TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Anti-Piracy Outfits Launch Attack on BitTorrent Protocol

In recent weeks alarm bells sounded at Poland’s Computer Emergency Response Team when it was discovered that an unknown entity is sending massive amounts of forged data packets and posing a threat to BitTorrent users worldwide. A detailed analysis reveals that anti-piracy outfits may be initiating these attacks to prevent movies from being downloaded. According to security experts, the legality of these attacks is doubtful.

dangerAccording to the Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT) in Poland, BitTorrent’s uTP protocol is under attack.

The security experts have observed a massive spike in activity compared to 2011, mostly originating from locations in Russia, Canada, China, Australia and the USA.

The CERT group operates a system that scans for online threats and the attack on BitTorrent triggered several of their honeypot sensors. These attack sources send data packages that appear to be legitimate, but the IP-addresses they send are forged.

The security researchers, who say these poisoning attacks are happening on a massive scale, observe that they are targeted at specific BitTorrent swarms sharing Russian movie releases.

One of the likely explanations for these poisoning attacks is that anti-piracy outfits are utilizing them to “protect” their clients’ movies. For example, these outfits could overload BitTorrent swarms with corrupt data or “disconnect” messages while masquerading as legitimate downloaders.

This is exactly what the Microsoft funded startup Pirate Pay appears to be doing although other companies may also use similar methods. A company called ICM is currently listed as “protecting” the Russian film that was the subject of the attacks identified by CERT.

The security researchers don’t make any conclusive claims about the origins of the attacks, but they do note that anti-piracy groups are a possible source.

“At least one interest group that would benefit from uTP poisoning is easy to point at: multimedia companies and their subcontractors. Conduction of this kind of campaign by these institutions wouldn’t be precedent. It’s also possible that generated traffic is used for BitTorrent network mapping and data gathering for later use in other projects,” CERT comments.

Perhaps of even more interest, CERT also notes that the poisoning attack, or anomaly as they call it, may very well breach cybersecurity law.

“[The attacks] produce visible disruption in IT systems and large amounts of our false-positive high-level alerts is a good proof. In terms of Polish law, European Convention on Cybercrime and U.S. Codes (and probably many other sources of domestic law) legality of process producing the anomaly is questionable,” the security experts note.

In other words, the techniques these anti-piracy outfits appear to be using to prevent people from sharing copyrighted movies could be illegal. If that is the case then the movie companies who hire these anti-piracy outfits may be complicit in cybersecurity crimes.

That would be a problem.

TorrentFreak contacted the CEO of the Microsoft-funded Pirate Pay for a comment on the legality of his service, but we are yet to receive a reply. More details about the specifics of the attacks are available on the CERT website.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Mwhahaha

    Excuse me officer, I was trying to illegally download this movie when my data stream got poisoned… 

    • Anyone

      the people downloading it could own a DVD or similar and just want a backup

      you know what happens when you assume

      • AnalRupture

        That sounds like a format shift – we all know that’s tantamount to buying a pair of socks, but wearing them like gloves which means you’re stealing mittens!

        • It’s a fit-up

          For mercy sake, why won’t somebody think of the mittens.

        • yello

          i like icecream…

        • ThatGuyOverThere

          Stealing mittens, and the money from being forced to buy a second pair right out of the Mega Mittens corporation CEO’s children’s trust fund. What has this world come to when people don’t want to pay for things more than once?

        • Kablah

          Mittens no fit… wanna find some right size for my cock. Ah… there you are

        • Anonymous

          my best friend’s sister-in-law got paid $14696 the prior month. she is making money on the inte<!–truth is almight–>rnet and bought a $372500 home. All she did was get blessed and work up the steps uncovered on this link ===>> ?????? http://seekingguru.blogspot.com

        • Anonymous

          my friend’s aunt brought home $17621 last month. she gets paid on the internet and bought a $566900 condo. All she did was get blessed and work up the guide revealed on this web site===>> ?????? http://uniquejoboffer.blogspot.com

      • Anonymous

        my roomate’s st ep-mot her brought ho me $1 3342 the previous mo nth. s he g ets pa id on the c omputer and bo ught a $ 369300 c ondo. All she did was get lucky and pr ofit by the ad vice u ncove red on this w eb pa ge ===>> ?????? http://hiringfreelancers.blogspot.com

      • Anonymous

        my buddy’s sister-in-law made $18108 a month ago. she worrks on the internet and bought a $525400 condo. All she did was get blessed and put into action the instructions given on this website ===>> ?????? http://hiringfreelancers.blogspot.com

    • Occasionally_S

      FTFY:
      Escuse me officer, I was trying to share our last up to date open source code that we’re creating with my co-workers when my data stream got poisoned …People and their pre-conceived ideas …Weed smokers are junkies, right? They’re all young, lazy, stupid and dirty.

      Just like BitTorrent, it’s used by pirates and by regular people sharing their files for work or personal use, of course people like you assume the contrary because you know next to nothing about it and just follows the mainsteam media stance … and yet you comment on it … repeating what you’ve learned on FOX news, just like a good little mindless sheep you are.

      • http://twitter.com/Life1sPeachy DarkSideOfLife

        did u read the article ? they are doing this for specific movies NOT all bittorent protocol…

        • Anonymous

           Because they have never issued a wrong takedown because they do just simple word matching…  They assume it all must be infringing because a single word matches.  They take down other peoples works and commit copyfraud because there is no one willing to actually pay for a case and the court would just pat them on the head and say ok while deciding a regular person they accuse has to be guilty and throw the book at them.
          They have a long history of shoot first then see if it actually was their property after the damage has been done.

        • anon

           ya just like the entertainment industry sends out robots to do DMCA claims and shoots innocent links at the same time. This is no different there will be some legit legal content caught in the cross fire.

        • Guest

          Yeah, because copyright software company have absolutely NO history of trying to eliminate open source alternatives (or even trying to claim ownership)

        • http://www.facebook.com/orphicdragon Trisha Lynn Dragon

          Yeah right Skippy.

          When the word used to determine what to poison is “The” or “A” let us know how that  works out for you. 

          Moron.

    • Guest

      lol

      Mwhahaha’s totally given up on pretending he isn’t a copyright industry troll, hasn’t he? 

      • crap old meme

        Actually it’s like two different people.
        Going back a year or so….. he didn’t seem like an industry troll at all.
        last few months however.
        playing the long game… nice tactic….it’s working

        He has converted over 9000 fileshares…. true story !

        • Oi Polloi

          He’s turned 9000 people into filesharers? Well done that troll – just like all the MAFIAA tactics, they just increase the Streisand effect!

        • crap old meme

          no…
          He has converted over 9000 fileshares into anti-pirate groupie bitches.
          really…….
          Was sarcasm at the fail hard tactics of an anti-pirate troll mong.

          “”He’s turned over 9000 people into filesharers”"
          your way works to…. he still failed epically at his faggotry agenda.

          No reward …. of cocaine and whores for @1a2d411eb5ed6109b2fc111f58871c5b:disqus

        • tsk tsk

          So Mwhahaha = mafiaa undercover… Looks rather gay and unconvincing. They should’ve at least send in a sexy bomb shell. Poor choice

    • Abab

      Excuse me, I was just trying to update my world of warcraft game which I pay monthly for but somebody poisoned my data stream.

      • I jest ….nothing more

        WOW…..not w.o.w……. but….. WOW …..people still play w.o.w.

      • Lord of the Files

        Luxology uses torrents to distribute their software. It’s a really good choice for that and makes me wonder if someone has ever bothered to make a list beyond the obvious ones, like Linux and WoW.

    • YARIGHT

      https://www.uha1.com/15-mug.jpg <—- ya excuse me aswipe your website wasnt working

    • Anonymous

      In what we download not everything is copyrighted, there’s also free stuff

  • Anonymous

     since when have any of the entertainment industries or their arse licking subsidiaries been concerned about breaking the law? if it is someone doing something those industries dont like, legal or not, they instigate court proceedings. add the money they spend on getting laws changed/added that suit only them and the companies they have forced into bankruptcy and the picture of who is doing illegal stuff is clear, and it sure aint the ordinary citizens!!! when it is them doing the law breaking, it’s supposed to be ok, everyone is supposed to turn a blind eye and let them carry on. will be interesting to see how far this is investigated and if the culprits are found to be those industries, just what will be done. i would hazard a guess at FUCK ALL!!!

    • Anonymous

      They’d be VERY concerned about the law when the FBI jackboot their doors in with a warrant, and arrest anyone that moves whilst confiscating all equipment for evidence!

      Oh and I don’t think the RIAA is capable of bribing a federal judge during a criminal case, do you?

      • Occasionally_S

        You really don’t think that the FBI protects the interests of Hollywood? Think again.

        • Anonymous

          They do, until they break the law that is!

        • Guest

          Hahahahahahaha.

          If the FBI gave half a shit about punishing Hollywood for breaking the law in the name of copyright protection, then they would have launched a massive investigation on multiple fronts after the MegaUpload raid took place.

          I believe they’d also be investigating Chris Dodd for the time he outright told politicians to do his bidding or else he’ll stop paying them.  

      • Guest

        Well, they were perfectly capable of publicly threatening politicans so I’d say yes, they are probably capable of – and have – bribed federal judges.

        • Anonymous

          Too bad it wasn’t them vs the government, the government would be quick to notice the backhanders going on and really give the MAFIAA the smackdown.

        • Guest

           I would love to see proof of your claim that they’ve bribed federal judges.  Because if you had such proof, that person wouldn’t be a judge anymore.  Federal judges have the most insane financial disclosure requirements.  If they drop a penny on the ground and someone picks it up for them, there’s likely a report written about it somewhere.

          Only thirteen federal judges have ever been impeached.

          http://www.fjc.gov/history/home.nsf/page/judges_impeachments.html

      • Anon

        Yes and no. Directly no way they won’t risk going to Jail even at 1% risk they are all ivy leaguers now and way to slick for that – indirectly they do it daily it is called lobbying.

        They do things like try to meet certain officials “to have a chat over lunch” you actually can do this with numerous public officials (elected and unelected they are like a train to the next official). They keep complex databases and “charts” of who they are speaking with, what about, who is next to target, who is a tough nut to crack, what schools they all went to, spouse and children’s names, birthdays etc….endless data mash to become friendly and thus influence a persons views. It is a VERY sophisticated long game and the USA are by far the best at it – but with that they have the biggest lobby cancer stuck on their system pulling it down than any other nation.

        It is all done in a very delicate manner.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Don-Dilly/1624894683 Don Dilly

    Bye Bye USA 6 strikes programme  

    • John Regifgtydesahg

      Why’s that?

      • Anon1

        I think he’s saying the MAFIAA will see these attacks and force ISP’s to use them rather than the six strikes program.

  • Anon

    People! It’s Poland ! Who cares!

    • morr

      Internet knows no country borders, dumbass.

    • Occasionally_S

      Typical american, right?

      • Ralph Brubaker

        Typical online banter.

        • World exists out there

          No… typical American

          Only 4.47%
          of the worlds population ….but the only part of the world that matters

        • Dfdfhdf

          Internet has no borders :P

          It’s like Afghanistan, some countries are trying to claim it, yet they fail.

    • Abab

       Polish people care. When it is USA where I do not like…. WHO CARES?

      • Abab

         DO not LIVE… not do not like :)  wrong spelling lol.

      • Souptooth

        When you children grow up you’ll realize that every country has idiots.
        You are proof that your country has idiot, just like the US where yes, there are idiots.
        You all fall for popular pressure to say what you think is internet cool.
        Nice free thinking intellects the lot of you.

    • Oi Polloi
      • Winston

        We’ll fight them with data breaches.

        Well, I tried.

  • Mr President

    Disrupt Internet Infrastructure = Terrorism ;)

    • Dollarse

      Governments make laws.
      They don’t have to follow the laws.
      ‘doh

      • chmod775

        Of course they have to. It’s called constitutionality or rule of law.

    • Anonymous

      Whose terrified?

      • Grammar dick

        It’s not my terrified.
        C’mon …. man up……Whose terrified is it ?

        • Anonymous

          That’s what I’m wondering, as I seem to have a bunch of terrifieds here for some reason.  I’m guessing I must have picked it up from somewhere thinking it was mine…

          ?

  • Cunty

    Sorry to play devil’s advocate – but what law is this breaking?

    Swarms are by their nature open and allow anyone to join. I don’t remember agreeing to any terms or conditions that would limit my activity?

    • Anyone

      anyone can connect to a webserver

      launching a DDOS attack against it is still illegal

    • http://profiles.google.com/sol.europa Bill C

      It’s against most international computer laws to actively disrupt a computer network or system (i.e. DDoS attacks)

      By sending all of these “fake” p2p packets the company is basically doing a DDoS attack on Bit Torrent servers and therefore it’s illegal.

      • Jimbo

         the difference here being that if it were you, I, LulSec, Anonymous or Uncle Tom Cobley doing this, particularly against a business (even though this may well be a legitimate business?), there would be all hell let loose. this would be classed as cyber terrorism if it were being done by
        anyone else and there would be joint operations going on worldwide to
        catch those responsible. as it is looking like it’s the entertainment industries or their lackeys, no one is going to give a flying toss, simply because of the amount of money that has already been thrown at heads of law enforcement and governments. when it suits, it suits, when it dont, it dont. hypocrisy at it’s finest!!

    • Guest

      Uh, cybercrime laws? Maybe you should read the article instead of just looking at the headline?

      • Cunty

        Oh – cybercrime laws? My bad, I must have missed that pin-point-accurate description of a specific offense! You know exactly what I know, which is fuck all. The difference between us is that I know that.

        Thanks to Bill C and Anyone for the insight! :)

        ICM seems to be a Russian/Ukranian outfit, so does that mean its activities need to be dealt with under Russian law, or can we (well, maybe the EFF or someone) use the anti-pirates’ own perverse logic to get them under US/EU law?

        • Huddel

          Communication infrastructure is of primary strategic interest for every single government in this planet, this does not only includes telephone lines and radio waves, but this includes the internet. 

          By disrupting the data flow you’re interfering in the way normal functioning of that infrastructure – hell, governments need court order to do something remotely like that because it is tampering with communications.When they do that, they’re clearing stepping on the prerrogatives that governments set by their own and bound to get someone on  their ass. It won’t be long until they get the FSB or other russian/ukrainian/ federal agency knocking on their door – be it by their own initiative or by pressure/request/collaboration with foreign governments and instutions, like EU or even the good ol’ US of A.Not only that, but if any legimate venture gets screwed by this they will be sued by disruption of service and collateral damages.

          There’s the jerkish behaviour of pushing the law boundaries, and there’s the outright crossing the line and jumping on the full illegal behaviour – copyright holders seemed to have choosen to do the later now, and did so in broad daylight.

        • Tyler

          good point about the Russian actions and what law they should fall on. that being said, we have American companies pursuing non American citizen, who committed copyright violations in countries that are not the USA. it’s like me saying something bad about the Thai monarchy and getting extradited to face Thai litigators, even though in my country it’s not illegal. copyright violations should be civil issued, not federal agenda

    • Abab

       If you left your front door open would it be ok if I took a shit on the floor?

      • Scatman

        Yes.

        • fartporngirl

          : ) actual lol you sick fuck.
          For that…I owe you….. at the very least, my stash of Brazilian fart porn.

    • Gabriel Bergmiller

      It seams like the ip spoofing they are using is similar to a man in the middle attack. This would be a the equivalent of a bad wire tap that cuts the line. So such an attack could be thought of as wiretapping and braking privacy laws. 

      • Burtrenolds

        the fuck are you talking about?!

        • ::1

          I think he means like how Comcast did a similar thing a few years ago with traffic shaping hardware where they injected spoofed packets into traffic flows to force a disconnect.  It was an effective man-in-the-middle attack against the protocol.

  • http://www.globalgeeknews.com pcnerd37

    Two wrongs don’t make a right!

    • Occasionally_S

      Enough money does.

      • Anonymous

         So true :)

    • Hurrdurr

      That depends on the outcome…

    • No1_2_u

      No, no Wongs don’t make a Wright…LMAO!

  • http://twitter.com/Anime4PSP Anime 4 PSP

    massive lawsuit against copywrong conglomerates :o

  • Stupid Anti-pirates

    250,000,000 bittorrent users are gonna be pissed.

    Time to get some popcorn…… this is gonna be a good show !

    • Anonymous

      Oh, my, yes. I can already hear that two-tone whistling noise of the anonymous bomb about to drop straight on to Pirate Pay et al.

  • Supermang

    So, if it becomes a problem, then simply disable µTP.  Problem solved.  Then get BitTorrent Inc. to fix the protocol.

    • Anyone

       uTP, not µTP

      • Twiddelbit

        Lol, and uTorrent and ?Torrent are two totally different things, too, right?

      • john doe

        Nope, it’s really µTP, but you can use uTP as a simplified form.

    • Guest

       That’s exactly what I did last night on a TV torrent when I noticed tons of µTP “bad peer” info in the log window…..speeds picked up soon after xD

  • http://zamphatta.com/ Forrest

    Shouldn’t this be considered a DMCA violation? I mean, is one is purposely trying to circumvent or block a technology (in this case  the µTP), then it’s a DMCA violation isn’t it? I’m actually surprised that companies aren’t jumping on the bandwagon to use the torrent protocol, for faster downloads or streaming. For example – Imagine if Netflix or Youtube stored popular videos on multiple servers, and then streamed them using the torrent protocol, thus reducing buffer time. It would also help any company that had large downloads really. Sites like Ubuntu & FreeBSD do this, and it helps a lot. I’m really surprised that other companies haven’t seen how this can benefit their profits yet. 

    • Danny

      Lots of systems use bittorrent already. Lots of IP TV stuff does, the backend to BBC iplayer uses it for downloads, steam, wow, facebook use it to sync servers, google use it, etc, etc.

      • http://zamphatta.com/ Forrest

        I didn’t know that. Very cool. Still, I’m surprised more companies aren’t using it. All the FUD that goes around about it these days is ridiculous.

    • thatguy

      youtube have licensing restricitons in place, depending on what country you live in. certain content is only accessible to certain ip adresses, with a torrent stream server that i guess could be a problem, since it is beeing streamed all over the freaking world. not to mention that it would be damn rigth impossible to take down and/or limit copyright infringing videos, like they started doing heavily since google bought youtube and started muting videos, and/or taking them down.

  • Cujo

    ok ,, so here’s what we do  ,,  we figure out how to circumvent the issue ,, then do as usual and copy the technoligy and use it to our advantage ,, ip address forging sounds promising  ;)

    • Said too many times B4

      muliticast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast , multicast

      Let’s get the teh workin torrent devs….

  • King of the Castle

    Tried downloading one of the movies that are supposedly “protected” by ruprotect. Worked just fine. It’s fun to watch people shovel sand in the desert so nobody could make a castle out of it.

  • Pingback: Attacking the Pirates « iStoryang HaaayTek!

  • Anonymous

    isn’t sending junk data a little redundant?
    I was downloading a torrent a few months back and more than 68% of the data was wasted. it still finished though.

    the only way to do this is if you comprise >~50% of upload traffic for all torrent swarms. this is terribly inefficient. also people having traffic watchers help stop it. (thanks little snitch!)

    the only way I see this working is by sending one corrupt block to as many peers as possible and then leaving, and relisting to do it again. still would take way too much effort though.

  • Master

    They don’t seem to know that there’s multiple torrents with the same content.

  • Twiddelbit

    Btw., in this the so called Sybill attack? An attack which is known since ~2002? If so, wow, they are only 10 years behind now, they are catching up!

    • Anonymous

      It probably is. I think someone sold the MPAA/RIAA the London Bridge again. 

  • Twiddelbit

    Hm, the report is interesting:

    “In analysed traffic from April 1st 2012 99.99% of uTP DATA packets contained hash 057a315b89b54e53e2ee583dd5cd9ef60648805e.”

    -> http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2094767/

    I think their problem is not piracy, but that they made a shitty movie: 5.2/10 imdb rating *facepalm*

    • Anyone

      blaming piracy is way easier than actually improving the content

  • tooeasy

    All sounds a bit sensationalist to me (not uncommon for Ernie’s pieces).  The linked article doesn’t sound too convincing either of there being a serious threat out there, more that they believe they’re seeing abnormalities in some of the data they’re receiving that could be malicious in nature.  Interesting in itself, but noone should ever be surprised to learn that there are entities operating out there that exploit the BitTorrent protocol for various reasons; There are, and always have been.  Nothing surprising about that.  But instead of getting hysterical about what could potentially be happening, why not just take a look at what effects are actually being seen instead – You’ll usually find there’s little to be that concerned about.

  • Huddel

    Please, correct me if I’m wrong, but the current blacklisting of peers that send bad packets wouldn’t render their effort useless – if not only a very minor nuisance – since after a few bad packets the ones sending it would be blocked? 

    I mean… yeah, a bad part… there are other 5 ok downloading simultaneously… what would that do, increase my download in 5 minutes or so? I can deal with that.

    • Rahvasaadik

      The malicious user pretends to be someone else on the torrent network and using that fake alias of the person you trust, tells you that he is logging off from the swarm. You believe that the message came from a trusted user and send your logoff confirmation to that legit user. Now, both of you are believing that each other are logging off, while the malicious user has duped you.

      • Huddel

        Thank you very much, sir.

      • Anonymous

        In short they are spoofing ip adresses lifted from the tracker/peer list. There should be an easy workaround here. A change in the protocol where you accept the logoff request as valid only after sending a “confirm logoff request” to the ip of the legit user would render such a spoof meaningless.

        Sure, they could adapt as well…but there is a limit to how much they can do in order to stop a swarm without effectively turning their spambots into a general DDoS.

  • Andrew Lee

     I hate to be the one to point this out erm no I don’t. The actions they’re taking is technically illegal. The files they decide to attack is completely irrelevant to the case. You know it’s illegal to go out and serve vigilante justice? If I decided to go out and start hunting down bad guys and beating the tar out of them I would end up in prison.

    We have a justice system “it’s not much I know” and it’s their job to deal with crime. It’s not the job of some random company to take matters into their own hands. We’ve see how well that can go when they’re allowed to take down files and end up abusing the fuck out of it. What makes anyone think this will be any different?

    If they want to see the true definition of piracy I suggest surfing some Chinese search engines.

    Every single method these Anti-Piracy tools take are 100 percent wrong.

    I’m getting ready to pirate my huge photoshop collection of styles patterns actions and brushes! Erm nvm wrong word since I made them all lol. Give away ^.^  #$%^ I’ll still call it piracy anyways it sounds more dangerous >:D

    • Sky Rockets

      In theory, maybe, but this kinda thing has been going on for at least 10 years already.

      Many file-sharing networks have been attacked in similar ways over the years, and the so-called legal authorities did approximately jack-shit to stop it (gee, I wonder why…).

  • Kidego90

    This could be considered an act of terrorism….

    • Anonymarse

      It could also be rubber banjo spatulas if words no longer have meaning…

    • ho

      Only the .gov can cry “terrorism” for things they want gone.

      Didn’t you get the memo ?
      It’s called “family protection from pirates bill”

  • Anon

    I would not be surprised if there is already a fix for this type of attack, Another few millions wasted by the entertainment industry.
    Maybe they should be concentrating on how to attract all those people that now get there movies /music/books/software free instead of alienating them even more by attacking what they are doing. personaly i think they cannot survive in this world of high tech and the internet, they are just not capable of understanding that the power they coveted so much has been taken away from them , they are now just insignificant distractions to people that know how to use a torrent client.

    • Rahvasaadik

      There is currently no fix and developing one requires total overhaul of the DHT network and months of work. The core structure of uTP protocol has to change to defend against this type of attack.

      • tooeasy

        configure encrypted only connections in the client

      • Armada

        What makes you say that? I looked at the source of this article and it seems they set the timestamp to 0, which would mean the packets came from January 1st, 1970. The Peer ID is also 0, which is not even a valid value. I’m actually wondering if these infections are effective at all, since I wouldn’t be surprised if uTorrent already rejects these packets.

  • Noo

    PLAN B a new source of P2P is NEEDED ! why dont they just let us do WHAT THE FUCK WE WANT TO HUH WTF

    • Guest

       We have so many sources of P2P that no this is not needed. Even Lime wire is still working.

    • Anti

      Fuck off, troll.

  • Fgdjkfvhklds

    this is like idk going to them and pissing/shiting in their water nd food

  • NewClear

    Of course you know this means war…

    • Tyler

      it’s all a waste of time. I’m in Australia and still waiting for a legit netflix style system here. have to buy $25 DVDs and miss out on foreign releases. Still think they should put 10% of the money they waste on litigation and useless measures like this torrent poisoning and make a system where I can actually buy the content I want.

      • PpppppP

        But why empower them further than they already are by feeding them more money?  They’re not going to become nice guys all of a sudden; they’re gonna want to use that power to get more power, and the consequences of that ain’t likely to be good for anyone but themselves.

  • Vincent Giannell

     I’m starting to think this attack was made illegally.

  • Jonseeder

    Might be why my bittorrent traffic was getting realy slow. Turned off utp last week, and everything is super fast downloading again.

    • ::1

      Yeah, that sounds like µTP by design.  It throttles itself when it detects congestion in the network in an effort to save ISP billions in investment in infrastructure to avoid interfering with your other internet activities.

  • Mr. MoneySuit Monacle

    US foreign policy creates/breeds rubber banjo spatulas.
    Now there’s a fucking headline.

  • Anonymous

    It was supposed to be so easy…….

    There was supposed to be no risk for them…….

    Not in respect to liability arising from damages inflicted on customers by ISPs doing the Six Strikes Barbed Wire Dildo Slam on hapless customers………And….Certainly not from these posse commitasse actions taken by designated “private agents” acting on behalf of Copyright Holders…….

    How COULD it have gone so horribly wrong?

    Hint!……The Politicians were supposed to have produced the mother of all Lead Diapers!  But…..as usual…..when the shit hit the Mother of all Fans…..they forgot who had paid them……..and why…..

    PIPA, SOPA, ACTA, CISPA did NOT pass……..and certainly, did not pass into law with all the Sado-Masochistic Christmas Goodies with which the Corporate Usual Suspects were expecting to “service” the Great Global Public for the next several Centuries……

    Can’t you hear them wailing, “What happened to the re-chartering of CIA and NSA resources for use within the United States against American Citizens accused (not found guilty after trial) of Copyright infringement that we were promised?”…….That was, after all, the fundamental promise of CISPA……Wasn’t it?…….

    Can’t you hear them wailing, “Wasn’t the Presumption of Innocence supposed to become (cough, cough) rebuttable Presumption of Guilt!”……..Each one of these laws changed legal burden of proof to accomodate corporate Copyright Holders and diminish the Constitutional Due Process Rights of American Citizens……

    Above all…….I’m sure you can hear them wailing, ”Immunity from Liability!  We must have Immunity from Liability!”……Of course, it’s absolutely true!…..They must have Immunity from Liability!…..and, Wasn’t Immunity from Liability promised in each and every one of those failed laws?……

    So, why are Mother’s Little Helpers out there in the wind with their Corporate Boodies all Exposed fixing to whip the Mother of All Fuckings on Three Hundred Million American Citizens (Not to mention a Billion or two Global Citizens who can also sue) without the coverage promised by those laws? 

    First answer:  They can not afford to wait.  The Internet evolves away from corporate or governmental control at the speed of light.  The ligitimacy of their legal and economicly priviledged control over Intellectual Property is erroding every day!  The public challenge to their legislated Monopoly becomes more effective by the minute.

    Second answer:  They are Horrified!  But their monopoly control over
    Intellectual Property in Perpetuity is worth hundreds of Trillions of Dollars ONLY IF they can continue in control.  That kind of money makes every loser an optimist. 

    Third answer:  They have clear standing PROMISES from American Politicians that NO MATTER WHAT AMERICAN CITIZENS WANT a back door WILL be found to give thewm ALL the powers that were denied in the PUBLIC REJECTION of PIPA, SOPA, ACTA, and CISPA. 

    I hope this Horrifies you! 

    You need to be Horrified enough to resist that back door slam dunk American Politicians are planning for the Copyright Industry. 

    Why? 

    Because you only have to lose once…….to lose everything! 

  • Dermy101

    Where can I download Russian movies?

    • Guest

       where your sitting now should be a good place

  • nona

    “The security researchers don’t make any conclusive claims about the origins of the attacks, but they do note that anti-piracy groups are a possible source.”
    Somehow that translates to “anti-piracy outfits launch attack…”?  Could just be an ISP ‘governing’ BT traffic.  In the U.S., Comcast got in trouble with the FTC for traffic shaping with a similar mechanism (DPI) not that long ago – but when all was said and done, it was deemed OK.  No one thinks the ISPs have a money interest in limiting BT traffic – from whatever source?  I know movie-makers are the great satan and all, but they really don’t seem like the most likely culprit here.  What’s more – the actual researchers aren’t willing to make that conclusion either.  Weird watching a pirate party-goer, of all people, spouting ‘guilty until proven innocent.’ 

    • Anonymous

      It could be.

      However, we do know that this exact scheme has, in fact, been used in the past. This is why we today have blacklists such as peerguardian.

      We also know that the copyright industry has used gray-area or even illegal methods in the past as well. Anyone remember Aiplex or ICS:Law? The cases where “Anonymous” made their first splash?

      In order to generate flags of this kind, you would have needed every ISP involved to be in on it. And if they were, this would be traceable.

    • thatotherguy

      honestly mate, why would an ISP want to govern bittorrent traffic? if they are, they are doing so because they were told by the MAFFIA to do so.

      that’s how the ISP make their money; faster internet with higher bandwidth for more monthly fees. naturally they want to scream “DOWNLOAD ALL YOU WANT!” if they could, because that is what is attracting their customers. if you think that your ISP is governing torrent traffic as their own idea, you are, quite simply, out of your mind.

  • Guest

    I don’t get why this is possible/effective at all…
    Unencrypted connection (like you see that anywhere): Simply embed a unique identifying number in each packet. If a packet arrives from a certain IP with a mismatching identifier, it’s faked/forged, ignore it.
    Encrypted connection: you simply cannot produce a valid packet. (although I suppose you could spam these invalid packets and have your torrent client drop the seeder). Use same solution as above.

    There problem solved.

  • http://modmyi.com/forums/iphone-4-new-skins-themes-launches/740147-neurotech-hd.html#post5637502 Jay

    If they were breaking the law, who would hire attorneys to take them on, anyway?  Sounds like vigilante justice, backed by more-than-sufficient funding. 

    Maybe Batman is doing it.

    • Dansith2705

      nah mate Superman

    • Desu1

      No no, you both got it all wrong. It’s Captain Planet. 

  • Desu1

    I still think it’s funny that the copyright holders are paying tens of thousands for this service. Who’s trolling who here? Before piracy cost them nothing. Now it’s costing them a lot of money and I can just find another torrent or go to XDCCfinder. 

  • Dansith2705

    i can steal anything i want lol off the net ur fault u invented it

    • me

      Well, you’re likely not stealing: you’re copying stuff, therefore making more of it, not less. Keep sharing, and remember: sharing is caring.

  • Dansith2705

    oh by the way so lame u cant beat a kids trick a super ghost kamkazze attack hahaha

  • me

    If there’s a flaw in uTP, that flaw needs to be fixed. It’s a simple as that. Copyright Trolls like Pirate Pay are just making sure we, the BitTorrent community, stay on our toes and won’t sit on our lazy bums. So, Pirate Pay & Co, keep the attacks coming: we’re fixing the problem as soon as you become a nuisance.

  • Pingback: Grupos anti-piratería lanzan ataque contra el protocolo BitTorrent | IntelDig

  • Anonymous

    Assuming they can actually do a good job of preventing themselves appearing as a shitload of IPs from the same netblock (which makes these swarm-deceiving efforts blatantly obvious and easy to mitigate) – we still have another, easy way to ensure Pirate Pay is a short-lived and futile failure.

    1) Inject report-tracking nodes A and B.
    2) Bogus-reporting node C tells node A that node B is bad (or vice versa).
    3) Node C is identified as malicious and gets blocked at the tracker.

    Pirate Pay isn’t a new idea.  Torrents were flooded with bogus nodes in the past, the p2p community mitigated it and within a few days everything went back to normal as the malicious nodes were blocked by trackers.

    Microsoft are being stupid by generating bad PR through financially supporting malicious DDoS attacks against network services that are relied upon by legitimate distributors and consumers, especially independent developers, artists, producers, etc.

    • Anonymous

      Yup. This problem can and will be handled just as poisoned torrents were handled in the past. It’s why peerblock blacklists are today an integral part of the torrent scene.

      Honestly, you think they’d learn. All they do is that they flood the net with the equivalent of a low-grade DoS in the hopes that this will delay distribution of one or two movies.

  • Anonymous

    TPB uptime is currently patchy.  For anyone having difficulty accessing it…

    http://www.magnetdl.com seems to cache the results frequently.

    Also have my own backup of magnets, from 18th May to the time this post was made: http://pastebin.com/Xp28fABw :)

  • anon

    Don’t use the MPAA owned uTorrent, problem solved. This is only an attack on the uTP protocol, not the BT protocol.

  • Fake

    Such actions are a felony under the DMCA and similar laws in other countries.

    The RIAA and MPAA wrote those laws and bribed political whores to pass them.

    Now they’ve hired people to break the laws they wrote.

    Considering how in debt our countries are law enforcement resources should be focused on large tax cheats like the RIAA and MPAA members.

  • tonyj123

    who cares, it’s not going to work, all you do is change the name of the movie like Borat to Borata.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1617612448 George Andrew Warren

    This is probably done by some ‘Scene’ idiots who are jealous of torrents, and want piracy to be available only to elite folks with topsite access.

    • MSEXITN0W

       I agree with that idea must be ‘Scene Retards’ behind this scheme.

  • Ralph Brubaker

    America! how could you!??!

  • MSEXITN0W

    STOP Going to movie theaters your only selling yourself as a slave to freedom lost on the internet in the long run I have not and will not ever step into a theater again these criminals RIAA, MPAA have tried to collect on dead people how low can they go?? supporting these BIG Corps is only enabling them and making things worse.

    • Anonymous

       ^ Cannot be repeated and emphasized enough.

      MAFIAA only understand money, if their dishonestly claimed losses became ACTUAL losses… they’d soon back the fuck up.

  • Pingback: Pour enrayer le piratage, des firmes corrompent les échanges sur BitTorrent | Geekattitude

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100003910293922 AnacondaWeb Hosting

     They are still trying to cover the sun with one finger.

  • http://www.executiveer.com/ Josefina Gomes

    The security researchers don’t make any conclusive claims about the
    origins of the attacks, but they do note that anti-piracy groups are a
    possible source.

  • Bemyguest

    Ok, so now we demand that ISP’ s hand over details of the attackers in order to sue them…and request billions…how that sound? can we get this message across the mafiaa and co?

  • Anonymous
  • Pingback: Anti-Piracy Outfits Launch Attack on BitTorrent Protocol | Mediafire Search Engine

  • Anonymous…..

    To me, the simplest way to find out if the Anti-Piracy folks are simply using a word matching program is to simply upload a Creative Commons movie to one of the trackers who have the anti-piracy false data and then make the title something like “[CC movie title/your own movie] – [copyrighted movie title] sucks!”. Then sit back and wait. Once the anti-piracy outfits start sending junk data to bombard your torrent file bring it to the attention of Torrentfreak AND/OR file a lawsuit claiming that your legit movie torrent is being harassed by anti-piracy outfits and that they are using a word matching program instead of ensuring the torrents they are attempting to negate actually contain “illegal” copies of their movies.

  • 1234567890

    ??, ???? ???????!

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

  • Pirates Can Be Identified Despite Sharing IP Addresses, ISP Claims

    Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation is a network mechanism through which many Internet subscribers can share the...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.