TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Publishers Fear eBook Piracy, But Shouldn’t

The music industry has made it quite clear that the Internet is a scary place full of pirates. These same fears have spread into the minds of book publishers, who are about to make the same mistakes as the major record labels did. It’s not too late though.

The list of most pirated eBooks of 2009 is mostly filled with geek manuals, dating tips and self-help guides. At the end of the year, Dan Brown, Stephen King, Stephenie Meyer and J.K Rowling were the only best selling authors that made it into the top 25.

One of the explanations for this apparent ‘lack of piracy’ is the fact that eBook readers are still an exclusive gadget. When compared to uptake of MP3-players, only a tiny fraction of the online population has an eBook reader, which makes it a niche audience.

Theoretically the piracy figure could explode when eBook devices become both affordable and desirable to the mainstream public, especially if the publishing industry makes the same mistakes as the major record labels did. Let’s take a look at how they’re doing thus far.

Before we start it’s worth noting that three of the classic mistakes discussed below are made by the publishers or authors whose books were pirated the most. Coincidence?

DRM

DRM doesn’t work. It only takes one person to strip the DRM from an eBook to make it available to millions, but it also prevents legitimate customers from using the book they way they want to. Unfortunately not all book publishers have learned from the music industry’s DRM failures.

According to CNN, Hachette Book Group, publisher of the ‘Twilight’ series, “considers copyright protection to be of paramount importance,” claiming that “piracy is a serious issue for publishers.” You can almost hear the fear in these statements, fear that will most likely result in a strong focus on DRM instead of offering a great service to readers.

Stephenie Meyer, the author of the ‘Twilight’ books, is even more pro-DRM than her publisher. After one of her forthcoming books leaked onto the Internet in 2008, she simply cancelled the book. You can’t get more restrictive than that.

Delay

Simon & Schuster, the publisher of Stephen King’s ‘Under the Dome’, delayed the release of the eBook version for a few weeks, allegedly because they feared that it would cannibalize hardcover sales. This is one of the stupidest mistakes a publisher can make. The only thing it does is annoy customers, guaranteeing less sales.

Those interested in a digital version of the book could get one on file-sharing sites anyway. Within days, scanned versions of ‘Under the Dome’ surfaced online, and even perfect replications of the book in text format. The result for the publisher is that tens of thousands of people have downloaded the unauthorized eBook versions, many of which might have bought it if it was available.

Digital Ban

J.K Rowling is copying the Beatles by refusing to make her Harry Potter books available in digital form. As a result her books are among the most pirated titles year after year. Every single book from the Harry Potter series is available digitally, either scanned or transcribed by fans.

Luckily, there are also publishers who have learned from the mistakes made by the music industry. CNN quotes Ana Maria Allessi, publisher for Harper Media, who focuses on the upside of digital books. According to Allessi, new technologies will offer benefits to consumers, authors and publishers.

“Consumers who invest in one of these dedicated e-book readers tend to load it up and read more,” she added. “And what’s wrong with that?”

Alessi’s right. The focus should be on offering an outstanding product and user experience. Give consumers what they want, for a decent price, and don’t let those music industry folks scare you.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • http://www.eZee.se www.eZee.se

    If they are stupid enough to listen to the music industry…nothing we say can change their minds.

    And if they are REALLY dumb… they will repeat the music industries mistakes – nothing we can do to stop it.

  • Anonymous

    It’s just hard to replace a book, even with an ebook reader, so i dont think book piracy is ever gonna skyrocket

  • free: the future of a radical price

    Would highly recommend a book which bears the title of my name. It’s free online, and it’s all about what this article is about. Well researched and all, personally I got it via torrent or nzb ( I download so much I can’t even remember which ).
    In my personal opinion I agree with research that suggests that humans are programmed fro scarcity and scarce environments. Fear has to be the order of the day with anyone who is in business to make money, simply because fear and greed are the primary emotions felt by anyone interested in making large sums of money, or just about any business transaction.
    Also I would like to promulgate the old party line of knowledge being as it should: free.
    Happy holidays and happy downloading.

  • Tigger

    Fear pure and simple.
    They are afraid and want us to feel the same.
    It really is a shame considering how far we have come as a species – fear still rules supreme. I hope one day we can put all this nonsense behind us and simply respect one another.

    Piracy may cost publishers a teeny percentage of profits (or maybe not! heh!) But to deny yourself money and your potential readers the satisfaction of reading your media, all because it “might get pirated” seems totally insane!

    “knowledge being as it should: free.” – you said it!

  • Yakushev

    I love J.K Rowlings reasoning, she is afraid of putting up her books online because they would be pirated.

    Which sounds sensible until you realise THEY ARE ALREADY PIRATED! Every single one available online at this very moment!
    She is losing a lot of potential sales for no reason at all.

  • E

    How is this different from public libraries, which have already existed for a long time? Maybe they should be lobbying to close libraries…? :)

    The example of the Baen Free Library suggests that there is nothing to fear:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baen_Free_Library

  • Mako

    I’d like to add one more to the list:

    PROPRIETARY FORMATS

    Offering ebooks in a proprietary format that can only be read by specific ebook readers is just another thing to encourage piracy. Those potential buyers who have incompatible ebook readers will be forced to find a pirated copy of the book in a generic format. This is one of the primary reasons I haven’t gotten an ebook reader yet, even though I would very much like to have one.

  • Brandon

    Oh man, I just found out that you can goto ANY library and get books, audiobooks, dvd movies, cd music for FREE!!! I guess they should shut down those pesky Pirating Librarys…

  • Anonymous

    Its also worth noting that by not distributing works in an electronic form publishers are putting those people with a disability at an disadvantage.
    Admitidly, this only impacts a tiny amount of users, but do any of you know how hard it is to do a degree with out any of your set works?

  • nomis

    I’ve bought sooo many hard copy books after first downloading PDFs to check them out. I recently purchased the complete set (5) of Card College books for £150 after seeing them all in scanned PDF form.

  • chris

    @10 spam !

  • Jay

    Book publishers are worse than music producers for ripping off the people who make there content.

    Firstly when a new book gets taken on by a publisher an advance is usually given, this advance depends on how much they think the book will sell.

    This advance is not free money its taken from the sales of the book so the advance has to be paid off before any revenue for the author is given and if the book flops and does not make the advance it has to be paid back.

    The royalties from the book paid to the author are not much, the best paid authors either have wrote tons of books OR made money on merchandising and movies and such that’s how J/K Rowling made her cash.

    The real reason book publishers fear digital distribution is that they will not be able to hide the fact that they are ripping off there authors if the publishing cost is close to zero? why give them 90%+ of the revenue for what? organising digital distribution?

    Thats the real reason there afraid the same with the music producers

  • Anonymous

    i find very hard to read a “ebook” even reading a PDF that have more that 10 pages is a pain for me
    paper books FTW

  • Recton Kracke

    I’m lucky to own a Sony PRS 700. Great gadget if you love books like me. On it there are both ‘downloaded for free’ and purchased e-books from sony’s online bookstore.

    Sony’s online e-book store gets a 5/10 from me. Not enough selection or titles atm. Some books not available in my location? Pricey too although the e-books are nice with illustrated covers & diagrams. (bbebook format).

    Downloading e-books for free off the net is a mixed bag too however. The quality is typically poorer (scanned PDF or txt format). There are TONS of technical manuals and computer guides out there but its hard to find good recreational reading…hard but not impossible.

    In order to read what I want on the PRS 700 I gotta do both.

  • Anonymous

    These book publishers need not worry about people sharing their books. I own an Irex Iliad and let me tell you ebooks are not all that cracked up to be. I still prefer a hard copy over digital readers. And as for the music industry bitching about piracy, these are two different industry. The fall of music has nothing to do with people sharing, more to do with the quality being produced. Let’s face it books has a more wider need than music.

  • Statistics Lie

    The books (not ebooks) I buy, I usually read, the ones I have downloaded, I rarely do.

  • haha

    hahha

  • Pingback: === popurls.com === popular today

  • kerijade

    I read just over 500 books this year. Almost all off of my ereader, which I thought I would hate until I actually got one and used it.

    I couldn’t afford to buy that many books (500+) if I had to buy them in print. Ebooks are about half price or less (and 100 times more convenient).

    I have discovered there is an entire crop of ewriters who will never see their works in “real print” and yet they are enjoyed by many.

    People who are ‘readers” will always read, no matter the format. Everyone listens to music but every year less people are actively literate enough to actually buy any books and could care less if books are pirated or not. And…if the music industry had adapted instead of running afraid, they could have saved themselves easily.

  • \\.neo.styles|sSG

    Willingly putting digital versions of your work out there doesn’t seem like it would conceivably make any difference. In this day and age, no one seems to see the problem with not paying for anytyhing and are determined to pirate things without any sort of moral boundaries. Whether something is pirated 2,000 or 2 million times, no one seems to care, since artists and content holders are apparantly purely mythical and dont depent on compensation at all. Making things available in digital form only makes the pirates job easier, making them more inclined to engage in theft.

  • Fear Us

    Dear Book Publishers, Fear us. Fucking fear the shit out of us. We don’t give a shit about you. Information should be free, and we’re taking it. We may be the barbarians invading Rome, but the barbarians won. We don’t give a fuck about anybody – and certainly not you.

  • Ebook Piracy?

    Maybe book readers might be more conscientious about the profit by authors, since they tend to be smaller than typical movie stars. So maybe the won’t pirate.
    Ha ya right ;)
    http://www.electroniccigaretteratings.com

  • Pingback: Anonymous

  • An interested reader

    Perhaps people should look at http://www.Baen.com, the Sci-fi/Fantasy publisher who has not only published their books online and DRM free for a number of years in a variety of formats, but also allowed a number of them to be freely available to readers.

    They have a very interesting write up with sales data about their online sales policy (although it is somewhat dated now).

  • me

    #14 jay: “why give them 90%+ of the revenue for what? organising digital distribution?”

    What do you think a proofreader/editor costs? A professional layouter? A designer for the cover? And of course the printing (forget eBooks, they’ll remain irrelevant for a long time, despite the hype), distributing, marketing, etc.? Especially if we’re talking technical and text books which sell approx. 3,000 to 20,000 copies at most, and take a year to write and get right?

    I’m a 2x published tech book author, and yes, I’m annoyed too at getting just 12% to 14% of the publishers’ price (NOT retail price!) for every book sold, but I could have had a better deal if I did the layouting, designed the cover myself etc. — maybe around 20% to 25% or so. But, writing is my area of expertise, and not fiddling around with LaTeX or Photoshop to make things look good and as they are supposed to be. I’m not superhuman either to catch every typo and other error despite proofreading the text 3 to 4 times in a row… so I have to rely on other people’s work to turn a decent good book into a great book ready for publication.

    So, despite feeling kind of getting a bad deal, it’s not as bad as for music artists who get really ripped off by the labels they foolishly picked.

  • MD3

    PUBLISHERS, read this thought:

    I think it’s much better that people share a good book on the Internet and spread the word about it being awesome, thus making other people (or even the own person) buy it legally, than forcing an individual on buying a possibly bad book without reviewing it entirely, only to become completely frustrated with it, causing the person bash it and its author for the entire near future, hampering its current sales, or even next editions.

  • Ninja

    I don’t like to read in the pc. Never tried an ebook so I”m not gonna give my opinion on that.

    In any case, nowadays I do download some books to check if they are worth buying. If the first 50-60 pages cannot get me hooked up I won’t buy.

    If I can’t at least preview, I won’t buy. End of the story. And I will break the DRM even if I buy so I can do whatever I want. Would you please spare me from the additional effort of breaking your DRM in the future?

    It’s all about old ppl and models running up there. Once they are renewed for younger and saner ppl it’ll change…

  • Dex M

    E-books?

    Audio books are way better.

  • Librarian

    Books are free, all you need is a library card…..

  • CCC

    I think the reason why ebook piracy is low not only because ebook reader is expensive but rather most people still prefer reading book from actual book.

    it will take one generation to replace such habit

  • ed2k/kad

    @16 thanks, I will look into getting one of those readers, @18 yes its the same for me because it is not convient to carry laptop around everywhere so I need a ebook reader see @16 on maybe which one to get I am going to look into the one they said.

    @25 I did used to get audio books but my I loaned out my dreameo video player to a so called friend and they lost the cord. I was going to buy another cord but its $50 so I think I will just buy a new dreameo for $100 for audio book side. Its also good to listen to the bible on which is the whole reason I purchased it before since I didn’t want to be tied down to the pc and other mp3 players seemed to like skip half of the bible since it has so many chapters and stuff they leave em off. Anywho, thanks for all reminder about it and thanks to all else.

    Piracy For Life

  • me

    I read a lot of books but I only buy them in book sales at libraries.

    $1.00 for hardbacks
    $0.50 for paperbacks

    Or $5.00 to fill a bag, usually with 10 to 15 books.

  • FukPiratez

    Might as well give up publishers. The pirates will pirate no matter what. It’s too late. An entire generation has been raised believing they are entitled to free shit. They lack respect for any intellectual property whatsoever.

    They will simply tell you that you should be happy to give your books away for free and should make your money, instead, selling trinkets or charging for book readings. Or perhaps, they’ll suggest you fill the margins with advertising. They’ll blame it on greedy corporations because they don’t understand how the book advance system works just as they don’t understand how record companies front the initial money for music production, distribution, and advertising. They’ll rehash the BS about how they buy more books because they stole your book. Too bad it wasn’t your book among those they bought.

    The library metaphor isn’t apt. When you are done with a library-loaned object, you are supposed to return it.

    My textbook is already pirated on the internet, and I can tell you it has had a significant effect on my projected sales. My own students bring pirated versions to class. Luckily, I don’t have to live off those sales.

  • Anonymous

    Its not piracy but FEAR that makes them do stupid thing’s .

  • Anonymous

    If they are going to remove our rights of ownership and block us from selling, lending or giving our books away then they are worthless & deserve to be pirated.

  • Dan

    *Off topic*

    As I don’t see any other place to post this, TPB is offline here in Canada. I have a bad feeling. :(

  • Liudvikas

    Quality is the reason why ebooks are pirated less. If I want to get a movie, I can find almost any movie in HD format, I don’t have bluray player, so it’s an only option for me to watch movies in best quality.
    If I need music, I can get any popular track of perfect quality, often way better than tracks on itunes.
    On the other hand, if I want a book, there’s three options:
    1. I could spend a fortune on ebook reader and buy the ebooks. It’s rather expensive. Even if I download the books its still expensive.
    2. I could download the books and burn my eyes reading it on my laptop. It’s rather uncomfortable.
    3. I could buy a hard copy of a book rather cheaply, most of the books I read are under the price of 10$.
    Plus the quality of downloadable ebooks is bad, they are often poorly scanned.

  • Computershack

    “The music industry has made it quite clear that the Internet is a scary place full of pirates.” – Torrentfreak.

    Err no. You’ve done that yourself with your “top 10″ download lists with figures in the millions…..Its not exactly going to do anything to counter the argument. Kind of shooting yourself in the foot.

  • lol

    One word.

    iTablet.

    Lets see what happens when that hits the fanbois.

  • Pingback: eBook Piracy Worries Publishers « Komplett Ireland

  • @33 Dan

    In the Netherlands too, so most probably maintenance.

  • Xcel

    @ #33 by Dan

    TPB is offline everywhere atm…

    They’ll be back, they always come back..LoL

  • Rooty

    Yeh TPB has been off a while [cue nervous rumours]

  • nomis

    @11

    chris

    What on earth are you talking about you idiot?

  • TopN0tch

    Excellent point..

    “The focus should be on offering an outstanding product and user experience. Give consumers what they want, for a decent price”

    Piracy is a direct consequence of corruption in the media industry. The industry has been focusing more on money, than on making affordable quality products that is available to the general public.

    The industry must realize, that they cannot ignore the fact that everything digital can be pirated.

    This is NOT about piracy, this is about an industry that makes their OWN rules. They consider customers to be nothing more than “Consumer Units”.

    Dear Industry..
    Change your attitude and respect towards consumers, there is more to a successful business than just making money !!

  • anon

    For what it’s worth, e-books are not worth all the trouble. If you want to have a good read, do it old-school, pick up a damn hard cover. Why waste time, money and resources when all you need is the damn book. Plus that would help the print industry quite a bit if everybody used a proper book instead of that fancy gizmo e-book reader.

  • AnarchyNow

    It’s a one-tought world… they all want us to pay and pay till death everytime you read a book, ear a song, watch a movie, etc, it’s all the same : ZERO CHOICE, you have to pay even if you only “use” it one time!

    Btw, there is a (limited) digital edition of the Beatles remasters, as an USB apple, with all the remasters in 320 kpbs mp3s and also and above all, in 24 bit flacs, all WITHOUT ANY DRM…

  • MrGz0r

    what about L.J smith diffident she make any money off the deal, or did twlight bump everything because its over hiped!

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy « Rssfeedsdirectory's Blog

  • Shinho

    ‘perfect replications of the book in text format’ made me laugh

  • paperboy

    Paper Rules.

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy | We R Pirates

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy « My blog at Servage :)

  • Conan

    We shouldnot be surprised if major publishers see their sales dramatically decline in the future.

    It will happen as it happened in the music industry. Big guys donot see little ones or are too arrogant to see them.

    It is an eternal law of human nature. A better one will come and beat you down. Itunes killed HMV. Google is defeating Microsoft (who will have thought so 5 years ago)as themselves badly hurt IBM. and etc…

    I won’t be surprised if this website sunbookr.com with its new business model kills Amazon.

  • prodigydancer

    Stephenie Meyer is a dumb (un7, who writes total trash. I sincerely hope she’ll cancel all her future books by killing herself.

  • Benjamin

    Let’s not fool ourselves Ernesto.

    No amount of positive thinking og self-delusion will take away the fact that as long as there is electricity in the world people will download – everything and increasingly so.

    Mind you, I absolutelely agree with you: the media industry should make things better for us the consumers and spend hard earned money on bs companies that scare them into buying their junk anti-piracy ‘solutions’.

    But for that to happen they need to come to terms with the fact that every day a million or so customers leave their shop without paying for the stack of dvd’s they are carrying. Not only should the industry come to terms with this, they even have to liuke it!

    You can’t stop piracy, you can’t even minimize it, but if you inspire one or two pirates now and then to actually go and buy for an item one day, then you will have done the best anyone can hope for.

    I myself have been riding the torrents and sponging the net for anything digital for years and paid only my internet provider for that. Until recently, that is – when I went and bought the movie a CD in a shop. ‘Some People have real Problem’ by Sia Furler, an aussie singer. The CD is pure gold and I would never have come across it if it was’nt for the net and never bought it if not for the initial piracy I comitted.

    That kind, I am afraid, is the only good deal the industry will ever get from piracy. But if they started using that fact to their own end, the end will inevitably be very good for them.

  • Blaine

    It’s all the same thing…

    For the first time in history consumers have the ability to say “hey, this is not ok to constantly give me the bare minimum for my money. it’s not ok to intentionally load an album with “filler” songs on it, to extend the recording life of an artist and make them more profitable.”

    The consumer has the power now to force a company to actually provide a quality product, and it scares the crap out of them. and rightfully so imo.

    i think the consumers are simply saying, “stop raping me at the register, and ill stop raping u online. $50.00 to take my 2 kids to a movie is INSANE. bring that price back down to earth and charge a reasonable amount and people will be much happier to support your work. It is not each customers job to single handedly finance your children’s college education.

  • Ben Hurr

    I’d love to point out that piracy isn’t just about being cheap and getting things for free;
    it’s also about overcoming business and technical bullshit. <:

  • Blaine

    @FukPiratez

    you sir or madam are exactly the problem…

    I am assuming that you are a professor of some sort for a university or college.

    You are speaking of your projected sales for your book. But what would be your projected sales if you did not require the book you wrote to be the textbook for the class you teach, and that you are payed to teach?

    Lets be semi serious here for just a second please. I dont think i have ever seen a university textbook that costs under 120.00$. ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY DOLLARS!!!!! for a book. This is payed for by students who have little to no money to eat as it is. And for what? because you try to force them to purchase a book that you wrote. Come on sir, this surprises you?

    How on earth is this practice not only unethical (teaching students that the only correct answer to the subject is based on your research) but how is it not even a conflict of interest?

    It seems to me that the 700$ per class that my girlfriend pays is WAY more than a fair price to include a textbook.

  • Saddened

    I LOVE the posts like the “forget eBooks, they’ll remain irrelevant for a long time” (@23). Do you people live with your head in the sand? Amazon’s Kindle is currently the most gifted item in Amazon’s history. During Christmas Amazon managed to sell more ebooks than physical books. If you follow any tech sites like engadget, it seems like every other day there’s a new e-ink reader announced. Barnes & Noble has been pushing the hell outta the Nook even though it keeps getting delayed.

    Almost all the people who think reading on a digital device sucks have never actually held or tried to read from an e-ink device. They are just as easy or easier to read from than paper. Battery life on most of them is measured in days and sometimes even weeks. Yes, the price point is still too high for many people but that has also been steadily dropping.

    While I don’t think the potential for digital sales on books will ever reach the percent music is at, book publishers could very easily get this right if they wanted. They have a VERY clear roadmap on what will happen if they try to suppress, ignore, or limit the technology.

  • Benjamin

    I’m with you Blaine – on the whole college textbook industry-gate and on the whole…

    About rip-off at the movies: I once met a Disney rep. and during our conversation he jumped on me for my (very diplomatic) pro-piracy views. They feel very strong about this.

    Ok, so I suggested that he and uncle Walt put a ticket or voucher in every dvd I bought from the shop and in return I would indeed go to see a film in the cinema next time my son would tug at my sleeve in the direction and pay for the adult seat.

    Halv win but no double loss for Disney – everybody wins.

    All Im saying is give us more value for money, and we’ll consider…

  • Blaine

    @ Benjamin

    WHAT A GREAT IDEA about the movie ticket voucher.. first time i have heard that. now THAT is productive anti-piracy thinking.

  • MissedMemories

    Well. Two things, in pro of e-books: They don’t spend money (less pollution to the planet…) and if I’m not wrong you should be able to carry more than one with you.

    Now, back on the post:
    Books were created in a way that people could pass knowledge without having to be present.

    They evolved, became cheaper. Now they are used to pass stories created by someone, and enjoy the others. PEOPLE that fear getting it pirated is people that didn’t write for the joy of doing it, and that other people reads you, but rather for the MONEY.

    There are exceptions, is true. But I think: what matters is that you get enough to live okay and that as much people as possible can read it.

    Then, a good book will actually get you at two places at once: you get many people to read it (unless it has a certain public, but yet, can be used for study by teachers and blah blah blah), and will get you MONEY, since people will be willing to pay for it, since it is worth.

    It ends up being the same for music, games, applications and anything else. IF it is good quality, even if it is pirated, you’ll get money, and make people happy; just don’t come up with stupid protections or measures.

  • me3p0

    I don’t believe that stopping piracy is the real reason behind all these “mistakes” though it may be the core reason but it certainly seems more likely to me that it is, in most cases, a matter of the publishers or executives or even insecure authors wanting to make sure they did everything in their power to protect their intellectual property.

    If they do nothing and they lose 10,000 sales/copies then they will think “we could have done more”; however if they impose DRM or other methods at IP protection and they still lose 10,000 sales/copies, then they will be able to think “at least we did all we could to try and stop it from happening”.

    I think that this is the real motivation, especially for publishers and executives because then they can be “seen” to be doing something other than making money.

  • Aerilus

    I have seen book prices more than double in the last ten years, the latest Robert Jordan I just bought after downloading it was over 30 dollars. Every time I go into a barnes and nobles I am shocked at the prices they want 12 dollars for a paper back when they used to be 5. The only thing more shocking is going into a college book store and them wanting 200-300 dollars for a book. I am simply not paying what I consider outrageous prices just as I am not going to pay 20 dollars for a cd or 50 for a game I do not download often I ussually wait to buy things used or on sale but prices on these thing are ridiculous and pirating will continue to be a problem until the cost to consumers reflects a realistic manufacturing cost. I think I can sadly say this just by looking at the cost if electronics where fierce competition has driven there cost to reasonable prices to consumers over the last few years.

  • Hummy

    It’s inevitable and a real shame that the publishers will go much the same way the music industry has. We just have to hold hope that someday we’ll figure out a way to make all this work that suits everybody.

    http://www.hoponbaby.com/

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy - News from the technology world - Technology News

  • ghost

    boo hoo hoo

  • Been Here Before

    @31 “They’ll rehash the BS about how they buy more books because they stole your book. Too bad it wasn’t your book among those they bought.”

    You know, all the sarcasm and finger-wagging you can muster isn’t going to put more money in my pocket. I’ve got about $5 to $15 a month to spend on media entertainment (books, movies, music, games) for myself. That isn’t going to change no matter how guilty you try to make me feel. Even when my income increases, I’m always going to be seeking the best value for my money. If I can buy one new item or a couple of secondhand items from those categories, and obtain from unauthorized distributors good-enough copies of 100 other things that I’ll never afford, then that’s what I’m going to do. You can consider it theft or a lost sale, but that doesn’t change the fact that I only have a couple hundred dollars of disposable income per year, tops, and that if you didn’t get any of it, then you failed to compete with all the other things that I spent that money on. This is the reality you need to wrap your head around. Consumers do not have infinitely deep pockets, and they have more forms of entertainment competing for their disposable income than ever.

  • voracious reader

    @63 That’s it in a nutshell!

  • C

    I wish someone had leaked the Twilight books early. How rockin’ would that be; a world without Twilight.

  • a Book Worm

    I’ve got the Sony PRS-505 and love the thing. I can have hundreds of books with me anywhere I go, as I tend to read multiple books at the same time. I have always been an avid book reader and have bought thousands of books over the years, but now, as was pointed out earlier, book prices have gone through the roof for a hard copy and digital books are an even worse raping.

    How do they justify the prices they charge for a digital book when the file they send to the printer is digital already and would need very little reformatting to fit an ebook. If they were to include a voucher for a hard copy with a digital download for that 12 to 15 dollar and up in “special editions” price, then I would purchase more.

    However publishers have modeled their business plan after the other media whores and will suffer the same fate as them if they are not careful. Until they change their pricing, I will download and convert to my format whatever books I want.

    There are plenty of free software tools to convert txt, html, pdf, and many other formats to whatever type is needed. One of the best is Calibre, the dev is very open to suggestions and is quite friendly on his forum.

  • Anonymous

    @31

    Of your entire post, this is the most ridiculous bit:

    My textbook is already pirated on the internet, and I can tell you it has had a significant effect on my projected sales. My own students bring pirated versions to class. Luckily, I don’t have to live off those sales.

    How dare those dirt-poor college students learn for free by circumventing a highly exploitive industry!

  • Anon

    “FukPirates” wrote:

    “They’ll blame it on greedy corporations because they don’t understand how the book advance system works just as they don’t understand how record companies front the initial money for music production, distribution, and advertising.”

    Sorry. I understand both systems completely. Both systems are dead. Largely because the “initial money” is now irrelevant — music production is done at home; book authors generally get their advances *after* they write large hunks of the book; distribution costs nothing (OK, maybe $1000/yr max) on the Internet.

    That leaves advertising. Hire a fucking ad agency.

    “They’ll rehash the BS about how they buy more books because they stole your book.”
    They didn’t steal anything. You still have your copy of your book, don’t you? Yes, yes you do. Nothing was stolen.

    “Too bad it wasn’t your book among those they bought.”
    Well, because your book was crap and not worth paying for, perhaps?

    “The library metaphor isn’t apt. When you are done with a library-loaned object, you are supposed to return it.”
    Whatever. People have been Xeroxing library books since the Xerox was invented.

    “My textbook is already pirated on the internet, and I can tell you it has had a significant effect on my projected sales.”
    You’re in an especially broken market. Textbooks are vastly overpriced and most students would not buy them unless forced to. If they can avoid buying them, they simply don’t, and that’s always been the case — they borrow the library copy for the term if they have to. If your textbook were (a) any good, and (b) priced reasonably, they would actually buy it.

    “My own students bring pirated versions to class.”
    Good for them.

    “Luckily, I don’t have to live off those sales.”
    Nobody lives off textbook sales. Absolutely nobody. In fact, most textbook authors *don’t write textbooks to make money off sales*. You write them because you’re sick and tired of the crap textbooks you have available and you want a better textbook for your class. So in fact this is a case where the authors *do not need to be compensated at all, and will write the books for free*.

    Wow. Amazing levels of delusion continue to survive.

  • Anon

    If they do nothing and they lose 10,000 sales/copies then they will think “we could have done more”; however if they impose DRM or other methods at IP protection and they still lose 10,000 sales/copies, then they will be able to think “at least we did all we could to try and stop it from happening”.

    I think that this is the real motivation, especially for publishers and executives because then they can be “seen” to be doing something other than making money.

    You got it. It’s very similar to the “security theater” at the airports — the desire is to *appear* to be doing something. Whether it actually has a positive effect, they don’t really care.

  • Anon

    “Piracy is a direct consequence of corruption in the media industry. The industry has been focusing more on money, than on making affordable quality products that is available to the general public.”

    This cannot be overstated. I go out of my way to buy (sometimes multiple copies of) really high-quality releases with *care* taken.

    Shoddy crap — cut versions of movies, sound-distorted music albums, etc. — is so common that I have to go to downloads in order to *find* high-quality, uncut copies of classics. Releasing damaged, trashed copies isn’t going to encourage me to buy from the copyright holders.

    Even *textbooks* do this. The “later editions” of most textbooks are worse than the first edition. They’re designed to shuffle the chapters and page references around from earlier ones so that students have to buy a new textbook instead of buying last year’s textbook from last year’s students. They’re *trash* and used bookstores are the place to find a good textbook, but of course it’s hard to find enough copies to equip an entire class, so professors use the “new edition”.

    Downloading can change that, and I predict that freely-licensed textbooks will take over all scientific fields within 10 years.

  • Bryan Elliott

    Sony’s got some Adobe-style DRM on their EPUB’s. Takes about two seconds to remove, once you find the right python scripts.

    Mind you, I’m forced to go through that effort, as the DRM would otherwise lock me to my current Sony eReader. I don’t expect this one to last much longer than the previous one – about two years before the fragile, needlessly glass screen cracked.

    With that eReader (BeBook), it was MobiDeDRM for PDB/MOBI/AZW books, rather than Inept for EPUBs.

    Besides that (and because) eReaders are a combination of expensive and fragile, I like to take books out of the house on my phone, leaving the delicate e-paper device at home. DRM prevents that, and therefore, must go.

    Anyway, I’ll be keeping an archive of my decrypted, converted* eBooks backed up in a various places.

    * to EPUB; looks like it’s the most widely supported: 20 of 26 eReaders support it, and almost all new publications are available in EPUB format.

  • Anonymous

    Just wait until the “ipod” of e-readers becomes available. Or wait for tablets to go mainstream…
    Book piracy will skyrocket. It’s the lack of decent reading hardware that’s keeping book piracy down. That’s really all there is to it.

  • Pingback: Top 10 Pirated eBooks (Summer Version) « Taylor Bright

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy – FUCK THE RIAA

  • Pingback: P2P, Copyright, Creative Commons e Net Neutrality, brevi news di inizio 2010 « YBlog

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy @ blog.idtorrent.org

  • Pingback: Doombin - Tablets Armor and more | Doomkopf.com

  • GloriaRoberts

    The biggest BS is, “If I like my pirated book, I’ll buy it.” You thieves won’t buy didly squat. So stop trying to justify thievery.

  • Pingback: Money Expert: Industry Should Compete With Music Piracy | InstantIdiocy

  • Pingback: Kindle Owners Get Back At Publisher For Holding Off On Digital Edition | The Kindle Warehouse

  • spurious

    I have written a book that’s been pirated. The book sells for $20 hardcover–hardly expensive!
    It took my FIVE YEARS to write that book. I’ve made about 5 cents an hour in money from it, and it will never come close to paying the expenses and time I put in.
    To those people that say “information should be free”… the trouble is,it costs a hell of a lot of time and money to make that information.
    You’re pirating a twenty dollar book so I have to keep living in poverty so you can buy more beer on the weekend. You’re not pirating because it’s a $200 text book for a course you can’t afford.
    You want to pirate a JK Rowling or a Stephen King? You know what, they’re not even going to NOTICE the difference on their paycheck. But think twice about pirating technical manuals and research books, because these take a hell of a lot of time for very little pay-off as it is. We’ll just stop writing them if they make no money at all.

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • The Pirate Bay Isn’t Down Completely, Just Having a Few Issues

    Twitter and Facebook, not to mention the TorrentFreak inbox, are currently alive with complaints that The...

  • Pirate Bay Founder Gottfrid Svartholm on Freedom of Speech

    Freedom of speech is a highly valued commodity, but should people be allowed to say whatever...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.