TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Piracy Rampant Among Spanish Government Officials

While the Spanish Government tries to ram through legislation that will enable the authorities to shut down file-sharing sites more rapidly, employees of the ministry responsible have been exposed as pirates. Fresh data shows that at nearly all ministries, staff have been downloading copyrighted material.

spain flagSpain is considered to be a safe haven for operators of file-sharing oriented websites. Courts have repeatedly ruled that if they don’t profit directly from infringements, such sites fall within the boundaries of the law.

In an attempt to change this situation, the Spanish Government has been working on new legislation under which sites offering links to copyright works could be taken offline within days of a complaint.

The change in law has been pushed for by the entertainment industries that claim to be hit hard by rampant piracy in Spain. The piracy rate has reached a level where movie companies are even considering putting a halt to selling DVDs in Spain, claiming that it’s just not worth the effort because piracy is baked into Spain’s culture.

Indeed, many Spaniards consider casual downloading of copyrighted music and movies as an acquired right and thus far they have had the law on their side. Even if the newly proposed anti-piracy legislation passes, it is highly doubtful that downloading habits will change. At the Ministry of Culture, where the new legislation is being prepared, employees are still downloading as if nothing is about to change.

Data gathered by the Spanish TV-channel VEO 7 revealed that at the Ministry of Culture, several employees have been downloading music and TV-series without consent from the copyright holders.

According to the report, the Ministries of Defense and Education are the most active file-sharers, with employees using file-sharing applications to download erotic calendars, music, movies and lots of other goods.

In other Government bodies staff members have also been caught red-handed while sharing copyrighted files, including the Presidency where a brain training game was downloaded without authorization.

The embarrassing revelations come from Angel Badia, a Houston based ‘hacker’ who decided to prove what many people suspected all along. Badia identified the ministries by the IP-addresses that are publicly displayed in most file-sharing applications.

Badia’s data shows that it will be hard to deter Spaniards from sharing files through new legislation. If even the people who are trying to get the new law implemented can’t break with their habit, how can they expect that the public will?

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • nobrains

    hypocrits

  • duane

    Yes, the movie companies should stop selling content in Spain and see where that gets them! :P

    If they had two brain cells to knock together, they’d look to find better ways of monetising the market — you know, the much-revered “new business model” argument.

    Oh, wait. They’re still making billions and are just bluffing to hurry the new anti-piracy laws along.

  • copywrong

    This is LOOOOW!!!!!!

  • jovialau

    FILE SHARING IS RAMPANT IN ANY COUNTRY THAT HAS INTERNET CONNECTIVITY!ONE IS LEFT TO WONDER WHAT MIGHT HAVE HAPPENED HAD THAT PARTICULAR HACKER BEEN ABLE TO ACCESS THE POLICE ADMINISTRATION!OR OR FOR THAT MATTER…………… THE HOME IPS OF THOSE WHO WORK FOR ANTI PIRACY GROUPS.

  • Anonymous

    “have also been caught caught red-handed”

  • Zush

    even though El Mundo and Veo are hostile to the current government, I believe it.

  • lastbastard

    Sony is “considering putting a halt to selling DVDs in Spain”

    Hasta la vista, baby

  • Anonymous

    So lets get this straight.

    They don’t like the law which allows people to share files, and because of that want to remove DVDs and CDs to try and get it changed? They do realize without the option to buy it without importing fewer people will buy it right?

  • Trelew

    Even if the entertainment gets their corporate-friendly law through, it’ll become very much a “Do as I say, not as I do” mentality; which will just spur on more internet file sharing in protest.

  • John

    No one else sees the irony of the president requiring brain-training? No one?

    As far as i’m concerned, if the government do it – good!
    The reason we have such crappy laws in other parts of the world is that:
    a) you can bribe a politician to say whatever you want,
    b) They don’t even know what filesharing really is – so they couldn’t care less if they get rid of it.

    One of these days, someone in power is going to say to himself
    “Hold on. The way we pay for copied content is all wrong – it should either be:
    The first sale costs the price it took to make the product, plus reasonable profit, and the every subsequent copy should be charged at the price it took to make a copy, plus reasonable profit. (so £x million for ‘original’ DVD, and 3p for every copy), OR,
    The total cost of ALL the copies is the price it cost to make the movie and all the copies, divided by the number of copies.

    But, as we all know, that’s not how it works. Movie studios make MILLIONS of dollars worth of profit from a movie – far more than what is reasonable. Reason being, we all have it in our heads that £10 is a reasonable cost for something of which there are millions of copies of.
    Well… you either think that, or you think that something so ubiquitous as a commercial DVD is worth so little, it tends to <£1.

    So to be honest, when it comes to paying a 'fair price' for the media… pirates are paying a far more realistic price…. even if that price is under the real cost.

    TL;DR,
    Copyright law enforces a sale model which allows people to sell the same thing an infinite number of times, at any price they like.

    As 99% of all new content comes from a small number of producers. As a result the creative industry has the public is a headlock, and there's nothing we can do about it. If you want new arts (which some might say was a human right), you're going to have to pay a fortune for it.

    These things will happen in the next creative revolution. I don't want to pick a date, but it probably won't be in our lifetime.

  • Amused

    @5: LOL LOL Torrent Torrent Freak Freak is is in in to to double double words words today. today. Amused Amused

  • Jim Seavo

    No surprise there seeing as most of them are “on the take” anyways.

    anonymous-surfing.us.tc

  • http://torrentfreak.com Ernesto

    @5, thanks thanks, fixed fixed

  • AntiE

    Apr 03, 2010 at 15:30 by copywrong
    This is LOOOOW!!!!!!

    Major low! They are a bunch of hypocrites.

    Total abuse of power.

  • Non-pirate

    Why is the word “piracy” used in this article? Spanish copyright law only restrict use of copyrighted material, if it’s used to make profit.

    Non-commercial use, such as normal P2P file-sharing, is not regulated by Spanish copyright law, and it’s therefore completely legal to file-share and distribute copyrighted material as much as possible. It’s the same as copying for private use, without any restrictions as to how many people you can distribute it to.

    Since all this is legal in Spain(and many other countries in the world), it’s NOT piracy! It’s fully legal use of copyrighted material, and the word “piracy” has nothing to do with it.

    When it comes to P2P-filesharing, Spain actually has the lowest percentage of piracy in the world, it’s around or close to 0%.

    Since Spain has no problems with piracy and P2P file-sharing, the rest of the countries in EU should copy Spanish copyright law as soon as possible, since it is exemplary in reflecting the public’s moral on what copyright law should regulate.

  • BIOS

    Is this really any kind of surprise? I bet anyone who has ever used the internet (that is computer literate) has downloaded something they shouldn’t…

  • THX1138

    Eventually the American people will win, we always do. The corporations involved in this will be ground into dust.

  • Cujo

    we are all thepiratebay ;)

  • Joe

    it’s not just the staff, imagine all their kids downloading stuff? I have yet to meet a single kid who doesn’t download music illegally.

  • Surys

    Dumbass Sony Exec: “I know, let’s make it so ONLY the pirated verison of media are available in a media-consuming nation. – That should teach them to buy more and pirate less”

    - Another fine business strategy brought to you by the numbskulls of the recording industry.

  • anonymous

    a typical ‘dont do what i do, do what i tell you’ attitude here then. wonder how quickly that will change when it becomes totally illegal to download anything, unless you have definitive written permission, (in triplicate) from whoever SAYS they own something? be too late to turn back then, wont it. just the same as it is supposed to be legal to be able to download (but not profit from that download), but not legal to have any type of p2p/torrent site to download from (banned in previous articles here). double standards again. if it applies to one sector, it must apply to all!

  • Surys

    @THX1138

    Where do I start?

    The corporations are “people”, they can commit manslaughter or murder without anybody facing jail, they can deceive people out of millions of dollars and never have to pay a cent back to those they deceived, they use lobbyists and bribes to have their coporate policy sneaked into your laws, your food/agriculture policy dictated by Monsanto, your energy policy dictated by Exxon, your healthcare policy dictated by insurers and big pharma, your military policy heavily influenced by Boeing, Northrop, Lockheed, Halliburton, Caryle Group, etc IP/copyright policy dictated by the recording industry (rather than artists/creators and citizens) and your currency is controlled by the Federal Reserve coproration.

    I really wish I could say the American people are winning and I hope they ultimately do win… but right now… it really seems like corporations own America and can do whatever the hell they want.

  • Don Reba

    If Spaniards really are such avid downloaders, then there really is no point in selling DVDs there. Let them go.

  • Afficianado

    Woooot Espana

  • Grok

    This is hilarious hypocrisy. I guess this is just going to be a law for show. Nobody will actually follow it. It’s simply spineless bluster.

  • Whatever

    Where have we seen this hypocritical behaviour before ???? Yes, in Canada the MAFIAA still owe 6 billion to artists…

    If they stop selling media in Spain there is a good reason to change the law to…. a copyright of 2 days.

  • Pingback: Piracy Rampant Among Government Officials

  • Anonymous

    Trying to shovel crappy liberty killing law through the throat of the people is not going to cut it.

    What you need is a consensus that can not be reached as long as the copyright corporate extremists and terrorists are on the scene.

    We must get ride of them first.

  • TerribleTony

    props to Spain!

  • Einstein

    @ # 7, lastbastard:

    “Sony is ‘considering putting a halt to selling DVDs in Spain’”

    I totally believe Sony is stupid enough to do just that!!! Typical studio behavior and logic–or lack thereof! They fail to understand that halting video sales will mean that piracy will be the only way to acquire said videos!
    They would be fueling piracy by such a move!

  • Anonymous

    good idiots stop selling dvds they’ll just all get them off the internet then and you wont get anything…

  • Alex

    Whatsup my TF friends.
    Anyone want an invite to Lockerz?
    I’m sure you’ve heard about it, it’s pretty sweet…
    get em while they’re hot!!!

    email me at alexmomalex@hushmail.com
    and I shall send you one

  • Hephaestus

    Way to funny … Next in the news the white house caught downloading Avatar and Clash of the Titans

  • CORUS STEEL

    several employees have been downloading

    several = RAMPANT?

    since when?

  • A.B.S.

    “have been downloading copyrighted material”

    What does that mean? I downloaded the CNN.com homepage just a few moments ago and that was copyrighted content, too.

    I found the link to CNN.com on a website serving up links to this copyrighted material, it was called Google. Are they, too, breaking a law that doesn’t even exist in Spain that says it’s wrong for a site to link to copyrighted material and it’s wrong for a person in Spain to download it?

    “working on new legislation under which sites offering links to copyright works could be taken offline”

  • Mainframe

    you put info out there whether its in the form of music movies software ect. but you dont want us to have it. what ever happened to the freedom of information act. your trashing our rites. so next a freind cant let me barrow a movie?

  • Soundwave [Have a Seasoned Rind]

    Great headline, but it’s not illegal for them to download. Even if the law they were preparing to pass was already effective, I don’t see anything that says it would suddenly be illegal to share files for private use.

  • Pingback: Spagna: pirati anche in vari ministeri del governo

  • DeltaPan

    This is a situation that if properly analysed, will show every nation’s civil service and public servants at every level, will have employees and their families who download media from Bit Torrent.

    Government, military, police, health services, education, so on so forth.

    We live in a consumerist society, where media, music, books, games etc, are highly advertised on commercial channels, Internet, papers and magazines.

    But we also have the ebb and flow of economic prosperity and recession, apart from media, games etc, people want to have holidays, nice clothes down to lower levels of society where paying the bills just to exist proves expensive enough never mind having cable TV and Sky1 or ability to go to cinema, even hiring a single DVD from a shop is prohibitive when it’s hard enough to eat properly everyday.

    OK, civil servants earn a decent wage, they also download, but police personnel, hospital workers, fire brigades etc etc etc all do so as well because the Price of living is so high, consumerism bombards people with the stuff they want to sell but the prices are often ridiculous, we are in a global recession now and however governments say things get better, the truth is things are still tight and the way things are they always will be.

    Which is why people in every echelon, whether government employee or people on state benefits, download for free the media etc they are tempted with.

    There is no invisible dividing line, where police, health service professionals teachers etc, government officials and all those groups families do not download from Bit Torrent and there is a dodgy section of society which do.

    So this, the ‘revelation’ of this article, is going to be mirrored in every nation and i suggest is the tip of the iceberg not the entirety.

    So is it going to be a case of government sector workers, police, military, health services etc get away with the punitive actions intended by evolving legislation’s?

    Or are the new laws demanded by greedy and sociopathic corporates, going to destroy families of these groups as well as unemployed downloaders, downloaders in families simply trying to improve quality of life?

    Not criminals, not doing so as an act of recalcitrance but simply because they cannot afford to pay bills, put food on tables and pay for life in general.

    Are governments considering the punitive actions in new legislation’s against downloading, really going to see half of families and individuals working for civil services, police, military, education, health, destroyed as much as everybody else.

    Because there is no magic defining line, we downloaders are from every level and quarter of society.

    Or is it going to be a case of special dispensation afforded to keyworkers, but working and unemployed families who can just about afford an Internet connection and downlaod are destroyed through prosecutions.

    No!!!

    That is never going to happen without nations ending up in mass rebellion, you can’t push society that far, in the past decade, society has been pushed far enough, do governments really want to act on behalf of greed and sociopathic corporations regards filesharing and when the consequences of what they want to to to people via new laws destroys so many more lives than test cases in the past 5-7 years, society erupts.

    Do governments really want to preside over this situation because they have pandered to the greed of those who frankly live life in cloud cuckoo land, not reality, because they have become so affluent off of the masses through copyright monies they have lost touch with social realities and just want more and more wealth, but more wealth simply isn’t there anymore.

    The world has changed, this is a message given by governments when it comes to the consequences of the global recession.

    This message needs to be applied to greedy corporates who also need to adjust, like everybody else has to and governments must compel media corporates to ‘adjust’ like everybody else.

    This is just like the Tories in the UK, they are unable to understand the money created in the capitalist 80′s simply isn’t there anymore and to try and regenerate it like was done in the 80′s will destroy society in developed nations create adversities untenable to society and it will break down and explode into mass violence, this too will be the consequence of corporates creating social adversity and affecting quality of life because of greed, destroying peoples lives through prosecutions based on greed.

    As is seen here in Spain, it isn’t just defiant members of society who download, but there people in government and all levels.

    Another solution is required than changing laws to allow mass prosecutions, disconnections, whatever, among downloader/filesharing communities.

    To task the issue of downloading will mean affecting every group and every level of society and it will cause chaos.

    I suggest “compliance through co-operation”, allowing a period of copyright of no more than a year for more expensive productions, 6 months for lesser media, then allowed propagation on P2P/BT.

    By then creators will have realised primary profits from those able to pay, any subsequnt losses from primary will be negligible after such periods, those unable to afford can then access for free or at minimal cost through fair and ethical hire/sale Internet business models, whatever the timescales, copyright protections in the 21st century in the digital arena should be no longer than one year and only the most expensive materials should be that long, most copyright protections to realise primary profit uptake by creators should be 3-6 months, enough profits to compensate production and above would have been earbned in those timescales and i suggest it is simply greed expecting materials to earn profits ad infinitum, in this digital age, copyright should be there for primary protection only, up to one year then it is open to public domain, anything else it simply greed.

    Take action against those who can’t work within more tolerant compliance parameters set out, task punitively then, but those inside such parameters of “Compliance through co-operation” are not held to social destruction through prosecutions driven by corporate greed.

    Greed has caused so much destruction in this world.

    I thought most governments had finally realised that.

    By the way greed is driving digital law, it’s apparent this is not the case, punishing society because of greed will not be tolerated by society anymore, the few will not cause adversity to the many without severe consequences.

    Punitive laws will affect everybody in society, not just those outside of governments, police, military, health professionals etc etc, but those people and families among those groups as well.

    Governments should wake up and act fairly towards society, before it’s too late and new legislation’s driven by corporate greed end up tearing the fabric of society apart for as it is already, that fabric is under so much strain it’s nearing tearing point.

    Peace.

    Pax-Delta-Pan

    Enlightened Evolution.
    Tempered From The Chaotic Forge Of Life
    ———————————
    They desire to be Solar, but we are all of Stellar.
    ———————————

  • gorehound

    let sony stop selling their dvd’s in spain so spain can watch all sony films for free by downlopading sounds great.would be good to see sony lose more money and lose face by their asshole remasrks.

  • Pingback: free and thinking» Blogg-arkiv » Poetisk rättvisa – t.o.m makten fultankar IDG.se - Störst på IT, dagliga IT-nyheter, tester, gratis forum, guider, skolor och nyhetsbrev mm

  • Ninja

    “The piracy rate has reached a level where movie companies are even considering putting a halt to selling DVDs in Spain, claiming that it’s just not worth the effort because piracy is baked into Spain’s culture.”

    Go ahead and die. If File sharing did hurt you so badly you wouldn’t be posting record profits. MAFIAA stfu.

  • Pirate

    Hope Indians and Chinese comes next.

    In India no one can control piracy !

  • TSO

    Mmmm, nothing feels better that the good old smell of hypocrisy in the air…

    “Do what we tell you, not what we do.”

  • dannyboy

    @37 nice write up, well said, It’s time for the corporate governments, which means most governments around the world must fall!!

  • Pingback: Links 6/4/2010: Parallels and Ricoh Join The Linux Foundation; PC-BSD 8.1 | Techrights

  • Oldarney

    We really need a leader. We need to write a book, i know it sounds lame.

    Here is the thing, entertainment has been able to corrupt us because of the huge amount of resources it receives, its like porn for men. People would pay for fast downloads at a small price, or movies on a bd disc. Instead of centralized “the money goes to the maker” policy, the world would be “the money goes to the seller, depending on how much he sells.” This decentralization would make it very difficult to mind rape people because studios would not have nearly as much money.

    Jobs. Yes, this is the kicker. While it is extremely difficult to explain the changes that would occur, the optimistic side would be that jobs would increase in quality and education would skyrocket due to the lack of distracting media. Even though media jobs would drop significantly, they would still exist due to the need for news and new content.

    I would propose placing attribution law, instead of copy right as an incentive to innovate. Such law would involve no restrictions on copying public material, but instead would give the original creator credit and a his/her name on every copy sold. This way the owner would be recognized and would sell many more copies then other distributors. As well as being able to get money from book signings and concerts.

    Copyright law is unacceptable bottle cap in the spread human knowledge. This isn’t just about movies, that’s actually a very small issue.

  • Oldarney

    @42 Dannyboy
    I completely disagree. If anything, the Spanish government is an example of how a government could transition into an open information government without copyright on non private material.

  • Pingback: Piracy Update: International News « IMPACT [the blog]

  • Pingback: Doi economisti din Spania critica legile anti-pirati | Partidul Piratilor

  • Pingback: Salou Festival

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.