TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud

In a massive operation, Spanish music rights and anti-piracy groups SGAE and SDAE have been raided by more than 50 police officers and tax officials. Operation Saga is the culmination of a two-year investigation into embezzlement, fraud, and misappropriation of funds, the latter connected to SGAE and SDAE collecting money on behalf of artists and spending it with companies they have interests in. The president of SGAE was among 9 people arrested.

On Friday, more than 50 police, tax officials and staff from Spain’s Audit Office were involved in Operation Saga, the culmination of a two-year investigation into the dealings of Spanish music rights and anti-piracy groups SGAE and SDAE.

The groups, which campaign tirelessly for tougher copyright legislation, are the main collecting societies for songwriters, composers and publishers in Spain. Today they are in absolute turmoil.

Acting on a warrant issued by the anti-corruption prosecutor, police raided SGAE’s headquarters in Madrid with orders to detain and question key executives.

Some of the biggest names possible were arrested including SGAE President Eduardo “Teddy” Bautista (right) who was handcuffed and led away under armed guard, Ricardo Azcoaga (CFO of SGAE) and Enrique Loras (Director General of SGAE).

An hour after police arrived some employees were allowed to leave, but not before their laptops and cellphones had been confiscated. Others were detained for questioning while the authorities seized all computers in the sealed-off building. In total the raids lasted more than 14 hours.

The complaint against SGAE stems back to late 2007 when financial irregularities were discovered in SGAE’s handling of the revenue they collect rights payments and revenue from Spain’s blank media levy. The Asociacion de Internautas (Association of Internet Users) and other groups then raised an official complaint with the authorities.

The complaint alleges that SGAE operatives set up companies and used revenue destined for artists to generate profit for themselves and their families, and that money bound for artists living abroad was diverted to personal Swiss bank accounts.

At the center of the storm is SDAE, the digital rights arm of SGAE. Although a notionally separate entity, SDAE is fully operated by SGAE. It appears that when SDAE was being set up, SGAE hired a for-profit company called Microgenesis as consultants.

Microgenesis describe themselves as “a team of specialists in engineering, consultancy and development, managed by individuals with established experience in the fields of intellectual property, as well as the culture and entertainment industries.”

Microgenesis operated a number of companies which provided various services for SGAE and SDAE, some of them suspiciously registered at SGAE/SDAE’s own office address. The problems only deepen when one learns who is behind Microgenesis.

Jose Luis Rodriguez Neri is Director General of SDAE and ex-director of SGAE. His wife, Maria Antonia Garcia Pombo, is the ex-president of Microgenesis. Partner-Chief Legal Officer of Microgenesis is Eva Garcia Pombo. She is Neri’s sister-in-law.

Along with Microgenesis Partner-Chief Executive Officer Rafael Ramos, majority shareholder Elena Vazquez and Partner-Chief Financial Officer Celedonio Martin, all individuals mentioned in the last two paragraphs have been arrested.

The incestuous nature of the business between SGAE, SDAE, Microgenesis and other connected companies is said to have created an illegal and “beneficial economic relationship” for those involved.

It is a huge irony that SGAE, who have longed called for a file-sharing crackdown under a tougher copyright regime, and their partners Microgenesis, a company that provided pro-copyright and DRM solutions for SGAE, now stand accused of fraudulent activities involving funds that should have been for the exclusive use of those they claim to protect – the artists.

The bank accounts of SGAE, which by law is supposed to act as a strictly non-profit organization, have been frozen.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Anonymous

    Lol, seems like karma hit them hard and right back in the ass. Now if only the same can be done to MAFIAA… oh wait, nevermind, they pay the US Government, so they can get away scot free.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IZ5BM5GNLA54OADSWGSXAMA7SY Jay

      But if they aren’t paying taxes, the government would be ON them like white on rice.

      • Anonymous

        you mean the way they “go after” the top 1% for taxes here in the states?

        #FAIL

  • psychocydd

    lmfao!!!! busted…

  • Sketch

    What comes around ….. goes around….LMAO

  • Fred

    SWEET

  • GeorgeB

    U.S government is a corporation, so the MAFIAA will continue as always with impunity, paying their lobbying money as usual.

    Corruption at it’s finest.

    • http://otester.myopenid.com/ PiRat

      The US is incorporated so it has a legal standing in court.

  • Bill Coyne

    They hired the Fox to guard the hen house.

  • ChippyMcChirpson

    It’s weird, we all feel shocked to see this happening, when really there was no way around it.

    Let this be a reminder to alle the MAFIAA-organisations out there, that you should not be throwing stones if you live in a greenhouse.

  • ChippyMcChirpson

    It’s weird, we all feel shocked to see this happening, when really there was no way around it.

    Let this be a reminder to alle the MAFIAA-organisations out there, that you should not be throwing stones if you live in a greenhouse.

    • http://twitter.com/icanhazsake Ninja

      And they want ppl to watch their “you wouldn’t steal a car” shit. But no, this comes as no surprise for ppl that follow TF and copyright related issues. At least in Spain they get their arses busted unlike some other countries.

      We are seeing those idiots doing illegal raids and seizures, using money collected on behalf of artists to sponsor their own activities and other shady activities for a while now. Apparently the Govts and judicial systems are unable to see MAFIAA’s misdeeds. Or maybe they are lagging behind. Or maybe they are just as corrupt as MAFIAA.

  • Devin

    Is it just me, or has there been a lot of significant events happening in the world of copyright management lately?

    • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

      Indeed. There’s been surprisingly many SANE decisions lately. Copyright trolls struck down with force, this, etc.

  • http://twitter.com/ezee ezee

    I bet the other scumbags organizations around the world (like these two) are scrambling to see if they covered their tracks well enough or they are next…

  • Anonymous

    lol coming soon to an riaa/ifpi/ every other association near you .Don’t be so kind to these industries “karma” eventually catches up. It’s the artist who should be making the money not the label!! As a matter of fact they should only get 2% earnings. Managers usually get 10% to 15 %.Let this be a warning to the riaa/ifpi etc.. etc… YOU’RE NEXT!!!

    • Mccorm1n

      That’s what I though when I opened this message boobs grope definitely!!!

  • Rlslog

    does anyone know why rlslog.net is down it has been 2 days

  • John Space

    That’s how you catch Al Capone, officer.

    • muumi

      not that big fish here, but abusing power is quite impressive. Good news anyway…

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Don-Dilly/1624894683 Don Dilly

    aside from the raid, lets face it we know the pro copyright brigade are a bunch of dirty underhanded crooks that represent themselves, certainly not the artists.

    What struck me most about this article was that Spain already has a blank media levy ie you have paid a royalties tax on your blank discs wether you are going to put pirate content on or not.

    As that tax is intended to compensate the rights holder it should in a just and fair world be case closed. So why then try suing or threatening to disconnect downloaders who effectively have already paid. It should be 3 strikes/sue OR the disc levy, not both.

    • zenithmaster

      Well, actually file-sharing is legal in Spain. I’m not sure about this, but may be that’s why they have the disc levy.

    • zenithmaster

      Well, actually file-sharing is legal in Spain. I’m not sure about this, but may be that’s why they have the disc levy.

    • zenithmaster

      Oh, my bad. Further down someone commented that the law was changed earlier this year and it is now illegal to file-share in Spain too.

      • Harek

        file sharing is legal. What has been made “ilegal” (it’s kind of murky actually and a commission of so called “experts” are who’ll decide in each individual case instead of a judge) are sites that host or link to copyrighted content.
        http://epic.org/privacy/intl/lssi.html

  • Guest

    Hm, funny, A cammer posts stuff for profit yesterday, and he’s a bad apple who doesn’t have anything to do with the real filesharing community. An anti-piracy group gets caught, and they are the very model of what all of the other anti-piracy groups are and aspire to be. Interesting.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_V7VDZ5GW7EPEZNU7Y6M66BMLKY zar

      Nice straw man logical fallacy there, M*FIAA shill. We see through you though…

    • http://www.xbomber.co.uk/ Crash

      I took him to be a desperate individual who was enticed by any small amount of funds. He certainly wasn’t a responsible individual in a position to alter legislation.

      This is a company with a continuous revenue from an unfair tax on everyone that had the law changed for its benefit. I think it’s fair to hold them to a higher standard.

      At least this is one model that won’t be used elsewhere now that we’ve seen how well its worked, thanks to proper supervision.

    • Anonymous

      I believe Crash put it best. This is a company essentially wagging it’s finger at everyone and “looking out for the artists” and doing everything in their power to further their “cause” and at the end of the day they’re actually short changing the artists and abusing their power for their own illicit gain. They SHOULD be held to a higher standard.

      When your actions are actually worse than the “criminals” actions that you’re fighting against and more directly hurtful to the people you’re “looking out for”, you are pretty much asking to be put in your place. It appears they have been. Now, let justice be served. In the form of prison sentences and heavy fines. Or, perhaps better stated, time for them to get a taste of their own medicine.

      • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

        I vote for internet disconnection AND 4 years or so in jail (that’s what they’re lobbying for for filesharing) AND a settlement that deprives them of all of their savings (they’ve done exactly this to non-pirates, even, like the Phynd dev).

        What else? A ban on doing business for 15 yeras too, maybe?

        • http://twitter.com/icanhazsake Ninja

          An eye for an eye. Sounds interesting. “Disconnection” from business world might be one hell of a punishment. Still, your ideas are very appealing.

          As for Guest’s comment, if you take your head out of your own ass and breath some air you’ll see that most anti-piracy outfits do the same these Spanish ppl did to some degree. So uh.. Yes, they all aspire to make shitloads of money while paying laughable amounts to the artists.

  • Zzzz

    I hope our MAIFIAA shill friends comment on this soon, I’m quite eager to see how they manage to twist this into some sort of anti piracy propaganda.

    Please tell us how anti piracy officials stealing real money from artists is good for the fight against copyright infringement.

    • Nomnomnom

      They won’t reply.

      • Zzzz

        I know that but it’s fun baiting them.

        • FuzzyDuck

          Finally a really good example of people really stealing real money from real artists, yet it’s all silence from those who pretend to defend artists’ rights.

    • M8R-d00108

      There was one just before you. Didn’t you notice? :D

      “Hm, funny, A cammer posts stuff for profit yesterday, and he’s a bad apple who doesn’t have anything to do with the real filesharing community. An anti-piracy group gets caught, and they are the very model of what all of the other anti-piracy groups are and aspire to be. Interesting.”

  • reallyxxxxxxloud

    Reallyxxxxxxloud Fuck yeah… Bout time the other side crashed…

  • Pingback: Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud | We R Pirates

  • Pingback: La SGAE bajo fuego | Partido Pirata Uruguay

  • Turbo

    buhahah

  • Momo

    A taste of their own medicine. Hope they choke on it.

  • Joska

    It’s one of those good news I never thought I’ll ever hear, only in my wildest dreams! Finally the raiders got raided too. This made my day.
    The only better news could be if this had happened in my country or if my goverment took a flight into Katyn (Polish style).
    By the way, time to sniff around every countries parasite organisations, maybe such a fine event could be repeted elswhere too!

    • FuzzyDuck

      > The only better news could be if this had happened in my country or if my goverment took a flight into Katyn (Polish style).

      That’s so sick yet so funny.

  • R7

    incestuous nature…

    I lol’ed

    • Anonymous

      Yes a risky choice of word there and I doubt too many publications would use this word to describe an unnatural marriage of companies.

      Well if that is their thing I can only say enjoy it while you can when as seen it could not last.

  • http://www.facebook.com/jordan.kratz Jordan Kratz

    next up the USA.would love to see a bunch of artists in the USA do a class action suit against the MAFIAA.
    and lastly a big fuck you to all things RIAA/MPAA
    may you die a slow and painful death.

    • Blazeflack

      I’d rather those organisations died a very swift, but still painful, death.

      • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

        No, cripple them badly FIRST, and THEN they can die a slow and painful death. Good enough for you?

  • Erik2

    MPAA,RIAA, IFPI and other antipiracy groups do exactly same. We only need give hint about that to goverment tax offices and police. So they can raid all corrupted MAFIAA places in every country. That will be huge victory so start making lawsuits and inform goverment tax offices that MAFIAA do tax frauds.

  • Meh

    I always like reading the comments of these news stories – not necessarily for the appraisal of the subject, but because I know the trolls go into hiding =)

    • Anonymous

      And yet if the story was the other way around, “Torrent site raided, all equipment seized” or something like that, they’d be out in force. It’s all fun and games til the shoes on the other foot. And then all you hear is silence.

      • Guest123

        Ok, fine. If I really must…

        It seems to me that this is an example of the rule of law working. Corruption is caught and punished. So… what’s the problem here? Why is piracy and lawbreaking necessary when the system of laws seems to be working fine?

        • Anonymous

          Technically, “piracy” and “lawbreaking” don’t apply, particularly as this took place in Spain. Where file sharing is perfectly legal. (Unless of course the law has changed, I haven’t kept up on the goings on in Spain to be honest so I may be wrong.) It is however, quite sad to see a group such as this doing what they did. Yes they were caught, yes they will be punished, but that’s beside the point. Actions such as theirs are detrimental. People already think that groups such as this are hypocritical in that they seek monetary compensation in legal judgments and yet none of the monies received ever actually go to the artists. But to see that they are directly stealing funds. Come on, that just makes what people assume look to in fact be true.

        • Guest123

          Of course, because one example of a bad company can be used to damn an entire industry. It reeks of confirmation bias. People want to believe that the industry is evil, so they find evidence that supports the theory and disregard the rest.

          “Technically, “piracy” and “lawbreaking” don’t apply, particularly as this took place in Spain. Where file sharing is perfectly legal”

          It does apply because this is used as an excuse by people all over the world, not just countries where piracy is legal. I still don’t see how lawbreaking by a company justifies the lawbreaking by pirates.

        • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

          @Guest123: But you should start worrying when the ONLY evidence there are suggests that the entire industry TRULY ARE bad!

        • Anona

          I love the impersonal “they” in your comments, meant to refer to anyone on the opposite side in a way that homogenizes their views into one easy collective.

          And it’s not that the only evidence suggests that the industry is evil, it’s that pirates will overlook evidence to the contrary. That’s the whole “confirmation bias” thing guest123 was talking about.

        • Anonymous

          @ Guest123

          One example of a bad company/person/etc is enough to damn an entire group. Just look at the news. One drug addict robs a store and kills a person to get money for their fix. Suddenly all people who use drugs are die hard murderers just waiting to slit your throat for $5. One priest abuses little boys, suddenly people are in an uproar over the practices and tolerance of the entire Catholic church. One teenager shoots up a school and happened to be listening to Marilyn Manson a few days before he did it. All teenagers who listen to Marilyn Manson are going to shoot up a school and it’s just a matter of time. One Muslim blows up a building. All Muslims hate us and are just itching to do the same, so let’s declare war on essentially the entire religion.

          It’s just the way things are. The actions of one can and do often damn everyone else. It’s not right by any means, but it happens. And it might not be one, but a handful, and you still get the same result.

          And no one said that the lawbreaking done by this company justifies the lawbreaking done by the pirates. I haven’t said that, I don’t believe anyone else has in the comments so far. Unless you mean, some use that as an excuse (and don’t mean specifically in this article so far). But that’s irrelevant as it pertains to this article and this country. In Spain it is legal to file share, so “piracy” and “lawbreaking” don’t apply specifically to this article, case or this country. (Unless as I pointed out, the laws have changed recently.)

          But if you do wanna discuss that, I don’t, but let’s look at one thing. I don’t see how the actions of a few “pirates and lawbreakers” justifies the actions of companies in attempting to exert control over the entire internet and what can or can’t be viewed by others. We discussed this, you and I, the other day. They can block things in specific countries where the laws are in their favor, but not in countries like Spain. Why then are they doing so, or trying to do so?

          @ Anona

          I don’t think you aimed your comment at me, but I’d like to reply to it just the same in case you did. I don’t like homogenizing everyone’s views as you said. It’s too vague. Because there’s lots of middle ground and lots of grey areas. You can’t just lump people together, especially in regards to any of the stuff. File sharing. Copyright. Etc. But it does happen, and it’s done by everyone on all sides. Again, not necessarily right, but it just happens.

          I don’t think copyright should be abolished, just shortened. I think the laws that are being considered will be hurtful to people in general, in a non file sharing related way. I don’t think file sharing for profit is a good thing and should be punished. However, I think file sharing freely is okay, I have no problem with those who do it. But because of my views, I often get called a “pirate” and a “thief” and a “criminal”. When I’m none of those things. Well, maybe not that last one, I do tend to speed when driving. But that’s irrelevant. It still happens that I am called all those things and that’s being done by people on the other side of the debate.

          As you said, you feel pirates will overlook evidence to the contrary. But why say only that. If you read some comments on here, you’ll see anti-pirates do the same thing. Just as often. They’ll ignore the studies done that say pirates purchase more media legitimately than regular consumers. They’ll ignore the studies that show that file sharing has shown no direct or verifiable harm to artists in general. (I might have worded that weirdly, but I mean the studies where they determine that there is no correlation between piracy and monetary losses to movies, music, etc.) They ignore their own sides data that shows they’re (the industries) are making record breaking profits yearly and still claim to be losing money.

          I’m not saying you’re wrong. What I’m saying is don’t just point out one group when the other side is doing the same thing. If you want people to take what you say seriously, say that exact same thing to every person doing it. It’s going to keep happening, I doubt anything anyone says can change that, but what applies to one should apply to all. (And please don’t put a spin on that and make it into something I didn’t say.) I mean, if you’re pointing it out that pirates do it, point out that anti-pirates do it too. Otherwise it’s nitpicking.

        • Guest123

          “One drug addict robs a store and kills a person to get money for their fix. Suddenly all people who use drugs are die hard murderers just waiting to slit your throat for $5. One priest abuses little boys, suddenly people are in an uproar over the practices and tolerance of the entire Catholic church.”

          Do you think that’s acceptable? I’m not saying people won’t use widespread generalizations; I’m saying they shouldn’t. I know people will. I can see it happening right here, on this site. It’s not tolerable. We shouldn’t just wave it away as what people will do, and we defiantly shouldn’t try to change laws or business models based on this.

          “Unless you mean, some use that as an excuse (and don’t mean specifically in this article so far). But that’s irrelevant as it pertains to this article and this country. In Spain it is legal to file share, so “piracy” and “lawbreaking” don’t apply specifically to this article, case or this country. (Unless as I pointed out, the laws have changed recently.) ”

          People use the supposed corruption of the entire entertainment industry (and again, judgement is passed on all for the sins of some) as a justification for not paying. Do you really want me to post quotes supporting that? I don’t think most of us will argue. And it is relevant to this discussion because we aren’t just talking about Spain.

          “I don’t see how the actions of a few “pirates and lawbreakers” justifies the actions of companies in attempting to exert control over the entire internet and what can or can’t be viewed by others.”

          You’re right. They don’t. The lawbreaking of the pirates does not justify the lawbreaking of the pirates, even though the companies will say it does. Likewise, the lawbreaking of the companies does not justify the lawbreaking of the pirates, even though pirates will say they do.

        • Guest123

          Fix: The lawbreaking of pirates does not justify the lawbreaking of COMPANIES…

        • Anonymous

          @ Guest 123

          I know I didn’t post the answer to “do you think that’s acceptable” in the same section I replied to you, but I put I don’t think that’s acceptable in reply to Anona. Widespread generalization. I don’t like it when people do that, but it happens. I’m guilty of it too from time to time. And we shouldn’t just wave it away, but what do you propose we do about it? How do you keep people from generalizing? I’m also in agreement with you on we shouldn’t try to change laws or business models based on generalizations, but again, what can be done about that? You aren’t in charge. I’m not in charge. People on here aren’t either. It becomes an “us vs them” mentality. In that the industries are the us and everyone who doesn’t FULLY support them is “them”. Now, don’t mistake what I’m saying for something else. I’m saying some people in the industry who have spoken up or in other industries who’ve said anything about file sharing or about the laws regarding it and whatnot, have been branded and generalized as being against the industry. Even artists (be they musicians or film directors or writers). And the same goes for the opposite side of the debate. People who are for file sharing but not for strictly abolishing copyright come under attack. Again, how do you stop that? It’s easy for yourself or myself to say that shouldn’t be done, but what can people in as low a position as us do to deter that kind of thinking? You can spread facts and truth, but facts and truth won’t go far with people who have made up their mind. The best example I can give is the war on terror. I don’t approve of fighting in general. Be it one on one, me vs you or country A vs country B. I’m a pacifist. As such, I come under attack quite often as being “un-American”. I can argue my point of view and present all kinds of facts showing that us fighting and labeling all Muslims as “terrorists” causes more harm than good. But that still won’t keep people from saying all Muslims are terrorists and I’m un-American and thus if I don’t fully support the war then by default I’m supporting terrorism. You can’t reason with people who don’t have an open mind. (And as for an example of the artists coming under attack. I think, and I might be wrong, Lily Allen was one who caused quite an uproar. I believe at first she didn’t condone file sharing, she was like “whatever” about it. And the labels and industry made a big deal and she came under attack, because by not caring she was basically supporting it. So to negate that damage she wrote a scathing open letter to pirates and basically b*tched them the f*ck out. So then, fans and people who didn’t care for her music one way or another then got on the attack against her. And she became ostracized for that. I think she had even just released a new album which took a major sales hit, in that people decided to not buy, not necessarily “pirate” it, just not buy it at all, because of what she said in her letter. She lost on both sides and presented herself as flaky because she said one thing one day and another thing another. I might be wrong, but I do remember she wrote a letter and I do remember there was a major backlash. I could be confusing all of what happened to her with events that happened to someone else, it was quite awhile back.)

          And I won’t say don’t post quotes supporting that. It’s your prerogative and right to do just that. And I’ve seen those quotes myself. I’m not entirely in agreement with that mentality, but I do understand it. And for “this discussion”, I was referring to what I thought we were talking about. Specifically, the events stated in the article. In a general discussion, like we’re having and apparently have been having (which sorry to say I wasn’t fully aware of), it does relate. But for the article itself, it doesn’t.

          As for that last bit you wrote, it’s kind of a “damned if you do, damned if you don’t thing”. The ends do not justify the means. Etc. One side basis it’s actions and justifies them on the actions of the other and vice versa. But what can be done about that? Again, you can debate the point and present facts all you want or I want or anyone here wants, but it won’t budge either side. They’re both set in their viewpoints. It will budge people in support of one side or the other, assuming they are willing to acknowledge any points someone makes and are open to discussing things reasonably. But again, it comes down to the “us vs them” mentality. Both sides will justify their actions. It’s not right, as we’ve both said and agree about. But there’s very little that can be done to change that. The industries won’t listen to the thoughts of guys like me who are straddling the fence as far as their thoughts. And the pirates won’t listen to guys like you who are (I’m assuming) are reasonably doing the same. (Now, I say that because you are open to discussing things. And you aren’t one of those “copyright should be a gillion years and all pirates should be shot” type people.)

          It’s easy to say this is wrong or this is right. But what can be done to fix that? I’m not referring to piracy and copyright and the laws and all that. I’m talking about generalizing people. And the justifying things on both side. What can be done to fix it? It’s easy to recognize the problem and condone or not condone it. As we’ve both done, but neither of us has presented a solution. I can’t think of one. And I like to think of myself as a problem solving kinda guy. Can you?

        • Guest123

          There aren’t any solutions other than giving them what they want (for either side). Companies will always protect their profits and gouge prices to the limit of customer tolerance, and piracy won’t stop until everything is free in any format anyone wants it in (the very definition of when piracy can’t technically happen anymore). The only solution is trying to convince people to change their views, at least enough to accept a compromise, and ideally enough to throw away their misguided views. That’s what I’m trying to do; convince people that they are wrong. Uphill battle.

          If we just accept that people will believe what they believe and nothing can change them, why are we here discussing this. If our beliefs are set in stone, there is nothing to discuss.

    • Anonymous

      And yet if the story was the other way around, “Torrent site raided, all equipment seized” or something like that, they’d be out in force. It’s all fun and games til the shoes on the other foot. And then all you hear is silence.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IZ5BM5GNLA54OADSWGSXAMA7SY Jay

    And the world rejoiced as justice was served.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IZ5BM5GNLA54OADSWGSXAMA7SY Jay

    And the world rejoiced as justice was served.

  • dlj

    I did feel like I was still sleeping, if this doesn’t prove it then I don’t know what is real anymore.

    • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

      It IS real! So don’t think you’ve gone lucid in a dream and try jumping from a building to fly. That would be messy.

  • Predator

    Wha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

    Epic!

    ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

    All these corporate parasites in jail!

    ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

    All criminals! Sony, Vivendi, Time warner Viacom,RIAA, MPAA, BPI, IFPI

    They will all go to the slammer for good and we are going to throw the key!

    Wha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

    What’s happened? Did the run out of corruption money?

    ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

  • Predator

    “And the world rejoiced as justice was served.”

    Only 9 arrested?

    Shall we shoot the rest?

  • Predator

    “And the world rejoiced as justice was served.”

    Only 9 arrested?

    Shall we shoot the rest?

  • DoNotReply

    Interesting, hopefully this progresses to a proper (not a show) trial and generates some interesting results.

  • DoNotReply

    Interesting, hopefully this progresses to a proper (not a show) trial and generates some interesting results.

  • Pingback: P2PTalk » Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud

  • FuzzyDuck

    Look who turns out to be stealing* from artists….

    * as in the *real* definition of the word stealing.

  • http://twitter.com/a1049 anTon

    Let’s not forget that this is the result of good people who didn’t just whince about the evil big wigs but did some research on their own (quite a lot, and quite tiresome!), and handed the evidence to the police! They are an example for all of us!

  • Brandon-is-a-spass

    This made my day. Now I can go to sleep knowing some corrupted fucktard guys are sitting in a cell awaiting trial and years behind bars. Cant become a better day for me hahaha.

    Now if only the RIAA, BPI, IFPA and whatever those organizations are called can get similar slap in the face I’d be laughing all the way down the street (not the bank ‘cuz i dont make any money of it). I’m pretty sure RIAA has hired “consultants” and “firms” that are going to help in their operations, but that are the family members of the executives. I hope they get done for corruption cus as far as I know the artists who belong to these organization never see a dime when “filesharers” get convicted or they collect royalties.

    Corrupt f*cks!

  • Anonymous

    So not only were they stealing from their own customers (the artists) but they also wanted tougher copyright laws with the glint of personal greed in their eyes.

    Jail time and large fines now await them. And good work to their tax service.gher copyright laws with the glint of personal greed in their eyes.

    Jail time and large fines now await them. And good work to their tax service.

  • Pingback: === popurls.com === popular today

  • Haxor

    CRIA in canada same thing they did but no charges cause it goes even higher right to the prime minister

  • WTF

    I bet they had pirated copies of Windows on their PC’s

  • http://disqus.com/ Rob8urcakes

    The only thing that surprises me about this story is that it hasn’t occurred already in every Country that has these stupid copywrong laws.

    Now maybe governments will listen to us when we DEMAND a drastic change to these laws in order to remove this corrupt industry and it’s paid thugs and mercenaries (eg see the Filesoup case).

    Major kudos to Spain and the authorities.

  • Pingback: Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud | Links Daily

  • Anon

    Industry = Corruption and exploitation. We’re doing everyone a favor by destroying the industry. When the industry is gone, only then can music truly thrive.

    • http://profiles.google.com/neme27ep sarge .

      But music has truly thrived before when industry was there. Sinatra, Crosby, Armstrong, BB King, Beatles, Who, Kinks, Animals… They were all there when the industry was around, and good music was there to enjoy.

      I don’t think the music industry as a whole is the problem, just their means of business. That and the overall larger emphasis put on wealth in today’s culture.

      • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

        The industry didn’t “make” most of them. It only found them and profited of them.

        • http://profiles.google.com/neme27ep sarge .

          ..hence why I said “just their means of business”.

  • Anon

    Industry = Corruption and exploitation. We’re doing everyone a favor by destroying the industry. When the industry is gone, only then can music truly thrive.

  • Anonymous

    Awesome! Best thing that has happened to the world today. Let’s hope they will have to spend their time in jail ‘next to someone who’s been there for a while and is looking for a new girlfriend’

  • Viking

    Now the REAL thieves got pwned!

  • http://tinyurl.com/ANoiXioNA-personal-info ANoiXioNA

    Happiest article in a while… :¬) Thanks @TF

    Now lets hope the riaa can get it for collecting royalties for music ……
    that they have NO RIGHT to collect…..

  • http://tinyurl.com/ANoiXioNA-personal-info ANoiXioNA

    Happiest article in a while… :¬) Thanks @TF

    Now lets hope the riaa can get it for collecting royalties for music ……
    that they have NO RIGHT to collect…..

  • Pingback: Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud | TorrentFreak | NotSoCrazyNews BETA

  • Lothor The Evil

    Oh snap! This just proves what people have been saying all along that the artists get screwed over by the copyright holders. It also proves the anti-piracy dolts are way bigger crooks than file-sharers.

  • CLL

    Weren’t they trying to get an anti-filesharing law passed in Spain? With this happening, I have a feeling that the law might not go through now. :)

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PXX4S66KOUIGIKTTIMV3CBGO7Y Colin

      Sad to say, much against the wishes of the Spanish people, the law was passed earlier this year.

  • http://www.thecomplexmedia.com/blog theComplex

    this makes me smile. Who’s next?

  • Phil Landry

    So copyright infringement is bad, but actually steeling was ok??? I hope they get what they deserve, because they did a REAL crime, that actually does strips artists of their money…

  • Anonymous

    Time to hack the others now.

  • Gil

    MWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jarrett Tennis

    Fantastic!

  • Morpheus

    Excuse me offtopic.
    Please add _Subscribe by Twitter_ button to the bar.
    TIA

  • http://natanael.posterous.com/ Natanael L

    How can you not like this story?

    They are consistently claiming moral high ground, and they re conistently proving that they only are lying.

  • http://profiles.google.com/zerianis10 Christopher Kidwell

    Karma in action here…… just plain old K A R M A biting them in the butt.

  • http://www.firedub.com/ SupamaN
  • Anon

    A pro-copyright organization that is corrupt? Damn, that’s totally irregular!

    • Guest

      HAHAHA

      /me loves sarcasm

  • AnarchyNow

    It seems that Spain is going to resist the worse than nazi U$ take-over.
    We’re not gonna be slaves for the completely useless record industry.
    Music is FREE!

    • Guest

      hello troll

    • Guest

      hello troll

  • AnarchyNow

    It seems that Spain is going to resist the worse than nazi U$ take-over.
    We’re not gonna be slaves for the completely useless record industry.
    Music is FREE!

  • Worwich53036034

    woww that great

  • Oxana

    Artists can manage their own music copyright, by using creative commons licenses or set their own conditions at http://www.villamusicrights.com

  • Pingback: Music Rights Group SGAE Raided And Directors Arrested | TechFruit

  • Pingback: Morning Coffee with David Farrell, July 4

  • Pingback: X-Wall-Newspaper » ???????……???????

  • Guest

    The system is corruption. Money leads to corruption. Countries are corrupt. Society is corrupt.

    nothing to see here

  • videocollector

    Anyone noticed this yet Ifpi may be in the same boat LoL

    http://www.zeropaid.com/news/94106/ifpi-boss-and-ceo-accused-of-tax-evasion-in-germany/

  • Thiswillsavemusic

    There is a simple solution to this problem:

    thiswillsavemusic.blogspot.com

    I outline my 4-step approach to saving the music industry – it probably would require a very strong individual or group (such as the RIAA) or a government who can foresee the declining point in copyright law to implement sadly.

    The spotify move by Virgin may be a first step in this direction though.

    • Friend of the People

      A few things. First, you aren’t saving music, you’re changing it. It may be a positive change, but music would survive in commercial and non-commercial forms without this change.

      Second, I’m seeing a few flaws. You’re talking about a subscription model that rewards artists based on how much time people spend listening to their music, but you also talk about letting people download music. Why would I continue to use the subscription service after I had downloaded copies of the music? Why would I continue to pay for something I already had? And if you aren’t going to let people download copies of the music, what’s the particular attraction to your product? Why would it succeed over piracy, which does offer copies? There would also be problems making the system profitable for the owners of the distribution site without increasing the price to much on consumers.

      It would probably be easier to start then you think. It just needs a few groups to sign on as starters and give bonuses to groups that join early. It would take some capital, but it’s definitely doable without someone like the RIAA mandating membership.

      It’s a workable model, and probably a better one then we have now (almost certainly better), but don’t say that it’s simple. It would have some issues that would need to be ironed out, particularly since no one has tried a model like this before..

      One smaller question; Why would albums be important? Why wouldn’t artists just release songs as they came out? I’ve just never understood people’s attraction to the album format of music. Seems kind of pointless to me.

  • Pingback: makin257 - Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud

  • Pingback: Spanish authorities bust suspected law-breaking anti-piracy group | MyCE – My Consumer Electronics

  • Guest

    For once, JUSTICE HAS PREVAILED!

  • Pingback: 3 Count: Tug of War

  • Pingback: Music Rights Groups Raided By Police, Bosses Arrested For Fraud

  • Pingback: Engagements and Accolades July 1-8 » Blog | NetShelter Technology Media

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

  • Pirates Can Be Identified Despite Sharing IP Addresses, ISP Claims

    Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation is a network mechanism through which many Internet subscribers can share the...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.