TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

U.S. Labels Canada a Piracy Haven

The United States Trade Representative has once again labeled Canada as a piracy haven.

In its yearly report on countries that are not doing enough to protect the U.S. copyright industry, Canada is listed on the Priority Watch List with China, Russia, Ukraine and a handful of other countries.

The Special 301 Report reads:

“Canada remains on the Priority Watch List in 2012, subject to review if Canada enacts long-awaited copyright legislation. The Government of Canada has given priority to that legislation. The United States welcomes that prioritization and looks forward to studying the legislation once it is finalized, and will consider, among other things, whether it fully implements the WIPO Internet Treaties, and whether it fully addresses the challenges of piracy over the Internet.”

Other countries are more lucky.

Spain, for example, has been taken off the list after it implemented a harsher copyright law. Last December the US ambassador threatened to put Spain on a trade blacklist if the country failed to pass a SOPA-style site blocking law.

Weeks later the new law passed.

Critics of the yearly “shame” report note that the Trade Representative is not balanced, and that the report is a pressure tool to further the interests of a few big media companies.

“Once again the U.S. Trade Representative has produced a fact-free report that ignored any point of view except that of big media companies,” says Rashmi Rangnath, director of Public Knowledge’s Global Knowledge Initiative

We are distressed that countries which have yet to pass harsh legislation being pushed around the world remain on the watch lists, while countries which give in to U.S. pressure, such as Spain, are removed when they pass punitive legislation,” he adds.

This post is from the News Bits section of TorrentFreak where we present stories from around the web in a concise summary format. Full TorrentFreak articles can be found here. If you have a tip please let us know. News Bits have their very own RSS feed
  • CuntyMcCunt

    Blame Canada, blame Canada!
    With all their beady little eyes and flappin’ heads so full of lies!

    • Danny

      They’re not even a real country anyway!

      • Techno lover

        At least they made it onto the List !

        Maybe next year the U.K. can get on it….. lives in hope

        • Havlentia

           The UK consistently caves to US demands to change laws.  They’re good little consumers and will be rewarded with preferential treatment by the military-entertainment complex.

        • Danny

           Obviously you’re not a fan of South Park ‘Bigger, longer, and uncut!’

    • Tony

      Canadians have never had enough bandwidth to leech anything. Read “Bell internet” and their generous 25 gigabytes a month allotment.

      • Guest

        And we have to listen to united states Comcast users complaining bitterly about their 250gb/month caps and 300kb/s upload speed. That sounds really great in comparison!

    • Beleanu

      Just because you all here are Canadians it dose not mean that you are all right. As long as the world  are pointing finger towards China for patent fraud why makes you think that Canada is more special ? And lets not forget that canada’s economy depends on US consumer not the other way !

  • Fuckoff

    i label the U.S. a pos country

    • Guest

       Most of non-USA citizens label United States as the most terrorist country of all time.

      • Ernesto

        Better word than terrorist is mafia. The US goverment is certainly biggest and most powerful and corrupt mafia in the world. Normal mafia threaten to earn a buck, US goverment actually kills to earn a buck :)

  • None

    oh no, Canada is on a made up ‘list’ .. that means nothing.. 

  • Mainframe Xaiver

    Can someone please explain to me why the US is allowed to bully other nations with out repercussions? 

    • politux

      Nuclear weapons and more spent on defense than the next 15 countries combined most of which are allied with the us.

      • Mainframe Xaiver

        Still not a good enough excuse when infact the us preaches itself as a Democratic country that values peace and diplomacy  ……. so it says lol 

        • Seth

          especially since they are a republic and not a democracy, that what always get me. No such thing as true democracy in today’s world

      • Wayne

         You do realise Russia (who is on the list) has more nuclear subs than the USA, right?

        • Phil Landry

           And they still go to space with their own shuttle!

    • http://www.twitter.com/echoman74 echoman

      blame bush

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100003004662314 Nick Matta

      any objections and we will blow you and your neighboring countries off the face of the earth, that’s why i do everything in my power to stop us before things get ugly

    • DutchGuest

       They ought to rename themselves to the U.S.H. : United States of Hypocrisy

    • GUest

      Because “they saved the jews” now they are allowed to do everything they want.

  • Kr0nZ

    lol imagine US put trade sanctions on Canada, we’re their biggest trading partner

    • http://twitter.com/Wirehedd Wirehedd

      The US is completely and utterly dependent on Canada and should there ever be hostilities between Canada and the US the devastation in the US would be significant. This would mostly be due to the fact that the entire North East of the US would be without electricity. They would lose a major portion of the water they need to survive in the areas where Canadian freshwater is piped in by the millions of gallons and then let’s not forget the massive degree to which the Canadian “bread basket” is responsible for feeding more ‘Merkins than their own farmers.

      To put it succinctly, attacking Canada would be suicidal for the US and they know it. They would have to watch as a large portion of their population froze and starved to death in the dark.

      Ask a ‘Merkin historian why the White House is white. :)

      • dialtone

        damn skippy, you hit the nail on the head. We would whoop their ass worse than we did in the war of 1812! boo yah

      • canadalover

         I’m myself from Holland, and I fully support Canada, let the american jerks in washington put a embargo on canada, lol america will be devistated specially the north east

      • GuySmiley

         I think your a little off with your water facts.
        There are several water plants in R.I. For instance that pipe water into Canada.

        Your somewhat correct with your electricity. 90% of the North East gets their electricity from Niagra falls and locations around there’s water supply. Whether its from the Canadian side of the falls or not who knows.

        • None

          Might want to recheck your “facts” Skippy.

          Most of the eastern seaboard’s power comes from Quebec, not Niagara Falls. As for the water, again, a lot of it is coming out of Northern Ontario and Quebec.  

      • Anonymous

        All the more reasons for the US to invade Canada and seize those assets.

      • higher ambitions

        Is there any organised response to everytime US government is out bulluying other independent countries in this only defending US-money interest? I see a need for consumer retaliation site: “today I bought this or that and I took great care in not buying US (even components/parts if one like). I wont stand for this bullying me and others around!”

        Canada could for once start flicker with the lights and mass camp by the water inlets with truckloads of domestic brewskies flooding down eager throats. At any given moment there is N persons ready to stand up, drop pants and let their water go. Raised prices is the answer to ensure the flickering to stop and the brewskies to dry up. Until next threat of course.. Why co-operate with a weak and depending offensive yelling bully not having the faintest rememberance of the true values of the revolutionary and founding great ideals: Egality, Brotherhood and Liberty. The great thinkers of that time applauded US and there is a lady given as a gift as a memorial of these forgotten high moral values.I mean, even China has higher goals than sticking their head in the sand protecting their precious life-style. Less bullying and not necessarily less democratic. And a true knowledge of that change feeds develepment.

        Personally I have, with little impact on life-style, avoided buying US products since Bush cheated his way to power and it got obvious what a fake-democracy US has become. A wicked tool controlled by shameless shortsighted greed. Opposing every responsability for future generations oftenmost conflict seeking and seldom consensus. Still, where so is acknowledged, it wont be seen through in practice. Sadly once a great promising young nation led by dynamic and visionary leaders. Open and WELCOMING NEW IDEAS embracing them leading away from old empires oppression. Once flew high but is now tumbling in the narrowminded darkness of protectionism. It has indeed become worse than that  forefathers fought and won their freedom from. The negative impact needs in someway to be visualised back in someway. Of course there is one. The world can certainly do w/o US but US can’t do w/o the support as exampled in Wirehedd’s list of Canada providing necessesities like water and electricity. It’s therefore totally bonkers that a bully should be left to do his ugly business when in fact all it takes is all of us putting our foot down stating “’nuff! STFU Start behaving according to international treaties recognising more than the contraproductive, selfish and egoistic approach of own maximal gain in every matter. There doesn’t exist any US foreign operation, including WWII (stood up WWI remember..) where US hasn’t had a personal agenda and calculated pros vs cons. Nothing wrong in countries looking out for themselves but when it nowadays is done giving the bird to the rest of the world I think it deserves to be pointed out. What goes around comes around.

        To the point: I wonder if there is a more organised way to get correlated response to this bullyiing acts. To show that US in fact is LOOSING real money (not only reputation and support) by this stupid ignorant going about ugly business. This has in fact many parallells with the pre-WWII ultimatums made by the Nazi-regime. Both dictated unconditional handing over of specific cultural areas to their control. And, as then, they are meet by the feeble response by weak governments screwing their own people in the interest of foreign money. Where will this end? Orwell/Bradbury fascist-states? Why is this not taken to UN? US doesn’t pay their tribute to UN anyway so their leverage should be weak to say at least!

    • Reaperkaze7

       lol we give them 80% percent of their total imported products, that would be like cutting your own dick off

  • Anyone

    stay strong Canada, the world stands with you

    • wish I was canadian

       +1

                

                               Well done Canada !

  • Fredrika

    > “Spain, for example, has been taken off the list after it implemented a harsher copyright law.”

    This is interesting, because the copyright monopoly in Spain still don’t regulate non-profit use of intellectual works, so normal P2P-filesharing through torrents or Direct Connect is still legal there, including uploading of the latest Hollywood movies.

    This means that countries can legalize non-profit P2P filesharing tomorrow if they want, and it will not result in a 301 listing(which by the way is something countries should be proud of, causing upset feelings amongst US-backed weak failed entrepreneurs that can’t handle themselves on the free market).

  • Logan19572057

    Why the hell doesn’t someone take the arsehole of a department, that has no legitimate say in anything and shut it down.

    • http://www.twitter.com/echoman74 echoman

      it would be the same with the federal reserve aswell as the chamber of commerce neither are government nor federal.

  • NewClear

     The sooner the entertainment industry and government disappear, the better.

    • Michael Manzella

       Then who will entertain us?

      • Guest

        The actual artists.

  • townie2

    lol. ask me if i give a f******. maybe we should turn off the oil, or the electricity, or the…….

    • http://www.twitter.com/echoman74 echoman

      i personally appologize for the idiots who run this country. :/

  • Cujo

    I hope we don’t have to change our national anthem
     
    O Canada!Our home and native land!True patriot love in all thy sons command.
    With glowing hearts we see thee rise,The True North strong and free!!!!!!!
    From far and wide,O Canada, we stand on guard for thee.
    God keep our land glorious and free!!!!!!!O Canada, we stand on guard for thee.
    O Canada, we stand on guard for thee.
     
    cause if the US had thier way  …..  lol

  • townie2

    it’s cool echoman, we know its not the People of the U.S., its the Government and the big corporations.

  • Guest

    Canada threaten to halt all trade with the U.S. unless it stops acting like a little bitch. 

    And then go through with it.

    That would shut some people up mighty fast. And hell, if the U.S. can bully Spain then why can’t Canada bully the U.S.? Fair is fair.

    • Guest

      *Canada should  threaten

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100003004662314 Nick Matta

        russia should threaten, THEN we’d have quite a fair match

        • Wayne

           USA bullied Russia for AllofMP3 and they had to close it.

          As far as I know of, Russia has never managed to close a USA website down for breaking Russian copyright laws (they claimed YouTube was a big piracy website of Russian music/movies).

        • No1_2_u

          Even better; if China told the US to sit down & shut up.

          They also have nukes, they have the biggest army in the world, they are spending tons of money modernizing their enitre army, ALL OF US buy their cheap products; & finally, they’re the US’s biggest creditors.

          When was the last time the US told China anything & they actually did it…

          Who’s got the bigger end of the stick now?

  • womble

    the us wants tarsands so they won’t cause much damage to canada, this is just another bully tactic from our insecure neighbor to the south please grow up soon or no soup for you!!!

  • womble

    Just thinkin’ if canada is a pirate haven then argh! where’s me gold matey!!!!! and just to clarify it’s not the good people of the us that cause trouble it’s the government robots that do the evil deed!!!!! same as in every so called free nation including Canada.

  • ANONYMOUS

    This is how the US bullies other countries into submission…Via the content industry. Pathethic. 

    • Mr. MoneySuit Monacle

      Ever hear of the world bank?
      G20?

  • mhm

    Ya know, I’d like the US to put all those countries on their blacklist, because all its going to do is harm the US economy when they start losing all the trade income, since the blacklisted countries can still trade freely with one another

    • Mpharberts1

      USA has a embargo with Cuba, but Cuba has no embargo with europe, and trade between Cuba and Europe is ok. Who needs USA anyways, with their stupid embargo’s

  • http://twitter.com/Anime4PSP Anime 4 PSP

    Muaha, my country is in this Priority Watch List, and you know what? I’m happy about it. I will never stop pirating :P
    and ffs, other countries not doing enough to protect shit of other country? why in the hell would they even bother to protect shit of other country anyway

  • Fuck America

    U.S is a terrorist haven. The world needs to sanction U.S and disarm their nuclear weapon.

  • 9turd

    Okay, so when will North Korea nuke U.S. so that they got to know their place?

    • Mpharberts1

       hopefully someone will nuke usa

      • Guest

        Hopefully someone won’t. “I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones.” It doesn’t take a genius like albert einstein who said the above words to realise that Thermo-Nuclear war is the last thing our species needs. Do you have any idea what kind of a shit storm nuking the US would create?  you need to sit down, and shut up. That goes for you too, 9turd. Don’t be such a fool.

  • Mr. MoneySuit Monacle

    What the fuck is a watch list anyway?
    Oh no, you’re going to observe us not give a fuck?

  • Anonymous

    Why exactly should it be other countries problems to monitor the united states copyrighted material?

  • http://torrentfreak.com/ Rob8urcakes

    So the equation is -

    USA gov’t + Hollywood movie industry = MEGA-profits & “good, decent” jobs (lol)
    but,
    non-US approved distribution = ZERO-profits + ZERO-jobs = ZERO Hollywood = Yaaaayyyyyyyyy FTW :)

    True or False?
    (PS  No need to post a reply, just click the “Like” button if u reckon the answer is TRUE  heheh )

  • igotabigweenie

    The USA isint a country anymore, Its just a corporation that works on behalf of the elites, All of the citizens are slaves.

    • Anyone

      it’s a cuntry

  • Anonymous

    I’m Canadian. Do we have to go down there and burn the White House down again???????  This was during the War of 1812 when the US was eying up Canada. They wanted to annex us. We didn’t want it then and we don’t want it now. Keep American Politics out of Canada!

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burning_of_Washington

    • Mpharberts1

      totally agree

    • GuySmiley

       Never even heard of this before. IT was a good read.

  • Anonymous

    On another note, if the US is going to continue being the bully, eventually no one will want to play with them anymore. Don’t they get it???

  • Wayne

    Piracy Haven? Well I hope Iran’s on the list because that IS a piracy haven since they’d never follow takedown notices, why? Simply because Iran hates America for all this shit that’s been going on.

    You can get a nice 2Mbps unmetered server hosted in Iran, so it’d be good for a torrent website (but have the torrents themselves hosted on a server outside Iran, just have the main site in Iran to provent takedowns/siezures.) 2Mbps may not seem a lot but it’s perfect for a website which only will buffer HTML content (since the torrents/imgs will be hosted elsewhere).

  • Guest

     The USA isn’t a bad country, it’s the greedy politicians and execs that are pushing all of this.  Kimble is right, the government is just corrupt.  They’re not acting in the interest of its people.

    Canada doesn’t follow the idiotic path set by these greedy sobs.  Canada may not be the best country in the world, but at least they’re not pressing others to stick to an outdated business model.

    • Sandy AJ

      trust me, the american people did not vote for this crap to be happening.  we have no say in a land where companies get the loudest voice due to how much they are willing to pay of an elected official’s election campaign.  and since even the prez owes the money grubbing entertainment industry (who despite piracy are still able to give themselves hefty bonuses) for paying his way into the white house.  so yea we are america land of the not so free home of the pay me to speak

      • Take the freakin foot out!

        we have the same problem all over the countries in Europe – but you can’t see any of our corporations and/or governments bullying their twisted views upon the rest of the world. US need a civil war. An uprising by their enslaved citizens. Protests en masse and pressure put upon the greedy, dirty persons behind the scene. Start with bying a bike and demand for pavements to ride on instead of another car.. ;) That’ll sure get through.. :D

  • Guest

    Canada actually asked to be placed on the list to help pass tougher copyright laws…

    http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/article/1048993–leaks-show-u-s-swayed-canada-on-copyright-bill 

  • Andrew Lee

    They also list Joy.com but I fail to see how selling mining gear = piracy. Maybe it was from the word underground appearing on their website rofl. I was high and looking at sites on the list when I found joy.com page 29 line 2

  • Derpaherp

    Lol at considering Canada a piracy haven.  They’re in the third world of internet regarding bandwidth caps.  Even if piracy is easy, they could get maybe 2-3 HD movies a month before paying an exorbitant amount in b/w overage. Yeah..

  • UniversalSoldier

    ‘ In its yearly report on countries that are not doing enough to protect the U.S. copyright industry’

    Why the hell should other countries put efforts to protect the US copyright industry, don’t they have problems of their own?

    • Guest

       I think the entertainment industry feels that it runs the economy.  If there’s an economic crisis, it MUST be because pirates are downloading movies for free.

      And god forbid that the countries pay attention to unemployment, actual crimes, or any other legitimate problems.  Protecting the U.S. copyright industry… yeah, help the pigs make more money, or else.

  • Guest

    “US ambassador threatened to put Spain on a trade blacklist”
    Get real, like they could afford to put anyone on that blacklist anymore.

  • Anon

    As a Canadian I find this news troubling for the reason that our current administration are inept CIA puppets who will bend to any Washington demand over the wishes of their own people. I can assure you, that a SOPA style information control measure is already in the works here and it will be implemented as soon as it’s ready and we Canadians will be unable to do anything about it.

    The goal of these legislatures is to establish a police state. Control what information the public is allowed to access and you control what they think and what they believe. My great grandfather saw this exact same process happen in Nazi Germany. First it will be the so called “pirate” sites, next it will be all alternative media. Totalitarianism is never sudden, it is always gradual, brought by step by step. And every successive step is justified by lies and propaganda, such as ostensibly “protecting artists”.

    Canada is a nation that is politically dominated by the United States down to the point where it’s independence is in question. All this talk about how we’re going to shut down trade is silly, they’ll just reciprocate the same and the end result would be far worse for us. But nobody in Ottawa has the balls to actually do such a thing so I doubt it would come to that. Like I said, when push comes to shove, our pols will bend over and take it in the ass like the two penny prison queens they are.

    My only hope lies in countries outside of the sphere of US influence, like Russia, China, Vietnam, and Brazil, which combined may be able to provide a strong obstacle to the global geopolitical plan that Washington has in store for humanity. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/chillinfart Arturo Julio Zevallos Córdova

    Don’t Forget Peru/Colombia (both governments, specially peru, are trying to put in silence an menacing article in a trade with the EU)
    http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/16/eu-peru-idUSL5E8EG2LC20120316
    http://www.peruhardware.net/foros/showpost.php?p=2621000&postcount=18

    And Chile/Peru (both governments are trying to put in silence the TPP, specially Chile)
    http://keionline.org/node/1091
    http://www.derechosdigitales.org/2012/04/11/notpp-se-deniega-el-acceso-a-la-informacion-de-negociaciones-secretas-que-chile-sostiene-en-el-tpp/

  • Anon

    Haha.  USA bullies other countries for not doing enough to protect the “US copyright industry”, but the US in turn doesn’t give a shit about the other countries industries.

    All your money are belong to the US!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_G54GSRZNYTDCZYPPZDGK53HL6M PadThai

    How long until the USA declares Canada a rogue nation?

  • :D

    LOL Canada.

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.