TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

World War II Veterans Must Pay To Sing War Songs

Veterans of World War II who sang war songs at a free concert last year have now been told that they must pay fees to copyright holders. A collections society says they are owed money since the veterans sang the songs in public. The controversy has prompted an announcement in Russia’s parliament.

Music played an important part during World War II. It was used to boost the morale of both soldiers and civilians during the conflict and since then war songs have endured, particularly in the hearts of those that survived the fighting.

Although the casualties on all sides during World War II were absolutely horrendous, the losses suffered by the then U.S.S.R were staggering – almost 27 million people lost their lives.

Last September a World War II veterans choir held a concert in Samara, one of Russia’s largest cities. At the free event they sang those songs that helped them through the fighting and have provided them with nostalgia since.

However, the Russian Authors Society (RAS) has now filed a claim with the organizers of the concert. It appears that since the war songs the veterans sang are copyrighted, fees have to be paid to RAS. Understandably the veterans are pretty upset and many simply don’t understand what is happening.

“We sang to convey an educational message to our grandchildren,” said one performer. “And we have to pay for that? Is this not a crime?”

In order for the songs to have been performed legally at the event, a licensing agreement should have been entered into with RAS, something which was not done, says RAS Deputy Director, Oleg Partin.

The controversy prompted an announcement in the lower house of the Russian parliament that the Arts Committee should be convened immediately. Copyright is there to fight piracy, they said, not to fight veterans.

“This is nonsense! It is unacceptable that those who sing the wonderful songs of WWII will have to pay a bribe,” said Communist Party leader Gennady Zyuganov. “I believe that in this case insanity grows stronger and stronger. Now it has arrived at complete stupidity.”

On May 9th 1945, Russia celebrated the end of the Great Patriotic War. The 65th anniversary of that day arrives in just a few weeks and it now seems that RAS is trying to make amends for the hurt caused earlier. They are suggesting that changes should be made so that singing war songs on that day is a free activity.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Glemball

    Haven’t these veterans paid enough.

  • theo

    No surprise.

  • Hoboapple

    this is ridiculous

  • Anonymous

    disgusting greedy pigs

  • djnforce9

    Such Arrogance! Why should anyone have to PAY to sing a song? I hope that gets shot down ASAP.

  • RoestVrijStaal

    WTF? Is Russia turning to a new France/USA in two weeks?

  • Phoenix

    so whats next !
    i sing in the street or at home and get arrested ?

  • Alex

    This isn’t just a pain in the back any more…

    This is inhumane insanity! At least fight the pirates, don’t mess with people who have been willing to sacrifice their lives for YOUR country! My God.

  • Anonymous

    In Soviet Russia, songs sing you!

  • Ralonto

    I’dd post something here about the music industry digging their own graves but I guess it would be nothing new to most people, lol.

    To put this into perspective, I guess this stands about on par with people downloading Haiti fund raiser songs and not paying for them where possible.

  • WilliamTM

    That’s just absurd.

  • Kirkpad

    Well the only reason I could see them owing any money is if they used choir sheet music that was copyrighted.

  • Anonymous

    Srsly the RAS needs to go die in a fire for stupidity like that.

  • Nobody

    The media nazis were bad before, but this is just low, even for slime like them.

  • Anonymous

    just saing, soon we got to pay licencing to be alive becouse someone copyrighted the human organism.

    I belive that copyright is the new way to destroy freedom of speech, just take this article, you cant sing becouse the words that you sing are copyrighted.

  • Anon

    And all of a sudden we must pay royalty to sing songs in the shower. >_<

  • doktor mcnasty

    You know what I am sick and effing tired of copyright nonsense. I don’t believe for one minute that no one would create anything if there was no copyright. No – instead you know what would happen? The people who are creative for reasons NOT having to do with money would find a way to continue on and the content that THEY would produce would be scarce, yeah, but worth while. I don’t want people doing things for the money. We all know money is the root of all evil so what’s so effing hard to wrap the mind around? hey? Sure I get paid for what I love doing and I get paid well. But that is NOT why I do it.

  • Anonymous

    this article is heavily biased against copyright holders. If you’re going to write an aricle, at least have a fair, neutral point of view.

  • J

    HaHa! Let them continue to make a fool of themselves. They’ll only help digging their own grave. :D

  • Will

    Stupid!

  • Anonymous

    I don’t think the problem in this case was the law. You can’t expect an exception for every possible special case. The real problem is that someone explicitly filed a claim against it! That doesn’t even make sense from an economical standpoint, the publicity damage will outweigh any monetary gain by far.

  • wlamer

    Damn, it happened in my city. I remember that concert…
    AAARGH RAS, get the hell out of here!!

  • Anonymous

    @18

    Considering the fact that RAS are trying to peddle backwards with what they said and did, I think it’s a fair assumption that they’ve realized they were in the wrong with their nonsense.

    How about you use your brain?

  • Georgios

    Yeah, well, the Russian Mafia has many branches …

    or how am I to understand that?

    SRSLY though, I liked the sentence:
    “Copyright is there to fight piracy, they said, not to fight veterans.”

    Guess, that’s the difference between common sense and the common greed displayed by those ‘collecting’ companies.

  • doktor mcnasty

    18 Mar 28, 2010 at 20:47 by Anonymous

    “this article is heavily biased against copyright holders. If you’re going to write an aricle, at least have a fair, neutral point of view.”

    I think that P2P networks and torrents have more than amply demonstrated that copyright holders aren’t worth any kind of consideration and in fact are the bane of our existence. I would now have some vulgarities to spew at you for what I perceive to be a well-deserving target of such defecations except for the fact that this site censors them out.

  • a/s/l

    *raises fist in a tabloid-style rage*

  • Anonymous

    This is just another proof, that copyright holders are the NEW FASCISTS!!!

  • Anonymous

    This dmca,riaa,mpee bullshit is getting out of control

  • RIAAtard

    Only in this forsaken WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • bleh

    Like I said times and times again, anything we write soon we’ll have to pay a fee to even write anything, ’cause all the words are in the dictionary and someone must own the rights to these words. It’s getting way out of hand now. I think the whole world needs to do something like France did in 1789, a worldwide revolution, some heads need to be cut.

  • copywrong

    “We sang to convey an educational message to our grandchildren,” said one performer. “And we have to pay for that? Is this not a crime?”

    According to some it is a crime. Would you believe it?

    Where will this end? That is why we need to abolish copyright laws. It has no sense whatsoever.

    We need to put in to power those that have sense rather than money, greed and how to fiddle expenses in their minds.

  • copywrong

    “We sang to convey an educational message to our grandchildren,” said one performer. “And we have to pay for that? Is this not a crime?”

    According to some it is a crime. Would you believe it?

    Where will this end? That is why we need to abolish copyright laws. It has no sense whatsoever.

    We need to put in to power those that have sense rather than money, greed and how to fiddle expenses in their minds.

  • Anonymous

    RAS is trying to make amends for the hurt caused earlier. They are suggesting that changes should be made so that singing war songs on that day is a free activity.

    LOL Who won the war and who lost?

    Maybe a new war is looming…

    I wonder if prisons in gitmo get fined if they sing (when not being waterboarded)? Or if they get a free day on the year of their capture.

    damn insanity. Who has a pill for me?

  • z0mg

    This is madness!

  • copyleft

    anyone who turns a profit on copyright should be given a sentence which is *at least* the minimum a dreg peddlar would get for selling crack to elementary-aged kids on a playground.

  • rock

    OMFG those greedy bastrads whats wromg with people this days.

  • Yo

    Hmm… who gives a shit what RAS says?
    I’d like to see exactly how they have a copyright to a WWII song?
    No case here.

  • Jay

    Communist war songs? That shit should be banned. Communism killed more people in the 20th century than any combination of wars, ever.

  • Ninja

    FOR GOD SAKE, THOSE SONGS WERE MADE BY THE PEOPLE, THE SOLDIERS. GET THE COPYRIGHT AND STICK IT IN YOUR … EARS… YOU FREAKING RETARDS [/rage]

    Excuse me the people with down syndrome, I really didn’t mean to disrespect you, you are much better than those imbeciles.

    Yet another proof that copyright is an utter bs. MAFIAA should be ashamed. O wait, they’ll never be ashamed if there’s money to be made.

  • k

    Democracy did the same. More American lives were lost during the civil war than any other. So before you go off on Communism remember, soldiers are dying in every day in this “war on terror”. I’ll take Communism over the joke that democracy has become any day. Like Pennywise said, “Land of the free?”

  • Test

    Great article Enigmax! Keep up the good work and keep exposing the copyright MAAFIA seems to have reached even Russia now!

  • free stuffz lubber

    Off with their heads!!

  • anonymous

    i thank God that i was not around during those horrendous days of conflict and cannot believe that anyone could show such disrespect by trying to charge people for singing the songs of that era. to say that they are going to allow the songs to be sung freely on May 9th during some celebrations is an even bigger piss take and nose rubbing! people should be able to sing the songs as often as they like, under any circumstances. when is this copyright insanity going to end? if we’re not careful, there will be wars started over this, the same as they have been started over politics and religion. i am convinced that those that opened the copyright can of worms originally didn’t realise exactly what they were doing, but am equally convinced that when they do eventually realise, it will be too late! a lot to be said for being pig headed, stubborn and ignorant, eh?

  • Anonymous

    Go ahead .. take ‘em on .. I’m sure some of them still have a few ‘treasures’ lying around to fight back with.

  • Anonymous

    This is fucking ridiculous, I sang along with the radio the other day, do I have to pay a fine?

  • lunar

    #1 “Haven’t these veterans paid enough.”

    that was one good comment.

  • dustin_ds3000

    THIS PISSES ME OFF, World War II Veterans have every right to Sing War Songs freely

  • Anonymous

    America land of the copyright lol

  • James Darlays expert France

    Des droits sont dûs si les entrées sont payantes, un petit pourcentage; si c’est pour une oeuvre charitable on peut demander une dispense, qui est accordée; si c’est un spectacle privé, entre amis, il n’y a rien à payer; dans tous les cas le responsable est l’organisateur mais pas les chanteurs; si un disque est fait il y a des droits aux auteurs des titres, s’il est vendu; s’il est juste en petite quantité en souvenir de la soirée pour les chanteurs, c’est un cas de gratuité.

  • RIAAtarded

    bloody hell if it wasn’t for those vets you wouldn’t have the freedoms you enjoy today. You should be thanking them for their sacrifice not threaten to sue. They already fought there battle someone with a little common sense squash this crap it is already way out of hand.

  • antiantipiracy.blogspot.com

    OMFG that’s totally insane!!!

  • Anonymous

    just accidentally miss with a foab (father of all bombs) on their hq knowing the greediness of these barstards their office surrounding luxury parkland should be sufficient to absorb the blast radius without anything else being affected…

  • Mad World

    Swap the millions of dead for the those mad profit making copyrightist any day!

  • Unauthorized Content Consumer

    Ummm…i’d like to say that the greed and selfishness of the music industry doesn’t surprise me. Then I read something like this and it is absolutely appalling.

    I wonder how the music industry can twist it so that some how they can blame old men singing obscure songs causes a loss of sales resulting in damages that exceeds $100,000 per infraction. Next thing they’ll send out press releases stating that Elderly Veterans are Killing the Music Industry. ACL law fricken whatever they call themselves must be salivating at the thought of sinking their teeth into those veteran pensions.

    I never thought I’d ever say this but I wouldn’t shed a tear if someone blew up the offices of their music industry office.

  • Simon

    This is bullshit! After all they have done, and you want them to pay more?

    Lots of them have already paid with their lives!

    This proves that you have absolutely no morals!

    You are a disgrace, a waste of space, and the worst part is, they fought so YOU could be free!

    Pay them a little respect!

  • mnml

    wow, seriously

  • Wolfy

    So, the songs that are supposed to be copyrighted here
    Were either old songs at the time or made up at the time – surely they’re in the public domain by now? Or is it a case of a pro copyright society claiming the rights to every single piece of music, whether they have the right or not?

  • Anonymous

    @18

    they dont deserve any consideration, especially when they do stuff like they mentioned in the article, so your comment is overruled.have a nice day…

    anyway this money pinching scheme is disrespectful and rotten and I think its time for the copyright industry to be shown the door.

  • Grok

    It was a free event. Furthermore, they sang songs that were sung in the war to keep their spirits up and get them through the fighting. If anything, this event can be seen as not only educational (given its strong tie to the event and the people in question, and the motive and message of the performance), but fair use for other reasons. These are the men who were a part of the song’s lives during the war, and they are expressing that same feeling in this performance.

    What money is expected for them to be able to give? It was free. They gained no money from using these songs, and if these people just wanted recognition, they shouldn’t go suing these veterans frivolously.

    If anything, this is just bad PR for the RAS. Nice going, ignorant scumbag leeches.

  • IHeard

    Pure filth and greed.

    I am surprised they haven’t tried to extort monies per spoken word used in their songs. Just think of the profit!

  • Barbara Rose

    And rightly so. Slam-dunk copyright theft if ever I saw it. Oh how they like to think that they’re somehow special and above the law, that the world owes them a free ride, that they have free pass to steal from the pockets of the rightful copyright owners, depriving creators (and intermediary content managers/rightsholders) of an honest reimbursement for their hard work.

    It is only right that they expect to receive the full force of the law for this degree of criminal activity.

  • Anonymous

    @6: Unfortunately, this all due to Civil Code part 4, which were enacted 2 years ago (so, not 2 weeks, but…).

    @59: RAS (???/RAO) is not so concerned about its rating. History with antirao domain were funny [it isn't finished, next part will be on April, 1st, when there are will be next part of judication :) ]

  • adyshor

    This is hilarious and sad in the same time.
    Next: © Christmas songs and © church songs LOL

  • Anonymous

    @61

    obvious troll is obvious…

  • Trelew

    Is nothing sacred to these corporate bastards? How utterly disrespectful to charge veterans anything! What’s next? To have a surcharge at sporting events where a national anthem is performed?!?

    I guess nothing is sacred to these corporate suits other than profit and power.

    When I first heard about it I thought it was too outrageous to believe so I double checked with other news agencies like AP. Not only did I find that this legit but has happened in other countries before by other copyright Nazis. And people wonder why we don’t corporations and why we rebel against them.

  • cwrw

    nothimg new form the new uncle joe

  • bryanskrantz

    utterly disrespectful. this corporation should be hannged.

  • Taylor

    I understand it is a copyright infraction. That being said do they have a monkey working in the PR department? No, they don’t because a chimp can make a better choice; they must have a rock sitting on the “sue” button. This gets them only bad press, Vet’s have given everything and then some, besides if it was a “free concert” what money is there to be made from it? No one earned anything, a law suit would’ve completely frivolous. Hopefully they get ride of the rock and hire someone with intelligence to make decisions.

  • Anon

    The songs’ artists are probably all long since dead. The vets have to pay off a bunch of talentless grandson-in-law copyright tycoons? Next thing you know they’ll be sued for telling war stories, which have since been adapted into movies. A crazy world we live in..

  • Pingback: Veterani della seconda guerra mondiale debbono pagare per poter cantare

  • Sanity_Vocal

    I don’t understand. War songs were written for the war effort, for boosting morales of the soldiers that fought the war, the same soldiers who were singing the songs as rememberence of those who sacrificed themselves so that the facist swastika welding Hitler regime of the Third Reich could be prevented? Those same songs? For whom are the so-called Royalties being collected?

    If royalties are to be collected, then perhaps all veterans of the winning sides in World War 2 should collect Life royalty from Every other living being in the world, for breathing free and dying free?

    Real idiots them lots collecting the royalties.

  • Sanity_Vocal

    And what about the royalty of using the English language? Wanna charge royalty for use of language as well?

    Any government that supports such rubbish deserves to be booted out of the polls. Like the UK one coming up.

  • Sanity_Vocal

    How about a total ban on the purchase of all CDs, MP3s, etc until the MPAA and all the other rubbish orgs out to milk the public are teethered? I know I’m not going to be buying any musical, printed and/or visual products, nor listen to songs, watch TVs or see movies for the next 2 weeks because of this.

  • OMG

    wow… that is seriously messed up.

  • Daffy Duck

    Disgusting.

  • Mike

    Get the story Right
    The veterans were not being told they have to pay anything

  • Mike

    This blog clearly misrepresents the facts of this story as detailed in the Moscow Times

  • Lososerg

    @75 Read the story right:
    “However, the Russian Authors Society (RAS) has now filed a claim with the organizers of the concert.”

  • Shot self in the foot

    and crawling on the planets face
    an insect called the human race
    lost in time… and space
    in meaning without grace

  • Bob

    I’m just surprised this happened in Russia of all places.

  • antiantipiracy.blogspot.com

    Where’s Reasonned Mind when we need him to comment?

  • Knarf

    “Haven’t these veterans paid enough.”

    QFT

  • zukov

    Greed has no limits

  • Pingback: Pirate Home Page » World War II Veterans Must Pay To Sing War Songs

  • Meh

    Absolutely disgusting… how dare RAS complain about the men who risked their lives in war. they should be ashamed!!! bunch of greedy unsympathetic a$$holes. I hope they rott in hell!

  • Basterds.

  • Dogsarentcoolright

    Those communist bastards! nuke em all!

  • Anonymous

    This is fucking disgusting

  • Dia

    RAS is so generous, letting them sing those songs for free on one day even though they have no right to.

  • Daniel D

    God forgive them because they’ve crossed the borders of stupidity long time ago!
    Why not arrest mothers who sing copyrighted songs to their babies while walking in the park? Why not arrest kids for singing copyrighted songs while playing? why not put a tax on watching and listening? (that way I’ll pay for listening/watching copyrighted materials even if I do it by accident)
    This might end up in a world wide revolution!

  • kuru

    hopefully all these pieces of shit will one day look straight into a muzzle and hear the final click…
    and then rot in hell…

  • kuru

    oh and btw, @ 85: go read an actual history book, won’t you?

  • Waleed

    i think then the RAS should pay the veterans a fee for their freedom.

  • arr

    I will continue to get my media pirated and not support mafiaa. emule atw

  • AnarchyNow

    27 millions died and the survivors have to pay to _sing_ ??? Aren’t those song supposed to be public-domain since they were made in communist times ???
    Russia has really gone the wrong way, the Putin totalitarian warmonging dictatorship has to go away and a real revolution has to start again, without any useless army left.

  • sad

    After reading the title i automatically assumed that it was amerika….lol.Cannot believe this happened in russia.

  • gorehound

    sickening news.i am very much into reading world war 2 and watching war movies.lots of them on eastern front combat and this post is disgusting.
    after what these men had to go thru to have some BS like this is a disgrace.

  • JOVIALAU

    Punishment is the last and least effective instrument in the hands of the legislator,for the prevention of crime.Those who make peaceful revolution impossible,make violent revolution inevitable.

  • Stephane P

    wow this is so Stupid !

  • Pingback: Quieren hacerles pagar a veteranos de guerra por cantar canciones con copyright | ALT1040

  • Jeanniewood.yahoo.ca

    I sung along with my IPod today. Would I have to pay? I doubt it. And neither should these ppl.

  • me

    Too bad to see Russia as a nation pay so little tribute to her veterans, yet so much more tender loving care to her newly-rich copyright holder mafia.

    Then, again, modern Russian regime IS a cleptocracy, or isn’t it? Shame on you, Putin: your great country and people deserve better treatment than this.

  • Whatever

    First thought was that its in the US. But suprisingly its in Russia.

    Proven again that the MAFIAA thrives on death and destruction.
    It can be added to the list like:
    - Haiti
    - Micheal Jackson
    - Other charities (Italy, previous Haiti song)
    The list of dead people and artists they make a profit from is probably very very long.

  • gogan

    Oh let me tell you more about that RAS filth…
    RAS represents some russian authors on contractual basis BUT they also represent ALL foreign authors by default. They collect money from radio, TV, bars etc. to give it to the authors (minus 15%) BUT they only give it upon request from those authors. Now, how many, say, american songwriters are even aware of RAS existence? Obviously not so many. And if within three years the authors don’t request their money RAS is KEEPING it!
    Also there was a funny story some time ago. RAS sued the company that had arranged Deep Purple concerts in Russia because the company didn’t pay RAS the money for having Deep Purple songs played by Deep Purple! AND THEY WON!

  • Pingback: Veteranii rusi din Al Doilea Razboi Mondial – corul piratilor fara voie | Partidul Piratilor

  • immortalus

    Some day, we’ll probably for be fined or sent to jail for memorizing a song in our heads.

  • nobrains

    this is absolutely ridiculous.

  • Anonymous

    Are they going to make them pay for use of the word ‘veteran’ next? That’s just beyond words, I can’t even express how that article makes me feel. It’s not as though they made any money, it was a free event. How can someone like that sleep at night?

  • Ilerien

    pizdec
    dats all i can say about this lol

  • S10

    Heartless bastards. This is really getting out of control.

  • Pingback: blingmyfaves.com

  • Mike

    @77 exactly

    The organizers NOT the veterans

  • Quartz

    Just what are the copyright length of term in the former soviet union ?

    One would like to think that copyright has expired on these works or that they are government property and thus property of all folks from that time as communism by definition proposes such is the case.

    Applying cretinous claims against those who defended their motherland is an affront to all Russian and satellite ex soviet states, I,m sure all older folks who hear of this will take fitting action to destroy the capitalist backed “patriot tax”.

  • Anonymous

    “One day, RAO woke up famous”

    http://bablaw.livejournal.com/160896.html

    Thank you, TorrentFreak.

  • 1whoHatesIdiots

    So now there gonna sue in American/Canadian Idol since they sing other peoples songs as an audition as well?
    I would also leave a few unkind words but I have nothing harsh enough and I already saw a few I thought fitting above.
    I know I will definitely think much harder now when I am about to buy something such as a movie or such as to who the money is going to.

  • Deamon Fire

    How do they even have any sort of case here if the performance was free? I could see if they were charging entry, or using sheet music as one commenter said. But for a FREE performance? C’mon, REALLY? -_-

  • Anonymous

    “And all of a sudden we must pay royalty to sing songs in the shower. >_<"

    Only if you leave the window open.

    AllOfMP3 was one thing. But come on. These geezers seriously put it on the line. Soviet grunts were not the best equipped and they were still 10000% ass kickers.

  • Anonymous

    Modifiyeli focus

    Modifiyelifocus, modifiyeli focus, modifiye focus, bursafocus, chacafocus, lambofocus, fordfocus, karizmafocus, martikapifocus, tesisatlifocus, aksesuarlifocus, 16yy920focus, tuningfocus, modifiyefocus, grifocus, yy920focus, 920focus, 16focus, bursan?n focusu, 16focus920, modifiyeli16, modifiye16, tuningbursa, maddesign, ledlifocus, neonfocus, kralfocus, bursadakifocus, blog, blogcu, r10, farmville hileleri, örgü modelleri, cep telefonu modelleri, dekorasyon fikirleri, bilgisayar, ahmet maranki, gold bilgisayar, futbol smart izle, ender saraç, cep telefonu, saç dökülmesi, zay?flama hareketleri, windows xp, zay?flama hareketleri, kavak yelleri, derya baykal, kilo alma, rapidshare s?n?rs?z download, örgü, web tabanl? oyunlar, gothic, panjur fiyatlar?, asus laptop, julia stiles, marquee, lida, kral tv, msn 8.5, facebook, youtube, google, yahoo, windows, windows live, windows live messanger, live messanger, bursaspor, galatasaray, teksas, skype, wikipedia, wiki, blogger, blogspot, ucretsiz blog, free blog, baidu, studentsn, badoo, netlog, gayet net, cartopu, mail ru, rus bayan arkadas, gmail, sahibinden, forum, mp3, kurtlar vadisi, muzik, remix, msn, hotmail, msnbc, msn messanger

  • Anonymous

    Fuck every single copyright owner in the world. Fuck them all.
    This is what will happen:
    - Laws on copyright content will become so strict that people will get so fucking pissed off and continue to break the law more and more.
    - A government of a powerful/influential country will one day infringe on copyright and the copyright owners will take them to court.
    - The government will get pissed off at the copyright owner as in “how dare you take the government to court” and as a punishment to the copyright owner for their fucktardedness, downloading and public all displaying/exhibiting copyright media work will become legal.
    - The copyright owner and big copyright/movie companies will try and take the government to court again or on apeal and they will lose, be fined hundreds of millions (maybe billions) simply because the government can. And they will go home and cry, and legally never able to take anyone to court for copyright infringement for fear of losing and heavy penalties.

    Just remember. We make the movie/music industry who they are. Without us they will all fall. It will only take one big one like Paramount or WB to fall and they will all back off and not fight us again. Maybe then they will make copyright content close to free. 5c a movie, 1c a song, pay online through paypal. Get it through your heads you movie/music/copyright FUCKING CUNTS. We wont pay, and we are here to stay!

  • Pingback: Global Geek News Podcast Episode #60 | Global Geek News

  • Truther

    Absolutely disgusting to do to some of the most important people in WWII.

  • 1

    ????RAS

  • TactileDot

    “they must have a rock sitting on the “sue” button”

    I lol’d.

  • aRandomFrenchGuy

    [quote]I think the whole world needs to do something like France did in 1789, a worldwide revolution, some heads need to be cut.[/quote]

    The thing you dont understand here is that the heads which were cut belonged to people who thought differently.

    Low class people were mislead into killing medium class leaders, so that the wealthiest and the real rulers would still be unharmed. remember, a revolution is a full circle, you just go back to where you started.

    At that time the power did not change hands. Some puppets where sacrificed to adress people’s bloodlust, and that is nearly all. Declaration of human rights ? Ha ! Our country is not far away from China considering outrages done to this. Our current leader is trying to create laws that will legitimate an even tighter human control than in China ! And so far, nobody is stopping him.

    We are going to be enslaved, pick your choice : in the US and Russia, they call it “piracy enforcement”, in France it is done to “fight against terrorism and pedophilia”, because as everyone knows the internet is just full of these.

    What a shame …

  • mm

    copyright>heros who risk their lives

  • nnsa

    Am I annoyed by this? Yes.
    Am I surprised by this? No.
    Same sh1t different day.
    Please seed, than you :-)

  • Brian

    “said Communist Party leader Gennady Zyuganov”

    Honestly? If I were a musician, I wouldn’t want to be associated with communists either.

  • !’ÂSD

    so they made song about the war, veterans made the war. It seem like authors should pay to veterans. Did they even counting if veterans didn’t fought there won’t be a country or a legal system for that fuckers to sew veterans for copyright

  • GeneralComment

    I enjoy TorrentFreak’s global reach immensely. Is it possible that the country be placed in the title? For example,

    Russia: World War II Veterans Must Pay To Sing War Songs

    It is sort of distracting to work out the mystery of what country or locale your stories apply to, especially if legal action is involved.

  • Pensive

    Pure greed.

  • Wesha

    From the article:

    “Oscar Feltzman, the author of music for [a few patriotic songs] is trying to find an explanation. He asks if maybe they (the veterans) charged a lot for admission to the concert? Not at all. The concert was absolutely free.

    “If it was a community concert, then nobody owes anybody anything,” the composer says. “It’s that *we* owe the veterans a bow and deep sincere thanks for their lives [they put on line in the war]“.”

  • Gogogo

    April fools tomorrow.. idiots.

  • Jimbo

    That sounds like the kind of shit you get in the UK these days, not Russia :S

  • me

    @114 Anonymous: Your scenario doesn’t take into account, that nothing prevents governments from making laws that puts them above the law. Or, more precisely, they could change the law, saying: “coyright applies to all, except to the government.” Just like highway cops who CAN drive faster than allowed to catch a speedster.

  • tehehe

    A prime example of the sons of darkness at work..

    Don’t worry too much about this, but speak up for sure. Soon the sons of darkness and the sons of light are going to have a clash.. u know it, the other folks know it.. so get ready!

    littlescroll . com

  • Elthar

    When World War II hit, my grandmother was 16 years and she had to crawl under nazis fire to chop up a piece of meat from a frozen horse’s body to fed up the rest of her family.
    My grandfather was in Russian army for 7 years: first for 3 years and then the War hit for another 4. He fought at the Kursk Bulge and was almost burned alive in a tank when it was hit.

    I’m glad they both didn’t made it to this day to see what people, for whom they and their comrades and friends had sacrificed their lives, are doing now.
    These moronic imbeciles with all their copyright crap would not had be even born, if not for those veterans.

  • geofffromcanberra

    fuccccckkkkinggg cuntttts

  • The Mikeness

    In Soviet Russia, copyright violates you!

  • Pingback: El colmo: Veteranos de la II Guerra Mundial deben pagar por cantar » nosoydelincuente.pe

  • Pingback: » WW II [Russian] Veterans Must Pay To Sin … vrypan|net|asides

  • Yoptop

    What words can you use? These people are the fucking BANE of humanity.

  • I friggin pirate

    SHIT LIKE THIS IS WHY PPL PIRATE STUFF!

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.