TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

“Going BitTorrent” Settles FrostWire’s FTC Charges

The popular file-sharing application FrostWire has settled its dispute with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). The FTC accused FrostWire of disregarding the privacy of its users, by not making it clear enough that their files are publicly shared when downloads are finished. By turning FrostWire into a BitTorrent-only client the company was able to swiftly settle the charges and avoid a lengthy court battle.

frostwireTo those who are not that tech-savvy, file-sharing applications that share all files by default can pose a threat.

This is one of the main reasons why the FTC filed a complaint against FrostWire at a federal court. The government agency, which aims to protect the rights of consumers, alleged that FrostWire was disregarding users’ privacy by sharing files by default.

Although some companies might view a looming lawsuit by the FTC as a massive problem, the FrostWire team approached the court case in a rather pragmatic way. The commission first contacted FrostWire in May, and by the end of the month the company had already delivered a version complying with the majority of the proposed changes.

“We are software people, and saw this as a bug fix that happened to be reported by the FTC,” FrostWire’s Angel Leon told TorrentFreak.

“Nobody as far as we know ever complained for having finished downloads shared by default, to us it was a given of P2P, but now we feel better that users are in full control of what’s being shared.”

FrostWire users could always prevent automatic sharing in just a click or two, but the FrostWire team understood the issues brought up by the FTC and quickly took action. By leaving Gnutella – which was little more than a spam farm after LimeWire shut down – FrostWire decided to become a BitTorrent-only client.

“We actually made our software compliant by making the allegations irrelevant once we dropped Gnutella. Now there’s no concept of ‘shared folders’ anymore and it’s pretty clear where all files are saved, and if the user is seeding or not,” Leon said.

FrostWire sees the FTC intervention as one of the most helpful bug reports in the company’s history.

“Thanks to this whole ordeal we made our application a lot better. In a matter of a couple of weeks, we had the last version of FrostWire 4.21.x fully compliant with the order, and then we just made the decision to go 100% with BitTorrent,” Leon says.

“With BitTorrent we feel that our users’ privacy is better protected than when we had Gnutella, and now they’re certainly immune to spam search results.”

Aside from the desktop application, FrostWire also has an Android app that runs on a separate file-sharing network developed by the company. For this mobile application the company changed the default settings so users have to opt-in before they share something.

As a result, the number of shared files dropped dramatically, so FrostWire will soon turn the Android application into a BitTorrent client as well. The source of this new client will be released under a GPL license as soon as the first version comes out.

Overall both the FTC and FrostWire are happy with how things worked out. Consumers on the other hand benefit from the relative privacy of BitTorrent, where no shared folders exist.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Gargamel

    Interesting. I thought frostwire had been dead for years.

  • puddipuddi

    I’ve never used it before, but good for them. Now back to uploading my local music collection :) Gotta take advantage of “Music Insanity”. Extra points! :thumbsup:

  • Anonymous

    Frostwire was the next thing to go to after limewire died. I wonder how it works now that it is a bittorrent client only. It must have something really good to offer if it wants to compete against the less resource demanding players in the game like utorrent, etc.

    • hikaricore

      It’s mostly crap now, but you can still use an older version of the client if need be to access the same content you used to be able to. Atleast as long as keep keep sharing on the networks.

    • Anonymous

      try the latest for yourself and see http://dl.frostwire.com/frostwire/5-beta

      Things it’s got going for itself:
      > Search on major torrent indices is built in. Search all the indices at once.
      > As you search, it scraps torrents to determine it’s inner contents, so you can search the bittorrent network for rare individual files.
      > Average search results under 10ms.
      > New media Library written from scratch (available only in the beta for now)
      > No more spam or fake search results.

      • DeathInMyEyes

        How can you claim no more spam or fake search results as those types of clients are well known to be filled with such type of files??

        Do you know something that not even the dev’s know? You still find files @ 2KB clearly petty trojens.

        • monkeyslap

          From the article: “With BitTorrent we feel that our users’ privacy is better protected than when we had Gnutella, and now they’re certainly immune to spam search results.”

          From gubatron: “> No more spam or fake search results”.

          From you: “How can you claim no more spam or fake search results as those types of clients are well known to be filled with such type of files??
          Do you know something that not even the dev’s know? You still find files @ 2KB clearly petty trojens.”

          Fist: the Frostwire developers, as quoted by Torrentfreak in the article, are the ones who made the initial claim of no more spam in the Frostwire search results.

          Second: You indicate that other people still find small files with trojans in them. Have you seen this yourself in the new Frostwire bittorrent only client?

          I don’t use Frostwire myself but have used the old client but stopped using it because of all the fake spam files. I do believe you have a point though. I also believe it is impossible to prevent/remove every single spam file in the search results. But I think it’s possible to prevent most of it.

        • Anonymous

          because search is now done using curated torrent search engines.
          There’s of course a chance of getting a fake torrent result, but torrent indexes are quick with their communities to find out and remove malicious torrents from their indexes.

          I’m the lead dev.

    • Zarberi

      It saves time by pulling results from a handful of torrent websites, instead of you having to manually go to your browser and look for what you want. There are a couple minor annoyances with it though, such as the automatic pop up of your browser when you start a download, but that can be turned off in Options and is only meant to direct users back to the hosting site where there may be comments/ratings on the chosen torrent. Also, a few more files than you selected will be downloaded when you use the ‘Partial Download’ manager, which is meant to give people a better chance at connecting to you for seeding, but even if seeding is turned off it still grabs more than you wanted (although those extra files will be deleted after you click Cancel on the finished transfer).
      They also made it easy to share a torrent directly with a friend by creating a link that can be posted to Twitter, Facebook, etc.. As long as that person has FrostWire it will automatically start downloading from the weblink page.

  • Pingback: “Going BitTorrent” Settles FrostWire’s FTC Charges | TorrentForce Blog

  • http://twitter.com/AlyssaBlindy Alyssa Blindy

    Hmmm. Accessibility of FrostWire is mehh, okay but not all the best. You can’t really do much with it accessibly, and HTML tags that they tried to use show up in the middle of the text. Yuck!
    Now I see why the entertainment industry can get away with saying that filesharing can leak personal data, because on GNUtella, it did allow downloading of personal files, because all folders were shared. Interesting.

  • Anonymous

    http://www.lovetoshopping.org
    http://www.jerseymall.org
    Cheapest Vans Shoes,Tiffany Jewelry Company,Wholesale Hollister
    Clothing

  • DTN

    http://dispersethe.net

    Open for signups!!!!

  • Pingback: P2PTalk » “Going BitTorrent” Settles FrostWire’s FTC Charges

  • Anonymous

    I had no idea Frostwire was so cool like that. Wow.
    real-privacy.no.tc

  • http://profiles.google.com/zerianis10 Christopher Kidwell

    With all due respect, gnutella, ed2k, etc. are NOT just spam farms. You can still get some very good stuff off there if you are smart about things and realize that a 100KB file is NOT a song.

  • http://torrentfreak.com/ Rob8urcakes

    I reckon Frostwire’s made a VERY good and sensible move by going bittorrent-only, but I’d like to ask gubatron et al why it took so long to help protect your users and why did it take an FTC complaint to get your asses in gear?

    Did you not really care about making your users vulnerable and at risk?
    And do you care now?

  • http://stoian.myopenid.com/ woolie

    nah, mpaa & ftc are going to sue all bittorrent file sharers as they already did before. folks, this is a trap…

  • Anonymous

    Too bad just by going to bittorrent now they just opened the can of worms to allow copyright trolls to sue more people.

  • Anonymous

    Dude seems to make a lot of sense man
    complete-privacy.us.tc

    • Guest

      Dude seems like I’m gonna flag you again

  • Peter Voth

    Gnutella is not a spam farm. I can still find almost any song I want on the old Frostwire through Gnutella. Then I “upgraded” and now it sucks. I already have a bittorrent client. I want my Frostwire back!

    • http://twitter.com/icanhazsake Ninja

      With Frostwire dead as a Gnutella client I’d say that this specific Network might be living its final hours. I think it’s a shame. But the bright side is that we have a healthy bittorrent network and I personally never ever got any fakes from TPB or any indexer unlike Gnutella where you could download a 4Mb song that isn’t a song.

  • Pingback: The Technology Blog: Going BitTorrent Settles FrostWires FTC Charges

  • Pingback: Anonymous

  • Pingback: Going BitTorrent Settles FrostWires FTC Charges « Anacristina79's Blog

  • Pingback: Google Boots FrostWire From Android Market, But Why? | TorrentFreak

  • Pingback: Google Boots FrostWire From Android Market, But Why? | We R Pirates

  • Pingback: P2PTalk » Google Boots FrostWire From Android Market, But Why?

  • Pingback: Google Boots FrostWire From Android Market, But Why?

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.