Data Protection Makes Identifying Online Pirates a Nightmare

Written by enigmax on June 10, 2009 

Norway’s data protection department has indicated that ISPs must delete all personal IP address-related data just 3 weeks after collection. The instruction, initially given to two ISPs but applicable to them all, means that it will be incredibly difficult to take action against file-sharers.

Previously it hasn’t been particularly easy for copyright holders to go after alleged infringers in Norway, but just recently the country’s telecoms regulator said that file-sharers’ identities can be given to copyright holders, providing a court agrees there is a good reason to hand them over. This means that these individuals can be pursued through the courts, or through “pay up or else” type threats.

However, the authority in charge of data protection in Norway has just made that process much, much harder for the copyright holders, since it has instructed two ISPs – Tele2 and Lyse Tele – to delete all IP address-related personal information they hold on their customers which is more than 3 weeks old.

According to Aftenposten the decision, borne of the Personal Data Act which prohibits the storage of unnecessary data, will apply to all ISPs in Norway such as Canal Digital, NextGenTel, Telenor and others.

The fact that data can only be held for just 21 days will see the immediate deletion of IP information held on around 1.6 million subscribers by these Norwegian ISPs. However, the decision flies in the face of European Union rules which say that this type of data must be held for at least 6 months – right now in Norway, data retention can be anything from a few days to five months.

The process of monitoring file-sharers, gathering evidence and then collating it all into an acceptable format can be time consuming. Add this to the time taken to get into the system to obtain a court order from a judge to force the ISPs to hand over data on their customers, and you end up with a period longer than 21 days. By which time the data has gone and the evidence becomes useless, since it’s impossible to identity the alleged infringer.

Movie industry lawyer Espen Tondel isn’t going to like this, one little bit.

Previously:

Next:

64 Responses

1 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:28 by nick

first? XD

2 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:29 by A. N.

21 days? that’s awesome. Hope it gets also applied all over the europe.

3 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:29 by Eleriel

Awesome!

I wonder if this has anything to do with all of norway’s internet traffic going through sweden…
hmm. nah, that’d be silly.

4 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:30 by ----

Norway FTW!

5 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:32 by dddunit

Sweet first time i posted and first 4th. Yah more privacy. Lets hope the U.S. does this. NOT!!!!

6 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:34 by One

_ F1_RS_T _ ! _ !

7 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:37 by cheapstyle

3 weeks is more than enough for getting your balls busted. it takes only some hours in germany from when the copyrights holders inform the police till the info at the isp gets locked, and won´t be deleted any more.

8 Jun 10, 2009 at 22:46 by Elo

However, the decision flies in the face of European Union rules which say that this type of data must be held for at least 6 months

you do know Norway is not a member of the European Union eh? they don’t have to give a shit about what the EU wants/does..they have enough money :D

9 Jun 10, 2009 at 23:03 by anon

the decision flies in the face of European Union rules

Norway is not in the EU.

10 Jun 10, 2009 at 23:04 by Anon

Norway isn’t an EU member, God bless ‘em.

11 Jun 10, 2009 at 23:06 by PirateLover

not long to go till the moron geezers who hate technology and p2p are replaced by our generation in government, im looking forward to being there when the record labels die and p2p declared not a crime

12 Jun 10, 2009 at 23:19 by www.eZee.se

@PirateLover,

+1 bro.

And on topic, Espen Tondel can go suck dirty monkey balls along with the executives of the industry he represents.

13 Jun 10, 2009 at 23:42 by Anonymous

Keep in mind that not all European countries are in the EU.

14 Jun 11, 2009 at 00:09 by Booty

This is not a problem at all. From a legal perspective, you just get a court order which is time activated. All the court order says is that the rights holder can submit IPs to the ISPs over a certain period of time for disclosure.

15 Jun 11, 2009 at 00:09 by anon

Norway is not a member of EU, but it is a member of EØS which basically places it “under” EU without actually becoming a member.

16 Jun 11, 2009 at 00:14 by Karl Rosenqvist

I hope the Norwegians invade and enforce their oppressive laws on us all!!!

17 Jun 11, 2009 at 00:32 by UltraleetJ

rather interesting. Its like collecting dust.. why do you need it? plus copyright holders would have “solved” this “problem” now if they think they’re so good at what they do (or dilligent)and if their reasoning (not makin any reference to any reasoned nicknames by the way) is of trust. 8+ years of “hard work” and look.. people are still sharing… my torrents are still going, my cd & dvd burner still work… so catch me if you can :P . Oh by theway still waiting on torrentfreak’s DCMA takedown notice (to take down their articles from hard drive cache) I downloaded (oh excuse me, not downloaded.. but articles I stole). I’m not sure what court to go to yet but I’ll arrange with torrentfreak’s leagal team to see what is the most convenient for them. Again, I’m sorry for stealing your graphics, your adverts, your user coments and articles… please forgive me torrentfreak for being such an ambitious pirate of your site!

18 Jun 11, 2009 at 00:46 by Mauritz

#9
#10
#19

Norway is a meber of the EEA

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Economic_Area

so basically Norway agrees to all EU low

19 Jun 11, 2009 at 01:00 by JeMoer

@ 18
No they don’t only laws that involve competition this is a privacy law

20 Jun 11, 2009 at 01:05 by Redmarine

I’m proud of having lived in Norway and learned their language! Go Norway!

21 Jun 11, 2009 at 03:09 by hiphop

to author: typo near end: “since it’s impossible to identity the alleged infringer.”

should be identify not identity

22 Jun 11, 2009 at 03:13 by Anonymous

@PirateLover,

You know at one time when I was a young lad, I thought just the same as you. That those things that made obvious sense, yet the established powers that be were against, would have to wait until our generation grew up to take the reigns of power to make things right.

Guess what? In the words of Bruce Springsteen, “Met the new boss, same as the old boss” developed to be truer than the words implied.

Those now in power are of my generation, much to my dismay. You see, when you get out in the world and have to make a living working a job, you wind up having to conform to the establishment to hold and keep that job. That means that the way things were is most likely the way they will continue to be.

Honestly, I pray you are right, that when your generation is “in” things will be different. Still you’ll pardon me if I don’t hold my breath. People will still be greedy for money, people will still scheme on how to get ahead at someone elses expense, and companies that hire labor will still want them to present themselves in a certain light to hold the job.

23 Jun 11, 2009 at 03:21 by Anonymous

Hmm, in the above response I failed to continue on with the topic at hand. I say good on Norway.

The copyright enforcement actions have made themselves so distasteful that the courts and governments of the world are getting wise to their methods and actions and it isn’t setting well with any not wrapped up in the trying to protect the income stream.

Sooner or later this has to come to a head. Either the dinosaurs learn new ways or they follow in the footsteps of their kin. I would rather see them do the latter both for a lesson in hubris, and for a lesson in what greed gets you when you let it rule the roost.

This is a nice way to put a roadblock in their plans.

24 Jun 11, 2009 at 04:15 by Anonymous

still too long

25 Jun 11, 2009 at 05:23 by StevO

i WILL STOP PIRATING, I promise…when…they make a return policy on bad products. I think a 30 day return policy on music movies and games is fair. Imagine getting your money back for a movie that has no ending. Leaving you hanging for a sequel. Thats garbage and its not moral. Also, Paying $50 for a game that constantly needs patches to fix all the problems it has and creates for its users. And horrid music. You pay $16 for a CD filled with garbage other than the 1 or maybe 2 songs that inspired you to purchase it. Software that is incredibly difficult to use to its potential. Thank God, for piratebay and its kin. It has saved me from spending alot of money on garbage. Believe me when I say, I have deleted as much as I have downloaded. And certainly have software and music and movies that sit idle on the shelf that would have gone directly back to where I bought it if I could have forseen the utter dissapointment that it brought me. WHERES MY REFUND!!

26 Jun 11, 2009 at 05:58 by DJ Sketch@1337x.org

@25
LOL, I’m with you, thats a great Idea…LOL

I too will stop pirating when it is possible to return a shitty movie, or a game that sux so bad that even old mario bros pwns it….

if ive said it once ive said it a thousand times, it is now possible to try before you buy.

so if lars ulrich of metallica gives me back my 30 dollars for the last 2 cd’s he put out, i wont upload his discography for free. LOL

27 Jun 11, 2009 at 06:01 by Anonymous

Hope it gets harder.

28 Jun 11, 2009 at 06:06 by Traum

Hoooray, they need meedio service now!

29 Jun 11, 2009 at 06:10 by msupre

New Wallpapers Added.
Visit: http://blog.bitcomet.com/9744199/

Most of the wallpapers are high resolution (HD Wallpapers).
More than 1000 Wallpapers.

30 Jun 11, 2009 at 06:15 by http://antimatter.atbhost.net/

Great idea from Norway. I’d like to see this happen in other countries. It’s a good step towards online privacy.

http://antimatter.atbhost.net/?p=43

31 Jun 11, 2009 at 06:44 by Jasper van Weerd

“However, the decision flies in the face of European Union rules which say that this type of data must be held for at least 6 months – right now in Norway, data retention can be anything from a few days to five months.”

Norway is not a EU member… is it?

32 Jun 11, 2009 at 06:46 by Jasper van Weerd

Lol, my bad for not reading fast enough…

33 Jun 11, 2009 at 07:16 by Anonymous

@6 epic fail

34 Jun 11, 2009 at 08:04 by Servicedesk thomas

This will go on my twitter and facebook page. Strictly cut and paste.

35 Jun 11, 2009 at 08:16 by Ah well

to them it’s probably not about the users, it’s about the money makers.

Check http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kBGNU892tI

36 Jun 11, 2009 at 08:21 by echo

NOW TO THE BIG QUESTION: WHERE CAN I GET A NORWAY VPN?

37 Jun 11, 2009 at 09:09 by manky goes to bollywood

cool story bro :)

38 Jun 11, 2009 at 10:07 by Another one down

. http://www.20minutes.fr/article/331417/High-Tech-SnowTigers-entre-40-a-50-teras-octets-de-donnees-saisies-en-France-et-a-l-etranger.php

39 Jun 11, 2009 at 10:07 by metal freak..

go europe!!! fook them american cartels in the ass!!!

40 Jun 11, 2009 at 10:28 by mastr

Norway isn’t in EU, so technically they can do whatever they want and tell EU to gtfo or else.

41 Jun 11, 2009 at 10:30 by Henrik

Pirate Tondel?

42 Jun 11, 2009 at 11:32 by Svetkka

?????? ??? ??????? ???????? ????? ????????????? ????, ? ?? ????????? ????? ??? ????? ?????? ??? ???? ??? ??????? ????????.

43 Jun 11, 2009 at 12:05 by mark

So if there is a real crime and they delete it, don’t they destroy evidence? Isn’t that illegal? I think there are exceptions where they don’t delete after 3 weeks.

44 Jun 11, 2009 at 12:06 by Anonymous

more stupid laws to let sharers, who are nothing more than thieves and criminals escape the system.

when will these countries realise action needs to be taken to stop pirating before it ruins these industries forever.

45 Jun 11, 2009 at 12:55 by Udlnu

Just throw in the terrorist card and you will see dem raise the retention to forever. :)

46 Jun 11, 2009 at 13:55 by Matheus Svensson

@Mauritz (18): A Norwegian friend has described EEA membership as ‘obey without say’ – agreeing to be bound by the rules of the EU, while having no influence on those rules. This isn’t entirely true. As that Wikipedia page points out, it’s only certain aspects of EU legislation. I’d have thought that the Data Retention Directive comes squarely under policing and justice, and so Norway won’t be obliged to transpose it into Norwegian law. But, the whole Europe thing is such a complicated mess, I could be wrong.

47 Jun 11, 2009 at 15:22 by Kos

Privacy laws stand strong in Norway. We’re also getting faster and faster broadband. Win/win

48 Jun 11, 2009 at 16:28 by JTK

Great, now do this in the UK!

49 Jun 11, 2009 at 17:05 by deadmanamerican

norway is the greatest country to live in according to micheal moore and this helps solidify that opinion…kvlt people but crappy music

50 Jun 11, 2009 at 17:45 by aXXo

Norway uh? then thats where I’m going next, I’ll be safe there…

Please send your money to me at:
speed.cdhelp@gmail.com

51 Jun 11, 2009 at 18:18 by Anonymous

“storage of unnecessary data” <–sure the uk use to have some laws for that but seems its just a data free for all now.

norway++ good work :)

52 Jun 11, 2009 at 19:21 by Bagwell

Now this is nice.

—————–
Bagwell.
http://certcollection.org/forum/

53 Jun 11, 2009 at 23:39 by slava!

NORGE NORGE NORGE

54 Jun 12, 2009 at 00:01 by Anonymous

@26: Try before you buy doesn’t always work. For example, I recently tried out the demo of Call of Duty: World At War on the Xbox 360 and liked it. So I purchased the full game and to my utter dismay finished it in one single and very short sitting. I wished I had known just how little I would be getting for my $69. I would not have purchased had I known. It’s a reminder that I need to be super vigilant by reading at least several reviews, not rely solely on demos and if possible wait until the game I want hits the bargain bin (not always easy).

55 Jun 12, 2009 at 00:23 by Anonymous

@44: When will the entertainment cartel learn that technology has made their business model obsolete and they must therefore explore new ones? I’m willing to bet you everything I own that over 80% of the people you call pirates would be more than happy to pay REASONABLE prices for REASONABLE entertainment. There is still plenty of money to be made as long as people are treated with fairly and honestly. It is up to the industry to find the right path. See, the folks you call pirates? I call them customers and ones that have been gravely mistreated at that. The entertainment industry feels like they are owed and the results have been not unlike a baby throwing a temper tantrum. Stop treating your customers like criminals, find a REASONABLE middle ground that everyone can be happy with, cut your losses and I’ll bet you anything that the entertainment industry flourishes once again. Seriously, which side do you think will win in a long protracted battle over many years? I’ll give you a hint: businesses come and go but consumers (NOT cash cows for milking that you feel you rightfully own) will be around forever.

56 Jun 12, 2009 at 03:32 by me

to bad Norway aint a part of the European Union :)

57 Jun 12, 2009 at 12:52 by Frank

Spam test:

Hello, I have seen people spamming threads and I am testing if this is possible.

Best Youth porn:

http://www.youth10.com

58 Jun 12, 2009 at 13:15 by Dan

Good to see things finally heading in the right direction =]

59 Jun 12, 2009 at 23:51 by red

good feckin story

60 Jun 13, 2009 at 00:29 by Anonymous

Norway FTW!!!

61 Jun 13, 2009 at 03:19 by since

since when Norway became EU member?

62 Jun 13, 2009 at 23:32 by Fredrik

But we still have to follow many of the EU-regulations.

Det er godt å være norsk i Norge.

63 Jun 15, 2009 at 10:40 by hulululu

How that is compatible with the EU regulations on data retention (which require a retention period of at least 6 months and up to two years [at the implementing country's discretion]) is gonna be interesting.

64 Jun 18, 2009 at 07:35 by Entertane.com

Check out http://www.entertane.com for a new meta-search engine – faster, simpler – access to all your favorite torrent searches

Responses are closed

All remaining responses will continue to be archived. Use the TorrentFreak forums if you want to discuss something.