TorrentFreak

The place where breaking news, BitTorrent and copyright collide

Wii Super Mario Bros. Pirate Settles for $1.3 Million

A man who uploaded Super Mario Bros. for the Wii before its commercial release has agreed to settle with Nintendo. The 24 year-old, who uploaded the game to the Internet in November 2009, has agreed to pay the games giant $1.3m in damages.

The Federal Court in Australia has ordered a man from Queensland to pay Nintendo the equivalent of $1.3m in damages after he uploaded the Wii version of New Super Mario Bros. to the Internet in late 2009.

James Burt, a 24 year-old manager at games retailer Electronics Boutique, admitted uploading the game on November 6th, a week before its commercial release in Australia.

In a statement the Japanese games giant said it used a range of forensic techniques to track down the uploader and on 23rd November obtained a Federal Court search order. This was used to locate and seize items from Burt’s property in Sinnamon Park, Queensland, to be used in evidence in the case against him.

As part of the investigation, Burt was also ordered to allow access using his passwords to social networking sites, email accounts and other websites he had used.

Australia traditionally lags behind the United States and Japan when it comes to media releases, but with the release of New Super Mario Bros. for the Wii the reverse was true, leading Nintendo to refer to the leak as a “global issue”.

“This legal proceeding was commenced to protect the creative rights and innovation of game developers, and to combat the growing international problem of Internet piracy,” the company said in a statement.

The game was a sure fire hit on BitTorrent. Data collected by TorrentFreak indicated that by December 27th 2009, the game had been downloaded 1,150,000 times.

Nevertheless, the game was still a huge commercial success. The game sold in excess of 10 million units in its first 2 months on sale – that’s 1 in 6 of all Wii gamers buying a copy – making it the fastest-selling single-platform game ever.

It’s unclear how Mr Burt will be able to pay this huge amount in damages. His salary at Electronics Boutique is unlikely to cover it – if he still has a job there.

Related Posts

Previous Post | Next Post

  • nrgz

    how can they track the person from torrent?

  • 2in

    Aged 10 years in 2 months, that must have been very stressful!

  • arg

    When will people learn to use seedboxes when you pirate something like that…

  • oh boi

    how’s he gonna pay that amount ? leave the poor boy alone. what you say guys ?

  • A Noni Mouse

    How did they get his passwords is more what I’m interest to know. O.o

  • Kai

    Did he even use BitTorrent to distribute it? Other news outlets in Australia are reporting he uploaded it to “his website.”

  • Anonymoose

    Blurb says he’s 24. Article says he’s 34. So which is it?

    TF: 24, my typo, apologies

  • Anonymous

    “Burt was also ordered to allow access using his passwords to social networking sites, email accounts and other websites he had used.”

    thank god for the USA where you don’t have to provide self incriminating evidence.

  • aerilus

    “Burt was also ordered to allow access using his passwords to social networking sites, email accounts and other websites he had used.”

    thank god for the USA where you don’t have to provide self incriminating evidence.

  • Rocky

    @8 nice try buddy, but USA has the Patriot Act where you can do almost anything you can, including getting passwords.

  • Anonymous

    @10
    lol

  • anon

    As much as it may suck for him…people shouldn’t mess around with this kind of stuff if they don’t know how to handle their own privacy

  • Pingback: Pirate Home Page » Wii Super Mario Bros. Pirate Settles for $1.3 Million

  • AnarchyNow

    I’m glad not to pay 50€ for such a shitty ’80s game.

  • Right Said Fred

    @11 by anon

    You are absolutely right!!! Play with fire and you’ll get burned!

    Smarten up N00Bs… read more and learn.

  • Spaniard

    “a range of forensic techniques to track down the uploader”?. Bwahahahahaha. The idiot was boasting about it in the forums!.

    And that thing about releasing the passwords.. omg, I’d have deleted them all before doing it. If you already have a $1.3 settlement, it can’t get much worse.

  • prodigydancer

    I wasn’t aware that Australia is SO horribly underdeveloped that courts can get away with such “decisions.” Basically it’s “we don’t care about privacy or proof or anything.”

  • blackjesus@1337x.org

    I wonder if he took any measures to protect himself Vpn,seedbox,pc encrypted,ect or if he just uploaded from home would be interesting to hear what these forensic techniques were.

    But either way $1.3 million sucks balls i feel sorry for him

  • Cujo

    1.3m ,, ridiculous ,, u might as well try drawing blood from a stone

  • Brandon

    Upload Crappy Nintendo Wii Game… Even worse the worse game EVER… Brag to ya buds in forums… Spending the rest of your life trying to pay 1.3m… Priceless…

  • Anonymous

    He’ll never have to pay that fine, unless Australia decides to bring back debtor’s prisons.

  • what the

    Destroying a mans life for a super mario game?

    wow

  • annon

    He will claim bankruptcy and he is off the hook…

    As for USA Patriot Act I doubt it can be used in cases such as this, probably only good for criminal/terrorist cases, not civil law suites like this.

  • deadbeat

    you don’t get off the hook if you claim bankruptcy in Australia.

  • jon

    yes as long as you rent and dont own anything of value or sell first and then claim bankruptcy dont give them a cent lol

  • Doctorjab

    How’s he going to pay?

    Simple, the minimum ruling in any given case is 1 cent per day payment. If he lives to 84, that’s about 21,900 cents or $219. I suppose his family will probably inherit the debt though.

    Regardless, its essentially a case of making an example.

    Probably not a good idea to be involved in such things if you actually work for a games retailer!

  • truth

    truth is he does not have to pay the fee as long as he keeps secret about his deal with nintendo to accept the ruling .. so they have a good story to frighten people

  • Pingback: Wii Super Mario Bros. Pirate Settles for $1.3 Million - 8761th | PSP WII Latest Games Movies Music Resource

  • Pingback: Wii Super Mario Bros. Pirate Settles for $1.3 Million - 8773th | PSP WII Latest Games Movies Music Resource

  • Anonymous

    @ 24 truth

    loll y most likely.. just to scare people :S

  • Voice of History

    Every store work must sign a contract, stating that no games shall be sold before release date. He AGREED to that, and now he is toast. Nothing new, Nintendo should sue anyone that do such things. The value ammounts to a scare tactic, and has nothing to do with the damages caused, and ALSO has nothing to do with the piracy per se, just with the early release.

  • Tina

    not like Nintendo are ever gonna see the cash .. he declares himself bankrupt and gets rehabilitated in 3 years and nothing has changed except Nintendo feel like complete NOBS

    corporate wankers

  • James Burt

    anyone no a way to pay for a usenet account anonymously or a usenet that accepts paysafecard.

  • Steve

    if Nintendo value their product so highly why they don’t protect it with effective DRM?

    … because it aint worth their trouble is why. all the big beef at Nintendo could not forsee this happening? much more fun for Nintendo to beat up on the poor average guy on the street, Nintendo designed their own EPIC FAIL

  • Macci

    If anyone has his e-mail post-it so i can shake his hand who cares about nintendo anyways?

  • The Original Oogy Boogy

    @25
    “I suppose his family will probably inherit the debt though.”

    Actually, in most democracies, family can not inherit debt they haven’t signed into- so this guy’s family will be just fine if he kills himself which he’ll probably do since they’ve raped his life away anyway.

  • idiots

    If youre convicted of a crime you HAVE to pay it(or as much as you can for the rest of your life).
    bankruptcy won’t dissolve the dept.

  • Will

    If I was him, I’d firebomb Nintedo Australia.

  • Bankrupt

    That is a Federal Court of Australia decision, the amount is damages awarded to a third party, he will declare himself bankrupt and nothing will happen.

    The interesting part of the story is how Nintendo et al traced him down and then searched his property and seized his computer equipment. Also the post says he was required to provide his passwords to various sites – that is worrying. Anybody have more on that?

  • Trelew

    This ex-manager screwed up by breaking a contract that these stores have with releasing product before a date. It was just bonus that Nintendo managed to spin this into another tirade on internet file sharing. The only reason the amount was so damn high was that the corporates needed their scapegoat for the media to show the public what happens when they don’t do what they are told to do.

  • KloWn

    It’s called a seedbox and a FTP client, learn to use them

  • Anonymous

    He’ll be fine.
    Declare Bankruptcy, have a few years of difficulty if you’re going to buy a house or car…not have to pay anything.

    Silly Nintendo.

  • hi

    no the reason it is so high is because the courts allow it to be that high. When you sue, you sue for the maximum amount you can.

  • Nizzy

    @31 most likely because ‘effective DRM’ doesn’t exist. Those 2 words should never be in the same sentence.

  • Reasoned Mind

    All I can say is “I TOLD YOU SO!”

    LOL

  • Anonymous

    Ok, so it sounds like this guy didn’t really kno enough about what he was getting himself into. Still feel sorry for him though.

  • Its Emil

    I find it hard to believe nintendo lost financially over the early online release.
    Anyone who downloaded the game before the official release was probably going to Pirate it after it was released anyway

  • Pingback: Where to watch Super Bowl XLIV | Cheap TV HD and HDTV Reviews

  • Pilgrimman

    @ 43

    Exactly.

    Most anyone who even keeps track of release dates more than likely has the knowledge to pirate the game.

  • OMG

    wow, how much damage to the individual who downloads the game? BTW, I bought my copy.

  • GP

    Maybe if Nintendo weren’t so fucking stupid by creating artificial delays, and just released the product at the same time in every country, they wouldn’t have had this problem…

  • John

    Everybody who downloaded this game illegally should pay this guy $1. Problem solved :)

  • Software

    I’ve read about software that was developed to determine the original seeder of a swarm. I think it was in Japan or somewhere in the area, but it does need to be a swarm that is fairly new. They can’t wait a month then use it.

  • .

    Well
    Let’s look at this sensibly:-
    * He broke his Employers’ trust by stealing the game from them and not acting in accordance with his contract.
    *Destroyed his credibiity of his fellow Employees.
    *He didn’t care for Nintendo’s right to their own product, why should he have any right to privacy on his sites? You reap what you sew!
    *Fines shouldn’t be related to how much you can pay. This kind of stupidity lead to people with small amounts of wealth being fined £1000 for dropping a crisp packet in the street.
    *Declaring bankruptcy is not the easy option it may appear -that action could haunt him for life and make future employment very very difficult.
    * The level of fine is also a warning to others.
    *If it was pirated after release, that is irrelevant, by uploading before release it denies an opportunity to the developers. They need to set a “warning” fine to others. Yes a lot of peoplealso bought it, but many Wii owners aren’t that Tech savvy are they? But pre-releases on other platforms could well destroy incomes – and if that continues unabated. YES WE DO KNOW 1 DL DOES NOT EQUAL 1 LOST SALE, so PLEASE Don’t say it again… WE KNOW. But you can’t seriously say that pre-release didn’t affect sales, esp early buyers who are tech-savvy.
    Think on… if everybody dloaded it=nobody bought it…no money, let alone profit(which equals future funding for future games), then NO MORE GAMES, then you cant PIRATE it.

    So why do you feel sorry for the guy.
    He’s a stupid criminal who got caught.
    He’s a guy on the street, how does this give him the right to rip off Nintendo?
    Who cares about Nintendo? Well who cares about Sony and MiniHard? But if you can’t dload ya games what ya gonna do, go out and play footie in the park, esp with all those Rapists and muggers out there the Police/Lawyers SHOULD be concentrating on?

    Destroying a mans life for Mario game???? NO??? Oh well, presumably, Nintendo should have shook his hand?, thanked him for helping distribute their game?, making it more widely known? Providing FREE(?)PUBLICITY???? given him a job in Internet Content Distribution Marketing ?
    Let him off and told him he’s a naughty boy and not do it again?

  • Nemo

    @49
    It looks like you listed all likely and contradictory opinions on this matter in one post. But what was your point?

  • diggler

    will people ever shut up about seedboxes! They ARE NOT anonymous. each has a ip like any other internet connection – shared ones are just that, shared. But there is a money trail from the, say, 20 people that share it….and each one of those has a connection to that seedbox, logged-on connection, recorded of course. Stored forever. That is YOUR real ip address mate. Even if you connect with a vpn, if you paid for your seedbox they can trace you eventually.

  • Reasoned Mind

    What has happened here is prevalence of someone that broke the law under the circumstances of his country and he got caught. Its no different then what happens in the United States.

    He settled with Nintendo, doing the right thing and admitting that yes he has been caught uploading copyright material and has settled with them for his actions.

    The only people seeing things wrong with this are the ones that dont realize that uploading hurts the game companies that need that money and that lest you agree with it or not, its still wrong.

  • A

    it’s just a silly game

  • Pingback: Australian Pirate Settles for $1.3 Million with Nintendo over Wii Super Mario Bros.

  • Dia

    It’s a wii game! What the fuck was he thinking!

  • Unseasoned Dime

    What’s a silly game? copyright theft or Mario?

  • RoestVrijStaal

    What is the reason to prerelease something? What do you have to win with it? I even wait a month / year(s) to buy a game, to give the developers the time to kill all the bugs. ( And the dropped price :3 )

    Sorry to say this, but that guy had only asked for it.

    @53: TRUE

  • Baby Plaz

    1.3 Million? Hey, no trouble– a piss in the bucket. Hell we all have at least half a mill in pocket-change, right?

  • Champnos

    One in 6 bought the game anyway, wheres the loss? People who probably pirated it either a. were never going to buy it anyway b. went out and got it if they liked it. People dont seem to get it. If the game was available why not release it immediately? Why do films take years to go to dvd? surely a month in the cinema is enough! Why is music cd’s still ridiculasly priced?

    Sucha flawed industry right now forces people to pirate. Id almost say its their fault!

    BTW – I have never had a refund when ive paid for a watched a crap film, so i have to pay for something that does not work? if it was a car i would have a full refund, now thats why i feel i have to pirate, i will watch in cinema if i like something!

  • Anonymous

    “thank god for the USA where you don’t have to provide self incriminating evidence.”

    Bit of correction: in a criminal case you can plead the fifth. This would have been a civil case and thus would not have been subject to that.

  • truth spoken

    Got what he deserved. Distributing a pre release is a big business problem. He could have waited for it to be released but wanted the kudos. Now he’s paid for it.
    Going for the Kudos is all part of the risk.
    If you can’t do the time , don’t do the crime.

  • Bobe-On

    The world has changed and will continue to change, despite some of our stupidity, greed, ignorance, arrogance or whatever you want to include/call it.

    Information-sharing is the correct way to go. It is part of the laws of nature. Simple.

    Illegalizing file sharing is wrong. Simple.

    Some of us have adapted.

  • Artificial Energy

    @15

    even if he deleted all his social networking accounts, their servers keep backup copies for a certain amount of time. so it may not be accessible to the general public, but the company that owns the site will still have a copy of it and all Nintendo would have to do is go through them.

  • Ninja

    And it was still a huge success… Where’s the point in suing then?

    In any case, he is probably not paying that amount so Nintendo loses, which is sweet even though the guy is kinda screwed =/

  • Jagger

    As part of the investigation, Burt was also ordered to allow access using his passwords to social networking sites, email accounts and other websites he had used.

    This is why pirates need to avoid Facebook.
    You leave one comment for a friend about your lucky loot, and then 100,000 people find out about it on their Facebook homepage updates.

  • null

    You can emulate the Wii on pc? Then download the games for FREE? I’ve been buying this s”"” for years!
    Thank you (MSNBC, CNN, FOX, ETC.) For informing numerous souls to just one of the many advantage of the joining the Darkside. They’ve just created a million more seaman, More than even they could possibly swallow…. Muahahhahahhaa

  • paul

    @33

    I guess you’ve never heard of community property then?

    You don’t need to sign anything to get your share of debts incurred during a community property eligible relationship.

  • paul

    Why is my comment awaiting moderation? I didn’t post any links or cusses ????

  • auda

    as australian, this really is chilling, that a company can basically ruin a person’s life for something this small

  • paul

    lol if you mention the words “sign” and “debt” you get moderated.

    Amazing censorship and a big huge f***ing fail in stopping spam here, honestly…. if you have to start targeting phrases we would probably utter in the normal course of things, the spammers have won.

  • Obedient

    Let me guess: this guy just uploaded from his home computer without using a VPN or a proxy!
    DUMB!
    And no! I don’t think he has a job anymore.

  • Traum

    Ah, who cares if(pi) its 1. 000. 000, 00 or ½ million cant pay anyway. It´s just good reason to stop working and start living with others money… (who can?)

  • krane

    No sane man will ever pay such an obscene amount.

  • slava!

    This is exactly why I wouldn’t buy a game. Not because I can download it for free but because of the mafia this business is.

  • Ololz

    As soon as I get enough money, I’m taking myself out of this stupid censor-happy country.

  • Jack

    LOL

    Why do people think that just because a proxy lets the remote side see a differnt ip it cant be traced back?

    Sure some of them are in Russia or china and getting the logs from them might take a bit of doing..

    But common, you REALLY think they cant come back if they REALLY wanted to.

    Remember they just put 1.3 million in a slush fund to do just that :-P

    PS: FTPs have logs to:-P

  • RAPE RAPE RAPE

    It’s called multiple proxies; route through a Russian based proxy, then a Chinese based one, then an Iranian proxy, and then a Malaysian proxy before anonymously posting to Usenet and forgetting anything ever happened :P

  • Anonymous

    @50 no profit no games, some of us do do a try before you buy.

  • Noip

    Poor guy. Hope he is able to free himself from this horrible claim. If Nintendo is not able to have people buy their stuff instead of downloading it for free, it is their fault.

  • Bobe-On (Go Local)

    Declare personal bankruptcy. Buying on credit for many is a losing proposition anyway, except for the credit card companies and creditors of course. Banks own many of our asses. Avoid the banks when at all possible.

    Another idea is to join a barter and/or own-currency and/or “deliberate community” group. Check out Saltspring Island in BC, Canada. They have their own currency.

    When you share/trade locally, any dubious distant “creditor” acting on its own laws and currencies, etc., can go take a flying fuck.

    While sharing is caring, so is it locally. :) REAL community rocks.

    Chill with your “homies”. :)

  • IGP

    I don’t know this guy personally but I know exactly how they tracked him down: he was the head admin of the now defunct Wii soft-modding/guide site http://yafaze.com/. Specifically, he was caught because of his poor judgment. He took full credit (including even pictures/screenshots) of his deed (aka leaking the game). IMO his downfall was due to the blatant lack of thought on his part. If you are going to do something illegal, don’t advertise it to the world.

  • cando22

    @50… Dude, Nobody asked you to write a manifesto.. put down the pipe and stop gulping black coffee..the article said “the game was still a huge commercial success. The game sold in excess of 10 million units in its first 2 months on sale – that’s 1 in 6 of all Wii gamers buying a copy – making it the fastest-selling single-platform game ever.”

  • Pingback: Hohe Geldstrafe für Wii-Spiel-Uploader - Die Achtundvierzig

  • .

    @82
    Yes I read the article, who asked for your opinion on coffee and ??pipes??
    How many units it sold is irrelevant
    You misunderstood the underlying point
    Oh well

  • Anonymous

    wow… i guess ill never use torrent now.. im happy with my windows pinball =S

  • nabs

    Feel sorry for the guy.

    But in the US, you only get sued for 150,000 max :P But 250,000 if it’s criminal, which I think he would have got. But it’s just a damn game, and ruining his life isn’t good. He can’t pay anyway so give him another 5 million. Who would care? File bankruptcy.

  • damn

    Let us know where to send money for this kid!! He’s a KID! Everyone who’s downloading anything owes him a little something. Well, not that we really OWE him, but he’s fighting our fight. We SHOULD try to help!!

  • NubCakes

    “will people ever shut up about seedboxes! They ARE NOT anonymous. each has a ip like any other internet connection – shared ones are just that, shared. But there is a money trail from the, say, 20 people that share it….and each one of those has a connection to that seedbox, logged-on connection, recorded of course. Stored forever. That is YOUR real ip address mate. Even if you connect with a vpn, if you paid for your seedbox they can trace you eventually.”

    Seeing as your apparently some m0r0n who hasn’t used seedboxes let alone understand hosting or servers whatsoever – and feels some strong compulsion to let everyone know how knowledgeable you are probably caused by jealousy because you’ve linked part of your ego to appearing “tech savvy”, let me explain.

    Seedbox providers don’t pass on IP addresses of their users – although they recieve many infringement notices. There hasn’t been a single precedent for any company handing over this infomation to any body, voluntarily or court-ordered.

    And actually I’m pretty sure they same is true of any VPN.

    In effect they are anonymous until such time as they start to hand over IP details.

    So why don’t you stop telling us how smart you think you are (believe it or not most seedbox users already knew that servers had IP addresses you fool) and also stop trying to inform people of your amazing knowledge in this area which you’ve never even used judging by your pitiful analysis.

  • Me

    wow you guys are a buncha tools, why would you feel bad for the guy? he did it and then bragged about it he got what he had comin to him, and as for nintendo suein, damn right htey should, if you are going to act like an idiot you get whats comin which this guy did.

  • Pingback: Nintendo finds revenues other ways - Page 3

  • Pingback: Super Mario World Cartoon Intro | Nintendo Videos

  • Pingback: Super Mario Bros 3 Commercial | Nintendo Videos

  • Pingback: Mario Party 2 Commercial | Nintendo Videos

  • Pingback: Mario Party 5 Commercial | Nintendo Videos

  • Pingback: Nintendo Wins R4 lawsuit!!!

  • Pingback: Nintendo nabs the Aussie who released NSMB for A$1.5 million

  • Anonymous

    He boasted about it on GBAtemp and uploaded a picture of the recipt with with his name on it. That is how he got caught.

    http://gbatemp.net/index.php?showtopic=207955

  • Pingback: Super Mario Bros Wii Commercial | Nintendo Videos

  • Pingback: Super Mario Bros Push Pins | Nintendo Photos

  • BTGuard - BitTorrent Anonymously

NewsBits

Even more news...

  • Blu-ray Anti-Piracy Tech Stops Discs and Promotes Purchases

    An anti-piracy system present in all official Blu-ray players since 2012 has received a fresh update...

  • Foxtel Breeds Pirates by Locking Up Game of Thrones

    One of the main reasons why people turn to piracy is the lack of legal alternatives....

  • UK Student Admits Breaching Sony Copyrights With Leak of PS3 SDK

    Last year an Internet user known as El Nomeo leaked version 3.70 of Sony’s Playstation3 SDK...

  • Pirates Can Be Identified Despite Sharing IP Addresses, ISP Claims

    Carrier-Grade Network Address Translation is a network mechanism through which many Internet subscribers can share the...

  • Feds Seize Cash from Major Bitcoin Exchange’s Dwolla Account

    The U.S. Government has taken a significant action against the web’s top Bitcoin exchange by seizing...

MostDiscussed

Below are TorrentFreak's most discussed articles of the past month. Join the discussion if you like.

CopyQuote

Left Quote

“The Pirate Bay has been one of the most important movements in Sweden for freedom of speech, working against corruption and censorship.

Peter Sunde Left Quote

PopularArticles

A selection of some TorrentFreak's classics dug up from our archives.