TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Top BitTorrent Trackers Face Major Downtime

For nearly a week the two largest BitTorrent trackers on the Internet have been mostly offline. With the recent DDoS attacks at BitTorrent sites in mind, some feared that both OpenBitTorrent and PublicBitTorrent were victims of a similar assault. Although both trackers are indeed overloaded, the origin is friendly fire this time.

OpenBitTorrent and PublicBitTorrent are two non-commercial BitTorrent trackers running on the beerware licensed Opentracker software. Neither service hosts or links to torrent files and both are free to use by all BitTorrent users.

The trackers were listed as number one and two in our latest list of most-used trackers, and both are generally coordinating the downloads of 20 million people at any given point in time.

Despite the seemingly neutral setup, OpenBitTorrent has had its fair share of legal issues in the last year. Both Hollywood and the music industry have declared war against what they see as an illegal service. After Hollywood won its case against the former provider of OpenBitTorrent, IFPI went after its new host in Spain, forcing the tracker to move again.

Considering this turbulent history, it is no surprise that many users were fearing the worst when OpenBitTorrent became unresponsive last week. However, this time the outages have nothing to do with legal threats.

OpenBitTorrent

openbittorrent

TorrentFreak contacted the operator of the tracker who informed us that the downtime is related to an increasing number of users. The servers are simply overloaded and can’t handle all requests. We were ensured that the problems will be dealt with but it is expected that this might take a few days.

As a direct result of the problems at OpenBitTorrent, the only other major tracker PublicBitTorrent had to deal with many extra users, again causing trouble. This week, PublicBitTorrent has been unresponsive for half of the time as their servers are overloaded as well. This is a prime example of how vulnerable the BitTorrent tracker ecosystem is.

The operator of PublicBitTorrent told TorrentFreak that extra servers are on the way. Hopefully this will solve the problems, but it is expected to take up to a week before everything’s setup properly.

The upside to all the bad news is that most people can still download torrents. Instead of using a tracker, most downloads work fine when they solely rely on DHT and PEX. Hopefully, both trackers will be fully functioning by the end of next week.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • CFultz

    This wont stop or slow anyone down.

  • Anonymous

    However, why not just use DHT and PEX which I believe torrentfreak itself pointed out are not monitored by data collectors (which is then passed on to companies such as ACS:Law)

  • NewEraCracker

    1st comment

  • NewEraCracker

    @3

    ACS:Law is dead :D

  • Tard-Spnaker!

    Firstwat…

  • www.tinychan.org

    What about those of us who have clients who don’t support DHT/PEX?

  • me

    #3 Anonymous “However, why not just use DHT and PEX which I believe torrentfreak itself pointed out are not monitored by data collectors (which is then passed on to companies such as ACS:Law)”

    I highly doubt that DHT swarms are not regularly monitored. Been at defcon lately?

    https://www.defcon.org/images/defcon-18/dc-18-presentations/Wolchok/DEFCON-18-Wolchok-Crawling-Bittorrent-DHTS.pdf

  • Maxx Ormis

    DHT and PEX are the future, the fact that these are down and people don’t notice proves that they work as intended.

  • Anonymous

    @7 install one that does

  • ?uesto

    @7 http://www.transmissionbt.com/download.php for linux / mac

    utorrent for windows

  • worpre

    I use magnet links all the time now.

  • Acce

    I noticed it, and I was surprised there were no article sooner! Even if pex and dht is useful, it’s not as fast to collect a lot of fresh IPs. I use trackers over tor and it works fine.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Top BitTorrent Trackers Face Major Downtime | TorrentFreak -- Topsy.com

  • politux

    Deluge works well.

  • Ash Ketchum

    Downloads have been working fine for me with DHT and PEX.

    Only had problem with one torrent where it wasn’t finding enough seeds but I managed to finish it by adding a web seed. :D

    Once it finished downloading though, utorrent magically started finding tons of seeds.

  • DoctorMouse

    Well, I’m just glad it’s nothing too serious.

  • Quad-K

    Hope this is resolved, my torrent keeps getting spammed !

  • Yorlik

    Pirate Bay seems to be having problems as well. No new Torrents have been added for over 24 hours now.

  • X

    I challenge p2p developers to make a decentralized indexing site and tracker. ;)

  • Anonymous

    DHT.

  • COICA

    I second the need for an article on this subject.

    https://www.eff.org/coica

  • Ninja

    A tracker is needed to start a torrent and make it healthy.

    Those guys from OBT and PBT are just awesome. I wish they keep rocking. Also, are there any public alternatives besides the denis one? Just in case

  • Retired Hacker

    In the public knowledge several reasons exist why IP tracking data can be wrong including wireless.

    A hacker as part of his/her exploration can visit hundreds or even thousands of computer systems.

    In some cases two tasks are then done. The first can be to close the security holes to prevent other unauthorized access including removing any viruses or trojans. Nice hacker cleans your house and takes control.

    The second task is to create their own access including FTP, optional bot and more that I wont state.

    One of these small additional files left is an anonymous proxy server running as a service task.

    This is used by a hacker to avoid direct connections to other risky computers.

    All well and nice but there is one problem which is other people doing port scans looking for anonymous proxy servers.

    Fair enough but the problem then is if they then use this connection for obtaining copyrighted files including via BT.

    The computer owner may never know. Their computer gets the BT data and forwards it across the proxy link without them even having a BT client installed.

    Proof that even their best claims can be false. I believe the public should know one reason why they can get such letters like from ACS:Law.

  • mule

    All the Edonkey servers were hunted to extinction years ago.

    It’s amazing that public torrent trackers have survived as long as they have.

  • Pico

    I’ve been exclusively using the tracker provided by the Russian EX.UA hosting service for over a year now. I have yet to see any downtime on this tracker so it’s been extremely reliable so far and I will continue to use it over the popular openbbittorrent and publicbt ones (which I use as secondary ‘backup’ trackers in my torrents), which have been down multiple times due to overload. Mind you, the EX.UA tracker is also pretty heavily loaded, but still keeps running without any issues so far

    http://tracker.ex.ua/announce

  • Phillip

    Strangely I started work on a node.js tracker this morning.

    Personally I think the way to go soon will be for indexers to remove trackers and add themselves or their preferred trackers to torrents.
    Add in a tracker exchange protocol and we are set.

    This way as the hydra grows a singular torrent distributed among dozens of indexes or trackers will form several super swarms rather than a single swarm around one or two trackers.
    Each of which can be bridged via dht/pex.

    This way we aren’t putting insane loads on any single point, but if one should fail anyone using dht/pex can hand out new/working trackers to other clients.

  • Mayank

    Could someone tell me as to why is http://www.hdbits.ro not opening up for the past 2 weeks now ?? thank u

  • Pingback: Ten Most Used BitTorrent Site | Queen of Random

  • quidcilshar

    it seems that there are big problems over at the piratebay, any news on that?

    no new torrents for 36hrs
    no seeds no leechs
    and seems as tho there are no file associated as when i tried to download a random torrent it was empty.

  • anonymous

    @ 27
    The seeds and leechs are wrongly showing as 0.
    Presently, one is able to download through Magnet Link only.

  • anonymous

    @ 26 Mayank
    Now it is opening up.

  • ano nym ous

    Comment 6: “What about those of us who have clients who don’t support DHT/PEX?”

    2004 called, they want their BT-client back.

  • Mayank

    @29. are you sure ? i’m from india, and it isn’t opening up. though the earlier msg. off high server load is GONE. Replaced with : “Oops! Google Chrome could not connect to http://www.hd-bits.ro

  • Anonymous

    Well, I have seen a significant drop in torrent activity, so I cannot confirm that things work as normal without trackers online. These are small torrents with very few peers, which I presume are most easily affected.

  • VPN

    I always use them. Thanks for providing the service.

  • Anonymous

    It’s over. Can’t fight the US government and expect to win.

  • Anonymous

    You guys love to whine about censorship, but that’s what you spend most of your day doing, isn’t it?

    Hypocritical douchebags.

    We’re killing you and it feels great.

  • Brudda

    Yesterday, I tried to dl 2 different torrent files from TPB. The first one wouldn’t dl at all (I tried about 5x). The 2nd one dl OK, but when I went to open it with utorrent, it was no good. Luckily, the magnet links worked and I got what I wanted. Anybody else have any problems like this with TPB lately?

  • quidcilshar

    @ 28

    massive probs with piratebay

    magnet links are only showing empty torrents with no file assciated with the link it is EMPTY

    as i stated in my previous post.

    does anybody have a clue as to what has happened there?

    is this something to do with the current ongoing appeal?

    have they finnaly pulled the plug?

    i hope not.

  • Gargamel

    @37

    who gives a $hit its just the piratebay. Find a real tracker.

  • anonymous

    @ 37
    I am able to download through Magnet Link without any problem.

  • Anonymous

    I cant use magnet links in utorrent the same way as normal torrent files. This keeps me from using magnet magnet linksinstead of torrent files.

  • dan

    i dl a lot of tv shows in the past days and thanks to dht and pex i didn’t even notice any difference in my dl speed, awesome!

  • Anon

    @ 37

    The magnet link doesn’t hold the file information – add the torrent and it finds the data from the swarm. Then it will d/l fine.

  • Pingback: Top BitTorrent Trackers Face Major Downtime | Systema

  • Historian

    torrentz.com/i

  • Jeroenz0r

    DHT and PEX still working fine, trackers are not needed to continue piracy! :P

  • Anonymous

    @23, nah edonkey servers are still alive & working fine

    I prefer edonkey2000 network anyway than torrents, they always seemed behind really as a)need torrent file or database to get magnet link,
    b) often need tracker byt not always

    with my edonkey, I don’t need anything but client and so if all servers went down, (not likely though) no databases, I still get me files… Fuk the bus government & censorship

  • diesel

    Torrent trackers are almost obsolete; their main task has been passed along to the peers.

    But a short term effect of not having trackers is that there are no stats on websites (eg. how many seeders?). Also, torrents might be take a bit longer to start downloading (often several seconds).

    Hosting torrent files is also unnecessary; most modern clients can get the torrent file from peers using just a magnet:? link. http://flickmag.net/magnet-download-instructions.php

  • Ayatholla

    Well, time is passing and neither OBT or PublicBt are back. I am among those who think that a tracker is needed to keep not so common torrents alive. However, adding trackers is a slow process since already registered torrents will not change if you just ad a tracker in your torrent program (with some exceptions).

    So, without knowing if the two mayor trackers will start again, I suggest it is time to ad some more trackers to new torrents.

    I have myself started to ad two trackers in the former Soviet Union:

    udp://tracker.openbittorrent.kg:2710/announce
    http://tracker.openbittorrent.kg:2710/announce

    http://tracker.irc.su/announce

    They are working, and I think is would be nice places for the media industry to start new law suits in!

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.