TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Hacktivists Protest Proposed Shutdown of P2P Sites

The Spanish Government is working on new legislation under which hundreds of file-sharing sites that are currently perfectly legal, could be shut off. In a response to these plans, a group of hacktivists have launched a clever campaign to prove that the proposal is useless, and that the Government might as well close down the whole Internet.

la lista de sindeSpanish courts have ruled repeatedly that operating a file-sharing oriented website without profiting directly from infringements falls within the boundaries of the law. In an attempt to change this, the Spanish Government has recently proposed new legislation under which sites offering links to copyright works could be taken offline without a judicial order.

It comes as no surprise that the announcement has been met with firm opposition from activists and hacktivists, who quickly organized several protests. Two weeks ago someone defaced the site of a local anti-piracy outfit, replacing it with a manifesto on the rights of Internet users.

Today, the group ‘Hacktivistas’ launches yet another campaign protesting against Spanish Government plans. The campaign is titled La Lista de Sinde, which is a reference to the Spanish title of the movie Schindler’s List and a direct response to the ‘list’ of 200 file-sharing sites that the major royalties collection societies presented to the Ministry of Industry recently.

The campaign website allows the public to embed a search box on their own website, turning it into a ‘file-sharing’ search engine. Users can choose a box that searches the BitTorrent site isoHunt, or one that uses a customized Google search engine that indexes many file-sharing sites.

For their part, Hacktivistas will then make a list of all the ‘sinning’ sites who use the embed code that they offer. Once this list is long enough it will also be sent to the Ministry of Industry with a clear message, along the lines of: ‘You’ll have to go after all of us.’

“The goal of this action is to tell the Government: ‘if you are going to close 200 sites, here are another 200,000 – you will have to shut the whole Internet down!’ It is a strategy of massive social disobedience,” a member of Hacktivistas told TorrentFreak.

“We hope that this action raises even more awareness and the Government steps back. If they don’t and the law is finally approved, we will ask them to prosecute us. We’re confident that a situation were the Government has to close thousands of websites won’t be sustainable for them,” the Hacktivist added.

Those who want to participate in the campaign can grab the code on La Lista de Sinde.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • Asdfjkl

    I love this story

  • ytb

    go el hacktivistas!

  • Cujo

    redundancy ;)

  • Magma

    interesting story…. hope the government gives up on this one

  • kkk

    “We’re confident that a situation were the Government”

    were should be where

  • Positron

    Quite a clever approach coming from this ‘Hacktivistas’ group. I think their strategy has real potential and if it catches on with enough website owners, they might just succeed in making the Spanish Government refrain from putting its ridiculous proposals into law. Interesting to see how this plays out.

  • Zush

    “La lista de Sinde [the current Minister of Culture]” can also be translated as “Sinde, that smartass”!

  • needs a raise

    hope it works!

  • anonymouse

    i certainly hope this campaign is successful but if you had been paid loads of money in ‘back handers’ to do a certain job under threat of some sort if you failed, would you give up? of course you wouldn’t! nor will the Spanish or any other government. money talks louder than anything. until the copyright industries achieve everything they want, they will not give up. they have the bottomless pit of money to enable them to do that. that is how they can go back to court, time after time after time, when the verdict is contrary to the one they want! their whole aim is to OWN the internet. shuting down web sites is a by product on the way to the real goal. fineing people under the guise of copyright infringement distracts from that main aim! see if i aint proved right!!

  • Tigger

    Heh – good on em!

    I love the term “social disobedience” – just rolls off the tounge ;)

  • BreinLovesMyHairyDick

    This shows how dumb people can be.

  • diarRIAA

    Pirates are lazy and passive and no one will join in.

    Unlike the media corporations. They Invest time and money to help them gain access to high powered law makers luring them, lying to them, bribing them, brainwashing them and threatening them. The media corporations are proactiv and are very experienced and capable of changing laws to suit their needs. Heck they even have us taxpayers pay for their witch hunts against widows, seniors, pregnant women, low income families, disabled children and more.

    The media corporations work very hard against all of us and always get what they want. Why? Because we are lazy and passive.

  • whoo FLung Dung

    Ya ye Spanish Dagos ya’ll screwed

  • gorehound

    Good.This sounds good and a good idea for when other countries think they will trod on people’s internet freedom.
    and as far as corporate media goes i do hope you are getting the message out there.
    Stop Feeding The Pig !!!
    Buy corps stuff used
    Buy Indie stuff new

    Fuck off MPAA,RIAA, and all your stooges.

  • Printer

    I think you’d like to include in the article that “La Lista de Sinde” is not only a reference to the famous movie, but also to the current Minister of Culture: 2Ángeles González Sinde”. So the name of this campaign is an evident pun with the minister’s name ;-)
    You’d also like to know, that this minister is a movie script writer herself, and since she arrived to the government, she’s increased ‘aids’ to the Spanish cinema with many millions of €, and she has repeatedly ignored claims of incompatibility between her job as script write and her job as the minister who decides who’s awarded with ‘cultural aids’. Amazing, right?
    Cheers~

  • Proud

    Good job! We need to make our voices heard!

  • me

    Nice… but useless. All European governments will force the EU Copyright Directive down our throats. It doesn’t matter how unpopular they are. Spain is no exception.

    And, frankly, with Pirate Parties ranging from 7% to 0.5% across Europe (median 0.8% or so?), it doesn’t seem all too (un)popular anyway. At least not yet.

    Whatever. We’ll keep ignoring their silly laws and it will be business as usual. A few of us file sharers will be thrown under a (legalistic) bus, but they can’t destroy all of us.

  • hmm

    translate the page to english! i’m not going to learn spanish just to help the cause! english is the world language!

  • rakiru

    So where’s your search box, torrentfreak? ;P

  • DanielRemains

    Hey people you have to respect that not everyone is english eh

    Go here:

    http://translate.google.com/

  • Rboy

    I guess this means that the spanish government law will shut down google as well in that country since it points to thousands of copywrited links.

    Fricking retards

  • Ninja

    Added to my site. Awesome initiative!!!

    To quote Mr John:

    “Handing over our cash to a game company (or any company for that matter) is a privilege, not a right.”

    Full post at http://www.bityard.com/gaming/Game-companies-hate-used-games-but-that-s-their-fault

    MAFIAA and merry friends should understand that already.

  • iFox

    @18

    Perhaps you have been living in America too long, but English is NOT the world language. In fact Spanish is known in more places than English. It may be true that some Spanish speaking countries teach basic English now in public schools, but they will likely never (need to)use it except to get a passing grade.

    ;P I suppose there is the chance you are not American. And before anyone starts talking about me hating Americans I am American myself. xP

  • amused

    Spanish is the 1st language in more countries than english.

    This wont work as too many people think they deserve to download anything for nothing and think it is their right to do so. The majority wouldn’t have a clue how to set up a web site, never mind add a piece of code to it.

    A downside to the whole p2p network is that so many claim to have rights but never do anything about it (other than embarrass those that work to promote p2p)

    Get some knowledge before you post.

  • _Captain Blackbeard_

    This is great news. Glad people are standing up to these bas tards. People also need to use decentralized programs (bt with mainline plugin for dht) & w ww.emule-project.net . Until Bittorrent comes out totally decentralized (well to use without having to have torrents, well scratch that, the ed2k network can share torrents too (although not as easy as a website and point and click.) but there are ed2k sites also like ww w.tvunderground.org.ru

    Also if you do happen to actually have a legitimate business, the mafia will do this to you

    “Record-store owner pleads guilty to Copyright Act charge over bootleg CDs” h tt p://bit.ly/5PulkD
    A Ottawa record store owner grudgingly pleaded guilty to a single charge under the Canadian Copyright Act, then took a reluctant pause before admitting to possessing 100 illegal CDs discovered in an RCMP raid earlier this year.

    “I can’t afford to fight it. It’s such a shame,” David Nolan said outside the courtroom, adding he felt “ripped off.”

    RCMP raided Nolan’s Wellington Street record shop — Legend Records — in April 2009 after an undercover agent bought CDs in January. Agents from the Canadian Recording Industry Association (CRIA) subsequently said the CDs violated Canadian copyright law.

    RCMP seized about 500 CDs in the April raid.

    About 200 were returned to Nolan, leaving 294 CDs that were deemed to be in contravention of Canadian copyright law.

    Many of these CDs were not illegal at all, Nolan’s lawyer Mark Lazarovitz said, including albums by local group The Townsmen that Nolan had helped finance.

    The final figure of 100 illegal CDs was a somewhat arbitrary figure acceptable to Lazarovitz and Crown attorney Rob Zsigo.

    Nolan said he often tracks down rare CDs that are unavailable in North America to satisfy his customers. Often the original copyright holders are dead, he said. cont on above link

  • Anonymous

    Most people would rather see the music and movie industries destroyed than the internet. The internet provides a real benefit to humanity, the media companies provide base entertainment for people to waste their time on.

  • \\.neo.styles|sSG

    Right, because shutting down website that rob people of their rightful profits and livlihood is the same as shuttin down the internet.. Is this what it really does to you?

  • 000

    I think its a joke that a year or two ago filesharing was deemed legal in Spain and yet the lobbyist still have the power to change that ruling. And if they cant change it the first time around you know they’ll keep trying year after year until they get what they want..

  • Tomas

    I just don’t understand why this keeps happening. Countries where non-profit file sharing is legal seem to all be changing their minds. What is so different now compared to when they decided it was fine? I mean beside the music and film undustries campaign.

    It’s part of a cultural identity, the promotion of sharing and development of artistic appreciation. Those ideals are what make those countries attractive to people like me, where in this country there is no reward for success, people only ever want you to fail. The governments seem to care little about throwing away their own ideals now, so they can help the rich get richer.

  • Rioja

    Cabron! speak out loud thats it! And put those bull-fights to an end too !

  • George

    Presumably they’d also have to shut down Google too, given it has one of these search boxes thingies, quite prominently displayed as I recall

  • Tomas

    @27 Get this into your head:

    IT IS LEGAL IN THEIR COUNTRY

    Those people are doing nothing wrong. Their law says so.

  • Cordelia

    WHAT A NICE IDEA.
    How do you get the plugin that searches these sites?

  • anon

    “We’re confident that a situation were the Government has to close thousands of websites won’t be sustainable for them”

    Really? One would think, closing down all those websites would free up a lot of bandwidth, saving a lot of money. And that’ll give people more free time to get a job, and money, and buy stuff; instead of freeloading it. That’s the plan it seems. So, hacktigeeks just basically screwed themselves over.

    Well done you morons.

  • A non mouse

    Quoted from Blackbeards link above…

    He is to appear in court again on April 1.

    What a joke of a appearance that will be!

  • Reasoned Mind

    I enjoy these stories of hacktivists. They make law enforcement look evenhanded, and they give government reason. The global plan is working and on schedule.

  • noname

    sorry off topic,

    people in the Uk needs to be buying “rage against the machine – killing in the name off” today!! so they get xmas number 1 and knock that simon cowle and cronys off the top spot

    ratm said they will do a FREE uk gig if they win

    http://www.nme.com/news/rage-against-the-machine/48961

    come on buy some music just once :)
    can buy the single online at iTunes and what not

  • VIVA P2P

    LONG LIVE P2P !

  • Hostench

    Follow this for the real spanish decree of right of the internet users #manifiesto on twitter

  • Any Guy

    ummm yeh more countries have spanish as their first language, but there are infact more english speaking people in the world no matter what country they come from. Besides thats dwarfed by mandarin (mainly) and cantonese chinese anyhow. Being european myself i know most of my neighbour countries languages, enough to hold a half decent convo with anyway. And have u ever heard of google/babel translate? It would give u an idea anyway.

    @24 to make a website nowadays is easy, infact i can tell u in 3 steps.
    Register at godaddy
    Choose one of their wordpress, joomla, mambo etc auto installations.
    Its installed so add the code to the front page.
    Voila.
    Was that hard?

    Anyway thanks to these guys they have thought up a brilliant idea, but thoose of us who do actually do something have already search engines on our websites for torrents. So are they going to take the spanish google servers offline? I can search torrents using google too..

  • Anonymous

    English is and should be the international language. The fact that it’s not the FIRST language of the majority has NOTHING to do with it. Because if that were so we would be speaking MANDARIN (which is chinese btw) not freaking spanish.

    neo.styles:
    rob people of their rightful profits and livlihood

    says you…
    I say that they should be locked up for trying to stop other people from doing what they want in their private lives.

    THAT’S robbery of rights, not your ass-twisted imaginary crap.

    If you restrict my rights I’m gonna restrict your right to post and talk, in return. You are robbing me of my rightful ability to go on the internet without encountering morons like you.

  • Lab5

    Nice play!!

    I Love it, all the webs pages become a p2p search engine :)

    Good work, hacktivistas.net is now in my bookmark :)

  • The Old Codger

    To those that like to point out other peoples spelling mistakes please note:

    1) Not all people posting on here are native English people.

    2) To paraphrase the Bible – He who has never made a spelling mistake throw the first stone.

    Now back on topic:

    @ 12 – I love all your comments but stop bitching and take the example of the Spanish and start the same action in your respective countries and if you need instruction on how to to it then take the advice of @40.

    Power to the people

  • Anonymous

    #34 you’re ******* kidding right? “save money”? You mean the economy will suffer tremendously if the internet is shut down, right? Heck let’s go back to the 1950s, surely the economy would be much improved.

    You know, the MAFIAA is not the center of the economic system, you moron.

  • t00m

    Please everybody, give us your two cents. Help hacktivism! Spread the idea.

  • ET

    ooooo.

    rage against the machine for number one.

    http://www.epictorrents.com

  • cosy

    mola

  • b4nd0ler0

    Pretty simple to do really, just open an account on any blogging site like blogspot.com and start a new blog. Edit in html mode and paste the code from hacktivistas.net and off you go, you have a torrent search page. http://b4nd0l3r0.blogspot.com/

  • mudisoft

    enough with the Spanish legislation people. aren’t they tired already?

  • JTK

    Very good idea. In fact they might as well shut Google down since it indexes virtually every torrent on the Internet.

  • Celestias

    Good luck! I really respect your efforts. And remember; if you torrent something and end up liking it enough to deserve a purchase, do like how I and many of us do; buy it! The product’s developers deserve it. As for if you download something and know you wouldn’t have purchased it anyway, don’t buy it, as either way that product’s developers wouldn’t have gained a purchase. Monitor yourself and be fair.

    Once again, good luck Hacktivistas, and may torrents live on!

  • Scooby

    “A site offering links to copyrighted works” could describe pretty much every web page on the internet. I’m pretty sure most of the web pages on the internet are copyrighted material in some way or another, or contain such, and therefore any link to a web page is a link to copyrighted material. Therefore, as this article describes the proposed new law, most of the entire internet would become illegal.

  • whoo FLung Dung

    To download get the BitTorrent client here and a .torrent file from any of the torrent search engines listed above (“Download Torrent” button/link)
    Using BitTorrent is legal, downloading copyrighted material isn’t. Be careful of what you download or face the consequences.

  • whoo FLung Dung

    Google also in trouble
    “A Paris court finds Google is infringing copyright, ordering it to pay €300,000 to a French publisher, and €10,000 a day until it removes extracts of the publisher’s books from its database.”

    Copyright infringement (or copyright violation) is the unauthorized or prohibited use of works covered by copyright law, in a way that violates one of the copyright owner’s exclusive rights, such as the right to reproduce or perform the copyrighted work, or to make derivative works.
    Wikipedia

    So yes reproducing (copying[sharing]) is illegal

  • Tomas

    #34
    What an idiot you are. You think the number of websites on the internet dictates how much it costs?

    It will cost MORE money because they need to go and spend money on getting the site shut down. Guess what – pick up a cheap/free computer from ebay, your friend or whoever, install a LAMP stack on it and voila. Another web server set up. That cost me nothing or almost nothing. It then costs the Spanish government money to come and track me down and close the server. By that time some other guy has already set up his one.

    If I just take these here glasses that have little rose tinted lenses and put them on… oooh. Now your moronic point makes sense. Yeah, no more torrent sites so I will go outside and see the world in a whole new light. I’ll get a new job and feel all warm and fuzzy inside, everyone will smile and greet me by my first name even if I don’t know them. Fluffy bunnies will hop down the street and rainbows will sprout miraculously from the ground.

  • Borderliner

    #53 “Using BitTorrent is legal, downloading copyrighted material isn’t. Be careful of what you download or face the consequences.”

    That is one thing that needs to be clarified – this depends on local law. Yes, the unauthorized public (ie, not with your personal friends) *sharing* of copyrighted material is illegal in most places (I won´t say “everywhere” as I don´t know that with certanity) but different countries have different views on the “getting” part. I know that in my country the law leaves a hole that can be interpreting as “downloading is allowed regardless wether the sharing was legal”.
    Such differences are one of the reason for the whole confusion regarding piracy – some say it´s illegal, some say it isn´t, and they´re both righ. *Sometimes*.

  • XavZz

  • Pingback: Clevere Kampagne gegen Anti-Filesharing-Gesetz in Spanien : netzpolitik.org

  • 3ohfive

    what a fantastic idea. once it is no long economically feasible for them to shut down everyone they will stop messing with us. because lets face it that’s what they revolve around, money.

  • Pingback: SkyRebel Communications » Blog Archive » Hacktivists Protest Proposed Shutdown of P2P Sites

  • Lord HAAAha

    You have to go where its actually happening that is the law makers. On another post Kiwi wondered if its the people or government that rule as in a democracy or republic? Its money baby!Actually Government and the people are the servants both. The wealthy pay the bill for what they want on the bill. The requirement for reelection is money to put your message (elect ME) across. This is the way of political science that is the rational truth, not just some pol-doublespeak mumble wave hands magic. Thats for the jokers that want reelected despite their sin. PS its why media control is so important to the doublespeak crowd. No use getting the rabble roused eh what? That upsets the order of things. What do you think someone could vote?

  • zeebart

    @ 54 didn`t u just copy that from someone`s website without their permission?…LOL

  • Pingback: SkyRebel Communications Network » Blog Archive » La Lista de Sinde

  • totallyynectarr@aim.com

    this was actually touching, im tired of government interference in everything.i hope all goes. <3

  • Alphasee

    en ingles por favor!

    In english, please!

  • Rave

    IF P2P is blocked or banned… I WILL cancel my internet connection..!!!

  • ALPHABETSOUP

    The Main Deal with P2P Programs is the film industry and music industry bitching and complaining they are not making the millions of dollars they thought they could have made.But a message to Them we are not living in the 80′s anymore!
    File Sharing programs will never truly go away, even if they do you can shut down as many sites as you like but someone will create a New file sharing program shortly after for file sharing eventually anyways. Downloading files from the computer is perfectly legal and for those people who think we are getting Music and Movies for free on the internet is NOT!!! I repeat NOT a problem of P2P networks nor the users!!!! People who Download media such as music and movies have that Right as we ALL PAY a monthly internet access fee!

  • ALPHABETSOUP

    Every computer in the world comes equipped with that Elusive download button.For acquiring updates for personal computers. Does that mean whenever I download a MICROSOFT update
    to my PC I’m doing something Illegal? Because Microsoft is also a copyright.
    I honestly think the reason for the shutdown of P2P programs is because some idiot in the world has no idea how to use P2P programs/the download button and is Jealous of the fact he does not know how to use it.It’s simple one click of the right button on the mouse and download! Activating that button also allows you to “COPY” & “PASTE” is that also illegal?

  • ALPHABETSOUP

    Could they also go after Microsoft for having a COPY button? Name Brand electronics Company’s Such As SONY,MAXWELL,PANASONIC ect ect.. for supplying people with DVD BURNERS, DVD RECORDERS,VCR Players,Blue Ray Burners,PVR’S,Blank CD/DVD Media,DIVX players… The list goes on and on.Where do you draw the line??
    All of these products were made with a recording button for a purpose and that purpose neglects copyright infringement laws in itself.

  • ALPHABETSOUP

    I don’t believe it’s fair for the Movie and Music industry to be targeting NON PROFIT Organizations for their personal gain which is greed! Torrent sites have nothing to do with it nor do torrent users.Go for the Big Fish, let the little fish grow.

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.