TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Man Uploads Episodes of ’24′, Faces 3 Years Jail

A man who uploaded four episodes of the hit series ’24′ to a YouTube-style video hosting site has been tracked down by the FBI and is now being threatened with 3 years in a federal prison.

24

According to a criminal complaint filed by the FBI, following a high-profile leak, Chicago resident Jorge Romero uploaded the first 4 episodes of this season’s ’24′ to a YouTube-style site before it aired on TV and is now facing 3 years in jail.

The FBI claim that Romero uploaded the first 2 episodes on January 6, followed by the next 2 episodes on January 7 and posted hyperlinks on other websites to ensure that the maximum number of people could find and view them. Romero apparently confessed that he previously downloaded the episodes from another web site before uploading them to LiveDigital.com.

Romero’s identity was reportedly revealed after Fox TV owner News Corp sent a subpoena to LiveDigital demanding the uploader’s details.

An FBI spokesman said, “Romero is charged in the criminal complaint with uploading copyrighted material to a publicly accessible computer network knowing the work was intended for commercial distribution.”

Fox TV put out a statement thanking the FBI for their work;

“We hope it will serve as a powerful warning that uploading copyrighted TV shows and movies to the Internet can be a crime with significant penalties and will be prosecuted as such. Video-hosting sites such as LiveDigital.com and YouTube are not copyright-free zones, and individuals like Jorge Romero who post episodes of television shows, particularly before they are even broadcast for the first time, will face harsh civil and criminal sanctions.”

Uploaders of pre-release copyright material are targeted by the FBI as these actions are considered criminal in the US and usually carry a custodial sentence, which is great for headline-grabbing when trying to deter future pirates. However, it is up for debate whether or not these pre-releases actually have any negative effect on viewing figures. Indeed, just this week the President of Lions Gate movies said that even though their latest blockbuster ‘Hostel: Part 2″ was leaked onto the internet, it would have “no meaningful impact” on box office takings.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Rick

    Well, stupid get what they “deserve”…

  • Rick

    I forgot:
    3 years jail are insane though.

  • grouder

    This guy can do what Michael did in th other FOX series. Maybe he have seen Prison Break’s firs season :D

  • Mark

    Ah, so I better kill a man, that only gets me two years jailtime…

    This is so completely insane. Fox wants to send to jail people who are spreading, and therefor popularizing, their material?

    How does uploading video’s on YouTube constitute anything more than a fine?

    Why don’t people who enforce these morally corrupt copyright constructions shoot themselves in the head?

    The world is broken, I tell you.

  • Pingback: אפרסק » ארכיון הבלוג » שלוש שנים בכלא על העלאת פרקים של 24 לאינטרנט

  • Stijepan

    If people like him hasen’t uploaded does series they wouldn’t be soo popular now…

    Those poeple are making a “wish hunt”…

  • Sweethacks.com

    Really stupid but then again people upload rubbish all the time!

  • FOX

    never seen 24. Maybe if i caught it on youtube i might like it, but i’m not going to sit in front of the tv waiting for it to show up. The new medium is internet. Show commercials or something with VOD after release date, but i dont want to be in front of TV.

  • Jeff

    by that man uploading into a internet it is now viewed by a different audience. for example i dont watch TV that much. but when i saw the episodes on the internet it made me wanna watch the next following episodes on TV. ratings would only go up rather then go down.

  • Pingback: Global Toad News » Thinking about sharing files?

  • Okella

    C’mon everyone. We’ve seen the FBI warning for centuries now. Just because its easier to put videos on the web than to dub a VHS doesn’t make it more legal. I agree the penalties are harsh but you knew the consequences since Loony Toons was on tape.

  • hmcrm

    The thing I don’t understand is why he is being charged at all. The article says because he uploaded files he knew were to be released for commercial distribution. That’s all fine and good, but Fox is a channel I can get even in my game room on a TV that doesn’t have cable. So in other words, I don’t pay anything to watch that channel, so what exactly is the damage done here??

  • Lagstyle

    rupert murdoch and the secret nazi society strike again

  • hmcrm

    I agree that copyrighted material isn’t to be posted on public sites, but if it’s something that anyone with a TV can watch without having to pay anything extra because it’s on local TV, just doesn’t make much sense to me.

  • anonimist2600

    agree with the above comment. I honestly do not watch ANY TV anymore. Why would you when you can get better quality commercial free TV almost immediately after airtime with the ability to pause, rewind, etc. These television producers need to get with the times.
    Three years in jail punishment does not fit the crime. Good job FBI, the “War on Terror” must be over–oh yeah–its not (according to you)!

  • ^sonic

    ROFLMAOTIME OFF WITH HIS HEAD!!

  • RIAA

    Everyone one watch 24 or else!

  • eM

    Jail is:
    A) For punishment
    B) To keep people away from society because they’re dangerous.

    This falls under A.

    Somehow, I don’t see why Paris Hilton getting DUI’s and driving with a suspended license nets her 40 days in jail, and this guy gets THREE FUCKING YEARS.

    3*365=1095 days

    It’s TV. It’s NATIONAL TV. omfg.

  • eM

    BOYCOTT 24.

  • Henry

    News Corp. and Fox should be happy that someone is furthering the viewship of this program. Also, this is another untapped way for these companies to further profit from the massive amount of product placement inserted into this show. Ford and other companies should pay a premium for shows that are shown to echo interest outside of the traditional television viewership. These companies need to get with the times and realize that ‘piracy’ could be extremely profitable for everyone involved, as well as improve worldwide viewership. Punishing this person will only hurt the long term successes of the media industry.

  • gyuval

    about the trakback:

    well it’s just a translation of your text into Hebrew with added sarcasm

  • Moody

    So the lesson is: upload from an Internet cafe, or over your neighbors WiFi router?

  • someone

    They should also imprison the writers responsible for ’24′ this season.

  • Pingback: Man Uploads Episodes of '24′, Faces 3 Years Jail « News Coctail

  • AnonymousChicken

    How DARE he upload something for broadcast on the Internet. What’s next, broadcasting the episodes on TV?

    … oh, wait. ^_^

  • non american 24 watcher and DVD buyer

    so does this mean that society at a whole is now punished again by feeding this guy for 3 years in a prison because he made sure that even more people know about this FOX series?
    What had become of the original intend of copyrightlaw described in the constitution?
    Housing/feeding this guy for 3 years serves the society as a whole exactly how?
    Man, this guy is/was oviously a hardcore fan of the series and did not made any money from selling bootleg DVD’s for example. And the crap .flv shit videos on those video sites are not used to produce Pirated DVDs that get sold to american soldiers in asia!
    WTF? You americans are so crazy that you let the big corporations rule you in such rediculous ways!

  • Pingback: Man Uploads Episodes of '24', Faces 3 Years Jail - Hip Hop/Rap music and Urban Entertainment

  • JoJo

    Is this story for real? Any official sources please? Sounds like a scare tactic from someone like Fox to me.

  • 24 Ambivalent

    I believe the reason he is being punished is for distributing those four Episodes prior to their public release via the usual TV Network. Meaning: he obtained them illegally, then redistributed them illegally. I haven’t heard of a TV Network suing anyone for uploading/downloading their shows after they air, for which I’m grateful since that is the only way I’ve watched TV in the past 3 years.

  • Pingback: USC Free Culture Alert: Murdoch and GE “Charming” New Suit Further Threaten our Media System at Free Culture USC

  • Pingback: Don't.. Uh.. Upload 24 | TechRave

  • Pingback: Man Uploads Episodes of '24′, Faces 3 Years Jail - News Doggy - Fetched News

  • ztexas

    3 years for copyright violation? Come on, let’s all say it together:
    “crypto-fascist state”.

  • Unsub

    It is not about the money it is about the control. A few years ago it was incredibly difficult to be a hit as a musician without the major studios backing. Now anyone with talent and a webcam can be a star and even distribute there own music. This loss of control is very scary to the big money guys and they are respondig the only way they know how.

  • Lewis

    Not only is that about control, but it’s about how all those outraged Digg fans who “rose up” against the AACS don’t see the connection in opposing Murdoch in all areas, for example, in his attempt to buy the Wall Street Journal. Until bullies like FOX are able to hide their scare/control tactics on the down-lo either through the MPAA, DMCA or FBI, but then “charm” the Bancroft family for billions while the blogasphere is blind bec. that’s old media baby, little things like “free press” and “civil liberties” will continue to widdle away.

    Check out the above USC Free Culture post for more.

  • Pwnd

    What a load of horsesh*t

    **most the time the networks themselves put those shows on the internet.. and I agree w/most everyone else.. I dont even watch TV anymore.. unless i hook my computer up to it and run the DVD player… Actually 24 lost me as a show by season 2..

  • Pingback: The Counterrevolution Will Not Be Televised ¦ Online Media Cultist

  • Someone Else

    i’d wish the FBI used their time for real criminals…

    but anyhow , watching your favorite shows on the net when you want is better then waiting for it to show up on tv.. everyone should agree on that

  • Pingback: 3 años por subir capítulos de 24 | Denken Über

  • Pingback: Soluciones Web » Blog Archive » Cuando entenderan las grandes compañías?

  • James

    I feel this way about it I dont have time to watch tv when they play it on the tv. So if i cant download it and watch it later guess what. i will not be watching it Besides i never heard of 24 till i ran across this blog. and paris hilton served 3 days in jail she got out she was DUI she could have killed someone this is watching TV something they put on a TV for the world to see whats the friggin diffrence! I can see them being pissed about a early realease on the inet. but 3 years give me a break there is murderers and child molesters and Homeless people that could use all these man hours THIS is why i hate the Gov taking out taxes in my paycheck i think i should be able to say where my tax dollors go to. This whole thing has gotten so over blown out of proportion its like having a battle of wits with a unarmed person. For gods sakes will everyone just grow up a little bit!

  • Pingback: 3 χρόνια φυλάκιση για το “24″ : Lixnoos.com(beta)

  • sam

    Do we as a consumer have anything right?
    Take what they give you.. is that all we do now?

    Well, it is a new world but mentality is still ancient. Money is Power.

  • Michelle

    Maybe he should get 24 months in prison…how ironic would that be?

  • Pingback: Throwing File-Sharers in Jail to Grab Headlines | TorrentFreak

  • Pingback: ‘24′ Uploader Facing Prison After Admitting Causing Fox $4m Losses | TorrentFreak

  • Pingback: Man Uploads Episodes of '24′, Faces 3 Years Jail « Odisx9’s Weblog

  • Pingback: car dealers in norwalk ct connecticut

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

  • Pirates Can Be Identified Despite Sharing IP Addresses, ISP Claims

    Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation is a network mechanism through which many Internet subscribers can share the...

  • Feds Seize Cash from Major Bitcoin Exchange’s Dwolla Account

    The U.S. Government has taken a significant action against the web’s top Bitcoin exchange by seizing...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.