????????????????

    • LE 9GAG ARMY XD

      Send them a congratulatory pizza.

      Fur the Lolz XD

      • ScrewEwe2

        Reach Out to Us, 24/7

        At Prenda Law Inc., we pride ourselves on being available when you need us. If you need to speak with us at any time, please do not hesitate to call or email us for immediate assistance. We are available 24/7, nights and weekends at 1-800-380-0840.

        What if people were to tie up their 1-800 number 24/7, nights and weekends with nonsense calls?

        http://wefightpiracy.com/contact.php

        © 2012 Copyright 2011 Prenda Law Inc. All Rights Reserved.

        “You may reproduce materials available at this site for your own personal use and for non-commercial distribution. All copies must include the above copyright notice.”

        • Anon

          “What if people were to tie up their 1-800 number 24/7, nights and weekends with nonsense calls?”

          Many of the best minds on both sides of the aisle are trying to work out a position paper that respects privacy and protects property intended for sale. When this is the best you’ve got in the digital age, you lose. And you lose because you deserve to.

        • Asd

          You’re blind, anon. Go home.

  • Tomber

    Pwned

  • http://techfleece.com/ Richard Gailey

    Good job TF. As you say if it does inform/educate at least one person who has been targeted then it is totally worth it.
    You can see that they have thrown around some pretty big numbers, which would intimidate most people threatened, especially without having prior knowledge as to whom Prenda Law Inc are.

  • Arb1

    i like the idea of redirect people to info they need to know to deal with this.

  • Martin_monea

    man, erase this quick before they find out and simply erase that link, that way you can help more people
    if not then you´d have just helped a few guys and passed the chance for the sake of self publicity (not that i say that was your main intention)

    • http://fightcopyrighttrolls.com/ SJD

      The ransom letters are printed on paper: they can’t erase the link. A huge new batch has been recently sent out.

      • Masau Fuku

        Yeah, but they might notice the change sooner due to this article and change it before the next huge batch gets printed. Still, it’s awesome.

        • Moar trollllll

          Copy the letter.
          Email it to millions of email addresses.
          ??????
          Profit

  • Sabu Sake

    Steele is such a fucknut tool

  • http://fightcopyrighttrolls.com/ SJD

    Thank you guys! It is a hilarious (although not new) idea to troll those who hotlink. In this particular case it also may save a lot of anxiety and possibly money: most pay ransom in the first couple of days, out of pure irrational fear.

    Every delay, every day of research and thinking results in more knowledge about the scam and less desire to part with hard one’s earned money. I hope (moreover, I KNOW) that this little educational boost will do a lot of good!

    • ANoi

      Someone remembers Goatse…. or the gay black porn that used to be southern christian “god hates gays type” hotlinked images……. eh….. SJD

      Bait and switch never gets old with the right target.

      • xpmule

        Yup i vote for Goatse too
        ..the old Myg0t clan CS spray .jpg ;)

  • bob loblaw

    Don’t forget to exclude the Prenda Law domain from the redirect so their lawyers won’t notice that anything is wrong with the link.

    • Guest

      Too late for that, there’s already a post on the TorrentFreak homepage about the “troll” we play

      • Ophelia Millais

        Indeed. The copyright troll lawyers and members of the MAFIAA all read TorrentFreak, TechDirt, Ars Technica, you name it, so TorrentFreak really shouldn’t have said anything about the redirect. They should’ve just quietly redirected people until Prenda Law figured it out, which might’ve been never. But since TF had to toot their own horn, now the URL isn’t going to get printed on any more letters.

        TorrentFreak should gather some stats on that URL from their web server logs. How many hits did it get from real browsers, without referring URLs? That would give us a good idea of how many people actually typed in the URL by hand.

  • Vincent Giannell

    Payback time.

  • http://twitter.com/DieTrollDie DieTrollDie

    Love it! ;)

  • http://twitter.com/DieTrollDie DieTrollDie

    Love it! ;)

  • infogulch

    Unfortunately, I think just the url itself might scare many people.

    Also if you get it in a letter, do you really think that most people will type that horribly long url in by hand? I dunno.

    I think it’s great that you’re not letting them misrepresent your website for their questionable legal evasions, but I fear a lot of the damage is done before people even get there.

    • Guest

      They could of used tinyurl or some other site to shorten it but the title was meant for their evil ways.

      • http://twitter.com/EvanKnz Evan Kennedy

        Or a corresponding QR code

        • merethan

          QR code? Dude, they are still in 1995.

      • Gee

        but they didn’t, as you can see the url in the screenshot of the letter above

    • Guest321

      Exactly what I was thinking. I doubt anyone will take the time to type in a long URL from the letter. They will just read the URL and considering the headline of the news is already in the URL itself, it will freak most people out to just go for the settlement.

      • Danny

        If someone being faced with this kind of threat doesn’t even do research then they get what they deserve.

  • Silversurfer Surfer

    nice1 tf about time thay got trolled :>

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ender-Wiggin/100000885624281 Ender Wiggin

    well played tf, well played.

    • ANoi

      Stole the words right out of my mouth.
      Was gonna say the exact words.

      Well played indeed TF.

  • http://torrentfreak.com/ Rob8urcakes

    Here in the UK we have Rules of Behaviour as to how solicitors nay act and present themselves to any potential victim if they’re within our established legal system.

    There’s a formal complaint process and investigations take place to determine whether the solicitor acted fairly or not.

    I’d be very surprised if the USA didn’t have a similar type of complaints system in place – because that’s what I’d use against these evil, money-grabbing trolls.

    • Violated0

      Yes in the USA they have the State Bar which deals with standards, ethics and complaints and people should complain. I can’t say it says much about the US lawyer system that no action has been taken against these trolls yet and in general speculative invoicing.

      Since we are both in the UK I am sure you remember how back in January that Andrew Crossley of ACS:Law was justly punished by the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (part of the SRA) when he was suspended as a lawyer for 2 years and even then he will only be allowed back after he pays nearly £77,000 in legal costs.

      So it would indeed be a happy day when the USA cleans out their rodents and improves lawyer standards as a result.

      • Whatever

        Too bad he was allowed could claim ‘poverty’.

        Or did i miss something ?

    • ScrewEwe2

      solicitor: A petitioner who solicits contributions, trade or votes.
      solicitation: The act of enticing a person to do something wrong (as an offer of sex in return for money)

      I guess all our US politicians and the MAFIAA are all solicitors.

  • Pren-Duh Law

    Ohnono … it’s … Trololo!

    @#*%&!$ TorrentFreak!

  • The_Strawbear

    Fantastic TF, nice to see someone doing something practical.

  • waaminn

    Yeah you have got to admit thats some pretty cool stuff!

    http://www.Go-Anony.tk

  • U-95

    Well done, TF.

  • Guest

    Brilliant work, keep it up torrent freak. I wonder how long it will take them to realize.

  • Windlasher

    I know that address. How would they like a nice surprise visit from Guido & Vinnie. Kneecaps anyone?

  • Andrew Lee

    ROFL!! Shit almost forgot you should post a good list of VPNs and some tutorials on how to set them up. Just to make it burn a little bit more.

  • PRENDA-TROLLING

    I’m happy they can’t change the URL at first instance. #fail

  • Lulz

    Should have had the link redirected to gay porn.

    • http://fightcopyrighttrolls.com/ SJD

      Do we want to stoop lower than extortionists? That’s exactly what Prenda would do if we trade places. As a matter of fact, it has already happened not long time ago. When I wrote about a scumbag Steve Lightspeed (Prenda’s client and co-crook), I linked to “Arcadia Security” — a bogus forensic company at the heart of one of the Prenda’s most brazen extortion ploys. In less than a week I started getting hints that arcadiasecurity.com was redirected to the Google Search URL for “Gay Love.”

      The entire story is here: http://fightcopyrighttrolls.com/discussions/steele-hansmeier/arcadia-security/

      • chronoss

        good laughs are hard ( LOL ) to CUM ( ROFL ) buy.
        send em to a giant penis pic ROFL of of a gaint asshole….

  • http://xfyrios.myopenid.com/ xFyrios

    Hahah great work TF! You made my day with this one ;)

  • Pingback: the pimpest internet news site – TorrentFreak Trolls a Copyright Troll

  • Who

    I just looked in to this Prenda law firm and there stupid. they tried to sue AT&T and Comcast for assisting hackers.LOL good luck making that stick.
    all this firm does is intellectual property rights cases.

    quoted from there site.

    Why create anything?

    Without copyrights, there would be no book stores, concert halls or movie theaters. Digital piracy is an existential threat to the useful arts and sciences. Our founding fathers enshrined copyright law in the Constitution, understanding that artistic works are instrumental to social progress.

    Stealing is wrong, regardless of whether it involves a DVD from the store or a digital copy via BitTorrent. While our firm cannot prevent theft, we can prosecute the thieves. We understand the frustration of creating a movie, book or song, only to watch online pirates use BitTorrent or illegal passwords to steal your content.

    We Can Help.

    WoW they even got the shit ASS bask words LOL. and I thought the RIAA/MPAA were stupid.

    1st off: BEFORE copyrights even existed…there were book stores, concerts and movie theaters.

    2nd “Digital piracy is an “existential threat” to the useful arts and sciences”
    means “Risks to civilization, humans, and planet Earth”

    3rd “Our founding fathers enshrined copyright law in the Constitution”
    according to what I understand as regards to this, its SAYS PRIVET property. well guess what, this EXCLUDES stuff you SELL.

    4th “Stealing is wrong” look up the TRUE definition of stealing.

    5th downloading from bittorent is NOT stealing. *if you looked up the TRUE definition you will know y*

    • U-95

      Their arguments look a lot as those of the SGAE (those of you who are spanish now who’re them). Especially this: “(…)there would be no book stores, concert halls or movie theaters. Digital piracy is an existential threat to the useful arts and sciences.”

      Not only that stuff existed much before copyright as other have stated before but also arts and sciences were around much before “digital piracy” and while man is man they’ll continue existing.

      I wonder what they mean by “useful arts and sciences”. Does it means the art or sciences that have no purpose (read: money) aren’t worth of being copyrighted?

      • Who

        don’t really mater as they are breaking TRUE LAW regardless.
        just wander how many other so called LAW firms pull this shit.

  • Dave

    “ignore the the problem”

    Nothing says “amateur” more than moronic typos that result from a lack of proofreading.

    • Danny

      Nice argument.

      Glad you had something positive to add to the discussion instead of just insulting people….. oh wait!

  • Pingback: TorrentFreak Trolls a Copyright Troll | My Daily Feeds

  • Guest

    TF = RESPECT

  • Violated0

    TF sure did the correct response there where it was a big mistake for Prenda Law to mention this site when the locals certainly would like the people who received these letters to receive some expert advice.

    People who receive such letters can often panic but that is the worst thing that they can do where it only takes a little advice to realise that law firms like Prenda Law are trolls and where the people who receive these letters can easily win their case. Now a three simple step plan would be: 1) Don’t panic. 2) Never confess. 3) Deny, deny & deny again.

    Well it is only a shame that Prenda Law will soon fix their mistake and where the people who saw the real article are unlikely to check twice. So only a few people will be saved by this act but as the author says even if just one person reads that new page then success will be ours.

    • Guest

      Yes agree on all points.

      Overall, wouldn’t it be best to avoid porn in the first place? Especially internet porn. I keep hearing over and over again how porn does some strange neurochemical imbalances in the head. Nasty stuff.

      • Frood_Dude

        The voices in your head are telling you that porn is bad for your brain?

      • Danny

        Porn is fine.

        I know lots of people who regularly watch porn and none of them have ‘neurochemical imbalances’.

      • IDIOCRACY

        Actually porn is addictive, but guess what, cigarettes, alcohol, drugs, cannabis (no that is not drugs, it’s a medicine hehe) shopping and watching TV too.
        Porn creates a neurochemical state in the brain that, depending of your point of view is called an imbalance or just very balanced, did you all knew that the exact same neurochemical state is found in the brain when you find a real bargain in a shop (f.e. a power drill from deWalt for only 2 dollars). so what does this tell us about shopping…. indeed same as watching porn, and guess what, all women are hooked to it……..hehehehe

    • Bananas

      denying is the best defense ever.

  • nanguo692

    tinyurl.com/bvc45pl

  • gummykage

    You should’ve posted that link to some hardcore porn LOL

  • None

    I DO have a problem with copyright holders protecting “their” content, and that is in cases where, I believe, the copyright should have (long) expired or should not be applicable. Cases in point:performing “Happy Birthday To You” at a public venue without paying royalties, giving a copy of “Steamboat Willy” to a friend, uploading a minute long video of a toddler dancing in front of a TV where a Metallica music video is playing.

    • ScrewEwe2

      A minute long video of a toddler dancing in front of a TV where a Metallica music video is playing, is just plain wrong, because Lars sucks, but I have no problems with a minute long video of a toddler dancing in front of a TV where a video of Steamboat Willy ass raping Lars Ultra-rich Ulrich is playing would be acceptable.

      • Edward Blackbeard Thatch

        for the life of me i cannot work out why people are so fantical about metalica, i’ve never found them to be as good as everything thinks they are. they are way over rated.

  • Guest

    prenda downloading torrents and fighting with it at same time.she’s trolling USA hard

  • Pingback: TorrentFreak Trolls a Copyright Troll | Zombie Torrents - Ultimate Torrents Downloads

  • Sketch

    what do you call one million lawyers at the bottom of the ocean? a good start……

  • ScrewEwe2

    Nice job Torrent Freak. :-)

  • chronoss

    you should have redirected the url to a giant penis pic
    that would have been hilarious….

  • jiuyueqi
  • KeyBeast

    too bad the firm law is in usa, because here we can kick the ass out of this attorney

  • hellooooo

    i’m getting a warning from google about the redirected URL… screenshot here http://www.mediafire.com/view/?7ti73csk4q8kf3h

    • Who

      chances are it google just stupidly blocking the link. Ive got similar screens for china trackers that are just fine. the US/RIAA/MPAA/Google are just trying to censer the web. but of course I might be wrong. you can try and use a free proxy to bypass it if you don’t want to click on alow/i understand the risks. but free Proxys kinda suck. most don’t work, or are SLOOOOW.

  • TJkant

    Well done TF.

  • Trekfanwarp1980

    Prenda are worthless Zionist Jews who said holocaust happen. that so holocaust never happen if did that hitler would be catholic saint

  • Asashii

    well i guess Hitler was a catholic saint HUH, nice to know, you break copyright laws and get caught, boo-hoo, play with the bull and guess what you get, cant justify law is in the books in what ever damn country you might be in, so quit calling black blue and dont get busted Good LUCK!!!!

    • SomeYahoo

      thefuckwhat did you just say?

  • Pingback: – TorrentFreak Pulls The Switcheroo On Copyright Troll That Cited Them In Threat Letters

  • Pingback: Sharing 7 Movies on BitTorrent = $1.5 Million Damages | TorrentFreak

  • Pingback: Sharing 7 Movies on BitTorrent = $1.5 Million Damages | Best Seedbox

  • Pingback: Sharing porn could cost you $1.5 Million | Planet Ivy

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.